[SOLVED] MPB4,1/MBA 'wait status failed: c != 8' solved?

**kosumi68** · March 14th, 2010

Originally Posted by hyperboloid

Here is a very weird thing. The script "applesmc-test.sh" produced some errors when I first ran it, and then when I ran it again after some time had passed, it seemed to work again. Same with the script "scan-smc.sh" which gave an infinite loop of error messages (something about "0: #KEY [4-ui32]" over and over) at first, then ran OK later. I did nothing in between except browse the forums.

I'm attaching the outputs from these scripts after they started working.

The reading of the SMC registers never was an exact science, and reading errors are still normal. By the look of it, you have a tiny but non-zero fail ratio on your machine, resulting in the test script sometimes reporting no errors, sometimes some errors. Nothing to worry about, as long as it seems to operate normally.

**m.prebble** · April 26th, 2010

Hi guys,

I have a MBP 5,4, and have problems with the SMC not regulating the fan temperature. After digging through various forums, I have only found people having the same issue. For others, they have no problem. This is very frustrating, as I can't rely on thermal mgmt when using Linux - I am afraid to come back and find the a rogue app has cooked my CPU.

I have followed the steps in the top of this forum. Please find the output of this attached:

Code:

0: #KEY [4-ui32] 00000134 [...4]
1: $Adr [4-ui32] 00000300 [....]
2: $Num [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
3: +LKS [1-flag] 07 [.]
4: ACCL [1-ui8 ]
5: ACEN [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
6: ACFP [1-flag] 01 [.]
7: ACIC [2-ui16] 0e10 [..]
8: ACID [8-ch8*] 8598d028c00310e7 [...(....]
9: ACIN [1-flag] 01 [.]
10: ACLM [1-ui8 ] 55 [U]
11: AL! [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
12: ALA0 [6-{ala] ca1effd602d9 [......]
13: ALA1 [6-{ala] 30a4021f0315 [0.....]
14: ALA2 [6-{ala] 0cea02d40396 [......]
15: ALA3 [6-{ala] 0389036103dc [...a..]
16: ALA4 [6-{ala] 00ee03bc0400 [......]
17: ALA5 [6-{ala] 04fcfff30400 [......]
18: ALAT [4-{alt] 002b0308 [.+..]
19: ALI0 [4-{ali] 04000f00 [....]
20: ALI1 [4-{ali] 00000000 [....]
21: ALP0 [4-ui16] 13330780 [.3..]
22: ALP1 [4-ui16] 00000000 [....]
23: ALRV [2-ui16] 0001 [..]
24: ALSC [16-{alc] 00c8009603e8000f0001015e1d030106 [...........^....]
25: ALSF [2-fp1f] 4b44 [KD]
26: ALSL [2-ui16] 004d [.M]
27: ALT0 [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
28: ALT1 [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
29: ALTH [10-{alr] 00320070025200140041 [.2.p.R...A]
30: ALV0 [10-{alv] 010102ed01990013466a [........Fj]
31: ALV1 [10-{alv] 00010000000000000000 [..........]
32: AUPO [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
33: B0AC [2-si16] 0000 [..]
34: B0AV [2-ui16] 3097 [0.]
35: B0Ad [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
36: B0Al [2-ui16] ffff [..]
37: B0Am [1-ui8 ] 10 [.]
38: B0Ar [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
39: B0As [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
40: B0At [2-ui16] 0960 [.`]
41: B0Au [2-ui16] 0960 [.`]
42: B0Az [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
43: B0BI [1-ui8 ] 51 [Q]
44: B0CM [2-ui16] 0119 [..]
45: B0CT [2-ui16] 0060 [.`]
46: B0FC [2-ui16] 1958 [.X]
47: B0FV [2-ui16] 0003 [..]
48: B0LI [2-ui16] 7fff [..]
49: B0PS [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
50: B0RI [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
51: B0RM [2-ui16] 18e3 [..]
52: B0SN [13-ch8*] 57303932364245373737375641 [W0926BE7777VA]
53: B0St [2-ui16] 40e0 [@.]
54: B0TF [2-ui16] ffff [..]
55: BATP [1-flag] 00 [.]
56: BBAD [1-flag] 00 [.]
57: BBIN [1-flag] 01 [.]
58: BC1V [2-ui16] 1032 [.2]
59: BC2V [2-ui16] 1033 [.3]
60: BC3V [2-ui16] 1031 [.1]
61: BCHA [1-ui8 ] 02 [.]
62: BCHB [1-ui8 ] 06 [.]
63: BCHF [1-ui8 ]
64: BCHG [1-ui8 ]
65: BCHL [1-ui8 ]
66: BCHO [1-ui8 ] 1f [.]
67: BCHP [1-ui8 ] 13 [.]
68: BCHR [1-ui8 ] 3a [:]
69: BCHT [1-ui8 ] 06 [.]
70: BCHX [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
71: BCLM [1-ui8 ] 64 [d]
72: BEZL [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
73: BILB [1-ui8 ] 1f [.]
74: BILO [2-ui8 ] 1f12 [..]
75: BNCM [1-ui8 ]
76: BNCR [1-ui8 ] 04 [.]
77: BNum [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
78: BRSC [2-ui16] 0063 [.c]
79: BSAC [1-ui8 ] 33 [3]
80: BSIn [1-ui8 ] 42 [B]
81: BTIL [2-ui16] 0780 [..]
82: BTTI [1-ui8 ] 02 [.]
83: BTVI [1-ui8 ] 03 [.]
84: BTVR [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
85: BTVT [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
86: CH2S [1-flag] 00 [.]
87: CHBI [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
88: CHBV [2-ui16] 3130 [10]
89: CHGC [2-ui16] 0040 [.@]
90: CHGD [1-flag]
91: CHGI [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
92: CHGV [2-ui16] 3130 [10]
93: CHPV [2-si16] 3130 [10]
94: CLK! [1-ui8 ]
95: CLKC [10-{clc] 00000e1000000e10198c [..........]
96: CLKH [8-{clh] 0000708000011940 [..p....@]
97: CLKS [2-fp1f] 198c [..]
98: CLKT [4-ui32] 000144d3 [..D.]
99: CLSD [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
100: CLWK [2-ui16] 0071 [.q]
101: CRCB [4-ui32] f0255a54 [.%ZT]
102: CRCU [4-ui32]
103: DPLM [3-{lim]
104: EPCA [4-ui32] 00007000 [..p.]
105: EPCF [1-flag] 01 [.]
106: EPCI [4-ui32] 03e00700 [....]
107: EPCV [2-ui16] 0001 [..]
108: EPMA [4-ch8*] 00006080 [..`.]
109: EPMI [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
110: EPUA [4-ui32] 00006000 [..`.]
111: EPUF [1-flag] 01 [.]
112: EPUI [4-ui32] 03e00001 [....]
113: EPUV [2-ui16] 0001 [..]
114: EVCT [2-ui16] 4a0a [J.]
115: EVMD [4-ui32]
116: EVRD [32-ch8*] 730000046f013d33631a7281050092c536c4000003011fca62b736050100bf10 [s...o.=3c.r.....6.......b.6.....]
117: F0Ac [2-fpe2] 2eef [..]
118: F0ID [16-{fds] 00010c004c6566742073696465202000 [....Left side .]
119: F0Mn [2-fpe2] 2ee0 [..]
120: F0Mt [2-ui16] f400 [..]
121: F0Mx [2-fpe2] 5910 [Y.]
122: F0Tg [2-fpe2] 2ee0 [..]
123: FNum [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
124: FPhz [2-si16]
125: FS! [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
126: HBWK [1-flag]
127: HDBS [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
128: HDST [4-hex_] 00000000 [....]
129: HDSW [4-hex_] 0dcb0db0 [....]
130: IBIR [2-fp2e] 0000 [..]
131: IBIr [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
132: IC0C [2-fp6a] 0851 [.Q]
133: IC1C [2-fp4c] 047b [.{]
134: ID0R [2-fp3d] 2966 [)f]
135: ID0r [2-ui16] 2740 ['@]
136: ID1R [2-fp6a] 0000 [..]
137: ID1r [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
138: IH0C [2-fp4c] 0000 [..]
139: IH0r [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
140: IN0R [2-fp6a] 085c [.\]
141: IN1R [2-fp6a] 00e6 [..]
142: IO0C [2-fp4c] 0000 [..]
143: IO0r [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
144: IP0R [2-fp4c] 0241 [.A]
145: IP0r [2-ui16] 0380 [..]
146: IW0C [2-fp4c] 0000 [..]
147: IW0r [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
148: LAcN [1-ui8 ]
149: LAtN [2-ui16]
150: LCCN [1-ui8 ] e0 [.]
151: LCCQ [1-ui8 ] 0b [.]
152: LCKA [1-ui8 ] 6f [o]
153: LCSA [1-ui8 ] 28 [(]
154: LCTN [1-ui8 ] 59 [Y]
155: LCTQ [1-ui8 ] a0 [.]
156: LDSP [1-flag]
157: LKSB [2-{lkb]
158: LS! [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
159: LSCF [10-{lsc] 00c80190800002020020 [......... ]
160: LSDD [8-{lsd] 0002000300030019 [........]
161: LSDU [8-{lsd] 0003000200140003 [........]
162: LSFD [6-{lsf] 00000004008c [......]
163: LSFU [6-{lsf] 00000004008c [......]
164: LSLB [2-{pwm] ffff [..]
165: LSLF [2-{pwm] 0000 [..]
166: LSLN [2-{pwm] ffff [..]
167: LSOF [1-flag] 01 [.]
168: LSOO [1-flag]
169: LSPV [2-{pwm] 0000 [..]
170: LSRB [1-flag]
171: LSSB [2-{lso]
172: LSSE [1-flag] 01 [.]
173: LSSS [2-{lso]
174: LSSV [2-ui16] ffff [..]
175: LSUP [1-ui8 ]
176: MACA [4-ui32] 00000000 [....]
177: MACM [1-flag] 01 [.]
178: MACR [32-ch8*]
179: MOCF [2-ui16] 8300 [..]
180: MOCN [2-ui16] e0f8 [..]
181: MOHD [1-ui8 ] 14 [.]
182: MOHT [2-sp78] 01c0 [..]
183: MOLD [1-ui8 ] 14 [.]
184: MOLT [2-sp78] 0060 [.`]
185: MOST [2-ui16] 8003 [..]
186: MOVX [2-sp78] 0016 [..]
187: MOVY [2-sp78] ffea [..]
188: MOVZ [2-sp78] 0102 [..]
189: MO_X [2-sp78] 0016 [..]
190: MO_Y [2-sp78] ffea [..]
191: MO_Z [2-sp78] 0101 [..]
192: MSAL [1-ui8 ] 4b [K]
193: MSAR [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
194: MSAc [2-fp88] 0000 [..]
195: MSAg [2-fp88] 0000 [..]
196: MSAm [2-fp88] 0000 [..]
197: MSBC [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
198: MSBP [2-ui16] 1191 [..]
199: MSBc [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
200: MSBp [2-ui16] 1191 [..]
201: MSDI [1-flag] 00 [.]
202: MSDW [1-flag]
203: MSFG [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
204: MSLD [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
205: MSPA [2-fp6a] 0000 [..]
206: MSPC [1-ui8 ] 06 [.]
207: MSPS [2-ui16] 0001 [..]
208: MSPZ [1-ui8 ] 08 [.]
209: MSPs [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
210: MSSD [1-si8 ] 05 [.]
211: MSSE [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
212: MSSF [4-ui32] 00000001 [....]
213: MSSP [1-si8 ] 05 [.]
214: MSSS [1-{mss] 00 [.]
215: MSTC [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
216: MSTM [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
217: MSTc [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
218: MSTg [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
219: MSTm [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
220: MSWR [1-ui8 ]
221: MSXC [4-ch8*] 00000000 [....]
222: MSXD [16-ch8*] 00000000000000000000000000000000 [................]
223: MSXK [32-ch8*] 0102030405060708090a0b0c0d0e0f1011120000000000000000000000000000 [................................]
224: MSXN [1-ui8 ] 12 [.]
225: MSXS [4-ch8*] 0205070a [....]
226: MSXb [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
227: MSXc [4-ch8*] 00000000 [....]
228: MSXd [16-ch8*] 00000000000000000000000000000000 [................]
229: MSXk [32-ch8*] 0102030405060708090a0b0c0d0e0f101112131415161718191a1b1c1d1e1f20 [............................... ]
230: MSXm [2-ui16] 0008 [..]
231: MSXn [1-ui8 ] 28 [(]
232: MSXs [4-ui32] 0103060c [....]
233: NACK [1-flag]
234: NATJ [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
235: NATi [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
236: NOPB [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
237: NTOK [1-ui8 ]
238: ONMI [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
239: OWCT [2-ui16] 000e [..]
240: PBIC [2-fp88] 0000 [..]
241: PC0C [2-fp88] 03cd [..]
242: PC1C [2-fp88] 05bb [..]
243: PD0R [2-fp88] 17d3 [..]
244: PD1R [2-fp88] 0000 [..]
245: PH0C [2-fp88] 0000 [..]
246: PHPC [2-fp88] 0845 [.E]
247: PN0R [2-fp88] 0234 [.4]
248: PN1R [2-fp88] 0056 [.V]
249: PO0C [2-fp88] 0000 [..]
250: PP0R [2-fp88] 01c4 [..]
251: PTHC [2-fp88] 20fb [ .]
252: PW0C [2-fp88] 0000 [..]
253: RBr [8-ch8*] 6b31396900000000 [k19i....]
254: REV [6-{rev] 01490f000002 [.I....]
255: RMde [1-char] 41 [A]
256: RPlt [8-ch8*] 6b31396900000000 [k19i....]
257: RSvn [4-ui32] 00006446 [..dF]
258: RVBF [6-{rev] 01490f000002 [.I....]
259: RVUF [6-{rev] 01490f000002 [.I....]
260: SAS! [4-hex_]
261: SBS! [2-ui16]
262: SCIA [2-ui16] 03f8 [..]
263: SCIL [1-ui8] 00 [.]
264: SDRd [2-ui16]
265: SIP [1-ui8] 01 [.]
266: SIS! [2-hex_]
267: SIT! [2-hex_]
268: SM0x [2-ui16] 7c40 [|@]
269: SM0y [2-ui16] 8340 [.@]
270: SM0z [2-ui16] b3c0 [..]
271: SMBC [5-ch8*]
272: SMBG [1-ui8 ]
273: SMBR [32-ch8*]
274: SMBS [2-ch8*]
275: SMBW [32-ch8*]
276: SPH0 [2-ui16] 2992 [).]
277: SPHS [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
278: SPHT [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
279: SPHZ [1-ui8]
280: SPS! [2-ui16]
281: TB0T [2-sp78] 1e4c [.L]
282: TB1T [2-sp78] 1e4c [.L]
283: TB2T [2-sp78] 1d00 [..]
284: TB3T [2-sp78] 0000 [..]
285: TC0D [2-sp78] 3760 [7`]
286: TC0F [2-sp78] 2f56 [/V]
287: TC0P [2-sp78] 3100 [1.]
288: TN0D [2-sp78] 3620 [6 ]
289: TN0P [2-sp78] 2ea0 [..]
290: TTF0 [2-sp78] 3100 [1.]
291: Th2H [2-sp78] 2dc0 [-.]
292: Ts0P [2-sp78] 1c40 [.@]
293: Ts0S [2-sp78] 2444 [$D]
294: UPRC [2-ui16] 0845 [.E]
295: VBOC [2-fp6a] 0000 [..]
296: VBOc [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
297: VC0C [2-fp2e] 43bc [C.]
298: VC0c [2-ui16] 5a40 [Z@]
299: VN0R [2-fp2e] 3fff [?.]

Can anyone possibly shed some light on this for me? fan1_manual is 0. Kind regards,

Here is my dmsg output:

Code:

(Many more before this)
[ 2866.895374] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2866.928232] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2866.961124] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2866.997974] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2867.040855] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2867.073667] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2867.109340] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2867.143917] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2867.176778] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2867.209802] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2867.246832] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2867.288783] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2867.321608] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2867.357032] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2867.390128] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2867.422935] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2867.455741] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2867.497112] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2867.538676] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2867.571490] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2867.607085] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2867.639999] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2867.672884] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2867.706434] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2867.743508] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2867.785468] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2867.818277] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2867.855732] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2867.893148] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2867.925998] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2867.958804] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2867.995312] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2868.037271] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2868.070078] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2868.105554] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2868.139460] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2868.172276] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2868.205087] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2868.242107] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2868.286271] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2868.319083] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2868.354592] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2868.387518] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2868.420333] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2868.453144] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2868.491307] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2868.532904] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2868.565717] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2868.601705] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2868.635068] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2868.668262] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2868.701093] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2868.738888] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2868.782822] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2868.815631] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2868.853941] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2868.887535] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2868.920346] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2868.953156] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2868.989667] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2869.031752] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2869.064560] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3044.253372] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3046.171132] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3046.226736] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3046.282905] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3046.563544] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3046.772481] applesmc: wait status failed: 4 != 5
[ 3047.179824] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3047.364443] applesmc: wait status failed: 4 != 5
[ 3047.576426] applesmc: wait status failed: 4 != 5
[ 3047.789169] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 4
[ 3047.824862] applesmc: command failed: 12 -> e
[ 3047.872516] applesmc: command failed: 10 -> 8
[ 3047.945687] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3048.444321] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3048.845766] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3048.928590] applesmc: wait status failed: 4 != 5
[ 3049.770745] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3049.839235] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3050.130181] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3050.200773] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3050.665543] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3050.728575] applesmc: wait status failed: 4 != 5
[ 3050.851919] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3050.922045] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3051.036258] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3051.150109] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3051.254577] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3052.037991] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3052.648339] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3053.045371] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3053.177547] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3053.831860] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3053.893642] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3053.995580] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3054.075667] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3054.158045] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3054.288659] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3054.347425] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3054.418522] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3054.489607] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3054.565982] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3054.696608] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3054.755403] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0

Marcus

**kosumi68** · April 26th, 2010

Thanks for providing the data. Please find attached a package for testing the MBP5,4 settings. I have to ask again if this is indeed a MacBook Pro? Is so, the 5,4 model has only one fan, which might explain one or two things.

Output of the test scripts after unpacking and installing this package followed by a reboot would be greatly appreciated.

Cheers!

**m.prebble** · April 26th, 2010

Hi,

Thank you very much for taking the time to investigate this with me. Yep, definitely macbook pro, 5.4 model according to dmidecode.

Installed the package, here is the output. Unfortunately the fan still stayed static at 2000rpm throughout the testing.

Code:

accelerometer: present, readable, output: (7,43,253)
fan:           present, readable, output: 2000
light:         present, readable, output: (2,0)
leds:          present,
 led:                   readable, output: 100
temperatures:  present,
 temperature:           readable, output: 49000
 temperature:           readable, output: 40750
 temperature:           readable, output: 26250
 temperature:           readable, output: 34500
 temperature:           readable, output: 27250
 temperature:           readable, output: 27250
 temperature:           readable, output: 27000
 temperature:           readable, output: 0
 temperature:           readable, output: 49250
 temperature:           readable, output: 43250
 temperature:           readable, output: 45250
 temperature:           readable, output: 50000
 temperature:           readable, output: 43500
performance:   reading all temperatures
 fail frequency:        .002
 reads per second:      62

Code:

0: #KEY [4-ui32] 00000134 [...4]
1: $Adr [4-ui32] 00000300 [....]
2: $Num [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
3: +LKS [1-flag] 07 [.]
4: ACCL [1-ui8 ]
5: ACEN [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
6: ACFP [1-flag] 01 [.]
7: ACIC [2-ui16] 0e10 [..]
8: ACID [8-ch8*] 8598d028c00310e7 [...(....]
9: ACIN [1-flag] 01 [.]
10: ACLM [1-ui8 ] 55 [U]
11: AL! [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
12: ALA0 [6-{ala] ca1effd602d9 [......]
13: ALA1 [6-{ala] 30a4021f0315 [0.....]
14: ALA2 [6-{ala] 0cea02d40396 [......]
15: ALA3 [6-{ala] 0389036103dc [...a..]
16: ALA4 [6-{ala] 00ee03bc0400 [......]
17: ALA5 [6-{ala] 04fcfff30400 [......]
18: ALAT [4-{alt] 002b0308 [.+..]
19: ALI0 [4-{ali] 04000f00 [....]
20: ALI1 [4-{ali] 00000000 [....]
21: ALP0 [4-ui16] 13330780 [.3..]
22: ALP1 [4-ui16] 00000000 [....]
23: ALRV [2-ui16] 0001 [..]
24: ALSC [16-{alc] 00c8009603e8000f0001015e1d030106 [...........^....]
25: ALSF [2-fp1f] 3873 [8s]
26: ALSL [2-ui16] 0030 [.0]
27: ALT0 [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
28: ALT1 [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
29: ALTH [10-{alr] 00320070025200140041 [.2.p.R...A]
30: ALV0 [10-{alv] 010101cd00fa000c1296 [..........]
31: ALV1 [10-{alv] 00010000000000000000 [..........]
32: AUPO [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
33: B0AC [2-si16] 0000 [..]
34: B0AV [2-ui16] 3091 [0.]
35: B0Ad [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
36: B0Al [2-ui16] ffff [..]
37: B0Am [1-ui8 ] 10 [.]
38: B0Ar [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
39: B0As [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
40: B0At [2-ui16] 0960 [.`]
41: B0Au [2-ui16] 0960 [.`]
42: B0Az [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
43: B0BI [1-ui8 ] 51 [Q]
44: B0CM [2-ui16] 0119 [..]
45: B0CT [2-ui16] 0060 [.`]
46: B0FC [2-ui16]
47: B0FV [2-ui16] 0003 [..]
48: B0LI [2-ui16] 7fff [..]
49: B0PS [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
50: B0RI [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
51: B0RM [2-ui16] 1936 [.6]
52: B0SN [13-ch8*] 57303932364245373737375641 [W0926BE7777VA]
53: B0St [2-ui16] 40e0 [@.]
54: B0TF [2-ui16] ffff [..]
55: BATP [1-flag] 00 [.]
56: BBAD [1-flag] 00 [.]
57: BBIN [1-flag] 01 [.]
58: BC1V [2-ui16] 1030 [.0]
59: BC2V [2-ui16] 1031 [.1]
60: BC3V [2-ui16] 1030 [.0]
61: BCHA [1-ui8 ] 02 [.]
62: BCHB [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
63: BCHF [1-ui8 ]
64: BCHG [1-ui8 ]
65: BCHL [1-ui8 ]
66: BCHO [1-ui8 ] 1f [.]
67: BCHP [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
68: BCHR [1-ui8 ] 3a [:]
69: BCHT [1-ui8 ] 06 [.]
70: BCHX [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
71: BCLM [1-ui8 ] 64 [d]
72: BEZL [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
73: BILB [1-ui8 ] 1f [.]
74: BILO [2-ui8 ] 1f0e [..]
75: BNCM [1-ui8 ]
76: BNCR [1-ui8 ] 04 [.]
77: BNum [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
78: BRSC [2-ui16] 0062 [.b]
79: BSAC [1-ui8 ] 33 [3]
80: BSIn [1-ui8 ] 42 [B]
81: BTIL [2-ui16] 0780 [..]
82: BTTI [1-ui8 ] 02 [.]
83: BTVI [1-ui8 ] 03 [.]
84: BTVR [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
85: BTVT [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
86: CH2S [1-flag] 00 [.]
87: CHBI [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
88: CHBV [2-ui16] 3138 [18]
89: CHGC [2-ui16] 0040 [.@]
90: CHGD [1-flag]
91: CHGI [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
92: CHGV [2-ui16] 3130 [10]
93: CHPV [2-si16] 3130 [10]
94: CLK! [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
95: CLKC [10-{clc] 00000e1000000e10198c [..........]
96: CLKH [8-{clh] 0000708000011940 [..p....@]
97: CLKS [2-fp1f] 8000 [..]
98: CLKT [4-ui32] 0000e03b [...;]
99: CLSD [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
100: CLWK [2-ui16] 0076 [.v]
101: CRCB [4-ui32] f0255a54 [.%ZT]
102: CRCU [4-ui32]
103: DPLM [3-{lim]
104: EPCA [4-ui32] 00007000 [..p.]
105: EPCF [1-flag] 01 [.]
106: EPCI [4-ui32] 03e00700 [....]
107: EPCV [2-ui16] 0001 [..]
108: EPMA [4-ch8*] 00006080 [..`.]
109: EPMI [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
110: EPUA [4-ui32] 00006000 [..`.]
111: EPUF [1-flag] 01 [.]
112: EPUI [4-ui32] 03e00001 [....]
113: EPUV [2-ui16] 0001 [..]
114: EVCT [2-ui16] 0505 [..]
115: EVMD [4-ui32]
116: EVRD [32-ch8*] 2303fa0001014a8d2304fa0001014a8df60601000000d83c760600000200858e [#.....J.#.....J........<v.......]
117: F0Ac [2-fpe2] 1f19 [..]
118: F0ID [16-{fds] 00010c004c6566742073696465202000 [....Left side .]
119: F0Mn [2-fpe2] 1f40 [.@]
120: F0Mt [2-ui16] f400 [..]
121: F0Mx [2-fpe2] 5910 [Y.]
122: F0Tg [2-fpe2] 1f40 [.@]
123: FNum [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
124: FPhz [2-si16]
125: FS! [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
126: HBWK [1-flag] 00 [.]
127: HDBS [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
128: HDST [4-hex_] 00000000 [....]
129: HDSW [4-hex_] 0dcd0db2 [....]
130: IBIR [2-fp2e] 0000 [..]
131: IBIr [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
132: IC0C [2-fp6a] 0dcd [..]
133: IC1C [2-fp4c] 06f1 [..]
134: ID0R [2-fp3d] 2e5d [.]]
135: ID0r [2-ui16] 2b80 [+.]
136: ID1R [2-fp6a] 0000 [..]
137: ID1r [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
138: IH0C [2-fp4c] 0000 [..]
139: IH0r [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
140: IN0R [2-fp6a] 087b [.{]
141: IN1R [2-fp6a] 00e9 [..]
142: IO0C [2-fp4c] 0000 [..]
143: IO0r [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
144: IP0R [2-fp4c] 0241 [.A]
145: IP0r [2-ui16] 0380 [..]
146: IW0C [2-fp4c] 0000 [..]
147: IW0r [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
148: LAcN [1-ui8 ]
149: LAtN [2-ui16]
150: LCCN [1-ui8 ] a5 [.]
151: LCCQ [1-ui8 ] 84 [.]
152: LCKA [1-ui8 ] 68 [h]
153: LCSA [1-ui8 ] 76 [v]
154: LCTN [1-ui8 ] 7b [{]
155: LCTQ [1-ui8 ] de [.]
156: LDSP [1-flag]
157: LKSB [2-{lkb]
158: LS! [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
159: LSCF [10-{lsc] 00c80190800002020020 [......... ]
160: LSDD [8-{lsd] 0002000300030019 [........]
161: LSDU [8-{lsd] 0003000200140003 [........]
162: LSFD [6-{lsf] 00000004008c [......]
163: LSFU [6-{lsf] 00000004008c [......]
164: LSLB [2-{pwm] ffff [..]
165: LSLF [2-{pwm] 0000 [..]
166: LSLN [2-{pwm] ffff [..]
167: LSOF [1-flag] 01 [.]
168: LSOO [1-flag]
169: LSPV [2-{pwm] 0000 [..]
170: LSRB [1-flag]
171: LSSB [2-{lso]
172: LSSE [1-flag] 01 [.]
173: LSSS [2-{lso]
174: LSSV [2-ui16] ffff [..]
175: LSUP [1-ui8 ]
176: MACA [4-ui32] 00000000 [....]
177: MACM [1-flag] 01 [.]
178: MACR [32-ch8*]
179: MOCF [2-ui16] 8300 [..]
180: MOCN [2-ui16] e0f8 [..]
181: MOHD [1-ui8 ] 14 [.]
182: MOHT [2-sp78] 01c0 [..]
183: MOLD [1-ui8 ] 14 [.]
184: MOLT [2-sp78] 0060 [.`]
185: MOST [2-ui16] 8003 [..]
186: MOVX [2-sp78] 0005 [..]
187: MOVY [2-sp78] 002b [.+]
188: MOVZ [2-sp78] 0100 [..]
189: MO_X [2-sp78] 0002 [..]
190: MO_Y [2-sp78] 002c [.,]
191: MO_Z [2-sp78] 0100 [..]
192: MSAL [1-ui8 ] 4b [K]
193: MSAR [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
194: MSAc [2-fp88] 0000 [..]
195: MSAg [2-fp88] 0000 [..]
196: MSAm [2-fp88] 0000 [..]
197: MSBC [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
198: MSBP [2-ui16] 0fe4 [..]
199: MSBc [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
200: MSBp [2-ui16] 0fe4 [..]
201: MSDI [1-flag] 00 [.]
202: MSDW [1-flag]
203: MSFG [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
204: MSLD [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
205: MSPA [2-fp6a] 0000 [..]
206: MSPC [1-ui8 ] 06 [.]
207: MSPS [2-ui16] 0001 [..]
208: MSPZ [1-ui8 ] 08 [.]
209: MSPs [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
210: MSSD [1-si8 ] 03 [.]
211: MSSE [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
212: MSSF [4-ui32] 00000001 [....]
213: MSSP [1-si8 ] 05 [.]
214: MSSS [1-{mss] 00 [.]
215: MSTC [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
216: MSTM [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
217: MSTc [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
218: MSTg [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
219: MSTm [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
220: MSWR [1-ui8 ]
221: MSXC [4-ch8*] 00000000 [....]
222: MSXD [16-ch8*] 00000000000000000000000000000000 [................]
223: MSXK [32-ch8*] 0102030405060708090a0b0c0d0e0f1011120000000000000000000000000000 [................................]
224: MSXN [1-ui8 ] 12 [.]
225: MSXS [4-ch8*] 0205070a [....]
226: MSXb [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
227: MSXc [4-ch8*] 00000000 [....]
228: MSXd [16-ch8*] 00000000000000000000000000000000 [................]
229: MSXk [32-ch8*] 0102030405060708090a0b0c0d0e0f101112131415161718191a1b1c1d1e1f20 [............................... ]
230: MSXm [2-ui16] 0008 [..]
231: MSXn [1-ui8 ] 28 [(]
232: MSXs [4-ui32] 0103060c [....]
233: NACK [1-flag]
234: NATJ [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
235: NATi [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
236: NOPB [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
237: NTOK [1-ui8 ]
238: ONMI [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
239: OWCT [2-ui16] 0010 [..]
240: PBIC [2-fp88] 0000 [..]
241: PC0C [2-fp88] 0211 [..]
242: PC1C [2-fp88] 0398 [..]
243: PD0R [2-fp88] 15ce [..]
244: PD1R [2-fp88] 0000 [..]
245: PH0C [2-fp88] 0000 [..]
246: PHPC [2-fp88]
247: PN0R [2-fp88] 021d [..]
248: PN1R [2-fp88] 0057 [.W]
249: PO0C [2-fp88] 0000 [..]
250: PP0R [2-fp88] 01c4 [..]
251: PTHC [2-fp88] 20fb [ .]
252: PW0C [2-fp88] 0000 [..]
253: RBr [8-ch8*] 6b31396900000000 [k19i....]
254: REV [6-{rev] 01490f000002 [.I....]
255: RMde [1-char] 41 [A]
256: RPlt [8-ch8*] 6b31396900000000 [k19i....]
257: RSvn [4-ui32] 00006446 [..dF]
258: RVBF [6-{rev] 01490f000002 [.I....]
259: RVUF [6-{rev] 01490f000002 [.I....]
260: SAS! [4-hex_]
261: SBS! [2-ui16]
262: SCIA [2-ui16] 03f8 [..]
263: SCIL [1-ui8] 00 [.]
264: SDRd [2-ui16]
265: SIP [1-ui8] 01 [.]
266: SIS! [2-hex_]
267: SIT! [2-hex_]
268: SM0x [2-ui16] 8000 [..]
269: SM0y [2-ui16] 7680 [v.]
270: SM0z [2-ui16] b2c0 [..]
271: SMBC [5-ch8*]
272: SMBG [1-ui8 ]
273: SMBR [32-ch8*]
274: SMBS [2-ch8*]
275: SMBW [32-ch8*]
276: SPH0 [2-ui16] 2a60 [*`]
277: SPHS [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
278: SPHT [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
279: SPHZ [1-ui8]
280: SPS! [2-ui16]
281: TB0T [2-sp78] 1b99 [..]
282: TB1T [2-sp78] 1b99 [..]
283: TB2T [2-sp78] 1b4c [.L]
284: TB3T [2-sp78] 0000 [..]
285: TC0D [2-sp78] 3740 [7@]
286: TC0F [2-sp78] 2b97 [+.]
287: TC0P [2-sp78] 2de0 [-.]
288: TN0D [2-sp78] 3320 [3 ]
289: TN0P [2-sp78] 2ba0 [+.]
290: TTF0 [2-sp78] 3100 [1.]
291: Th2H [2-sp78] 29a0 [).]
292: Ts0P [2-sp78] 1ac0 [..]
293: Ts0S [2-sp78] 22cd [".]
294: UPRC [2-ui16] 0845 [.E]
295: VBOC [2-fp6a] 0000 [..]
296: VBOc [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
297: VC0C [2-fp2e] 450e [E.]
298: VC0c [2-ui16] 4d40 [M@]
299: VN0R [2-fp2e] 3fff [?.]

I am happy to try anything more to get this solved.

Kind regards,

Marcus

**kosumi68** · April 26th, 2010

Thanks, I take it there are fewer errors in dmesg? If so, it is a valid kernel patch, although for a different problem. If you want your name to appear as a tester in the kernel logs, please send me a private message with your full name and email address, and I will include it in the patch.

Just to get a clean baseline, did you try to set the /sys/devices/platform/applesmc.768/fan1_manual to one, then to zero again, after applying the package? Just to rule out that stopping reading of non-existing temperature sensors did not somehow magically solve the problem. I would also consider resetting the SMC (support.apple.com/kb/HT3964?viewlocale=en_US).

**kosumi68** · April 26th, 2010

Looking at the data again I realize Apple added even more sensors to the new machines, so the scan-smc.sh script needs to be changed slightly. Modify the line starting with "END=" to

Code:

END=400

and run the script again - you should see more entrys after the last one (299: VN0R).

**kosumi68** · April 27th, 2010

Looking even more at the data and comparing to other models, it seems one fan register (F0Sf) has been dropped for the new models MB51, MBA21, MBP51, MBP54. That register is commonly referred to as "safe speed".

Because the register has been removed, it is likely that Apple changed the way fan control works. It could well be that the SMC overheat protection that keeps the other models cool enough under Linux was removed and replaced by something else. Anyone's guess at this point.

In practise, it means the fan might have to be regulated by the OS for all those newer models. Are there any new mac owners out there that beg to differ?

**m.prebble** · April 27th, 2010

Kosumi68, thank you again for your continued efforts on this. In reply to your previous message re: dmsg output, no, this is not the case... and now intermittently i get errors reading from TG0T GPU transistor..

But the number has changed again now:

Code:

 

marcus@marcus-ubuntu:~/scripts$ dmesg | tail
[ 7340.889817] applesmc: wait status failed: 4 != 0
[ 7648.893822] applesmc: wait status failed: 4 != 0
[ 9082.888785] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 1
[ 9452.889228] applesmc: wait status failed: 4 != 0
[ 9518.894479] applesmc: wait status failed: 4 != 0
[10050.887675] applesmc: wait status failed: 4 != 0
[10092.895570] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 1
[10114.896571] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 1
[10292.890494] applesmc: wait status failed: 4 != 0
[10344.887784] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 1

Code:

here is the updated script output:

0: #KEY [4-ui32] 00000134 [...4]
1: $Adr [4-ui32] 00000300 [....]
2: $Num [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
3: +LKS [1-flag] 07 [.]
4: ACCL [1-ui8 ]
5: ACEN [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
6: ACFP [1-flag] 00 [.]
7: ACIC [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
8: ACID [8-ch8*] 0000000000000000 [........]
9: ACIN [1-flag] 00 [.]
10: ACLM [1-ui8 ] 55 [U]
11: AL! [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
12: ALA0 [6-{ala] ca1effd602d9 [......]
13: ALA1 [6-{ala] 30a4021f0315 [0.....]
14: ALA2 [6-{ala] 0cea02d40396 [......]
15: ALA3 [6-{ala] 0389036103dc [...a..]
16: ALA4 [6-{ala] 00ee03bc0400 [......]
17: ALA5 [6-{ala] 04fcfff30400 [......]
18: ALAT [4-{alt] 002b0308 [.+..]
19: ALI0 [4-{ali] 04000f00 [....]
20: ALI1 [4-{ali] 00000000 [....]
21: ALP0 [4-ui16] 13330780 [.3..]
22: ALP1 [4-ui16] 00000000 [....]
23: ALRV [2-ui16] 0001 [..]
24: ALSC [16-{alc] 00c8009603e8000f0001015e1d030106 [...........^....]
25: ALSF [2-fp1f] 4b44 [KD]
26: ALSL [2-ui16] 004d [.M]
27: ALT0 [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
28: ALT1 [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
29: ALTH [10-{alr] 00320070025200140041 [.2.p.R...A]
30: ALV0 [10-{alv] 01010228010b00135312 [...(....S.]
31: ALV1 [10-{alv] 00010000000000000000 [..........]
32: AUPO [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
33: B0AC [2-si16] fa1a [..]
34: B0AV [2-ui16] 2f62 [/b]
35: B0Ad [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
36: B0Al [2-ui16] ffff [..]
37: B0Am [1-ui8 ] 10 [.]
38: B0Ar [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
39: B0As [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
40: B0At [2-ui16] 0960 [.`]
41: B0Au [2-ui16] 0960 [.`]
42: B0Az [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
43: B0BI [1-ui8 ] 51 [Q]
44: B0CM [2-ui16] 0119 [..]
45: B0CT [2-ui16] 0060 [.`]
46: B0FC [2-ui16] 19b1 [..]
47: B0FV [2-ui16] 0003 [..]
48: B0LI [2-ui16] 7fff [..]
49: B0PS [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
50: B0RI [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
51: B0RM [2-ui16] 1869 [.i]
52: B0SN [13-ch8*] 57303932364245373737375641 [W0926BE7777VA]
53: B0St [2-ui16] 40e0 [@.]
54: B0TF [2-ui16] ffff [..]
55: BATP [1-flag] 01 [.]
56: BBAD [1-flag] 00 [.]
57: BBIN [1-flag] 01 [.]
58: BC1V [2-ui16] 0fca [..]
59: BC2V [2-ui16] 0fcf [..]
60: BC3V [2-ui16] 0fca [..]
61: BCHA [1-ui8 ] 02 [.]
62: BCHB [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
63: BCHF [1-ui8 ]
64: BCHG [1-ui8 ]
65: BCHL [1-ui8 ]
66: BCHO [1-ui8 ] 1f [.]
67: BCHP [1-ui8 ] 0d [.]
68: BCHR [1-ui8 ] 3a [:]
69: BCHT [1-ui8 ] 06 [.]
70: BCHX [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
71: BCLM [1-ui8 ] 64 [d]
72: BEZL [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
73: BILB [1-ui8 ] 1f [.]
74: BILO [2-ui8 ] 1f12 [..]
75: BNCM [1-ui8 ]
76: BNCR [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
77: BNum [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
78: BRSC [2-ui16] 005f [._]
79: BSAC [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
80: BSIn [1-ui8 ] 40 [@]
81: BTIL [2-ui16] 0780 [..]
82: BTTI [1-ui8 ] 02 [.]
83: BTVI [1-ui8 ] 03 [.]
84: BTVR [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
85: BTVT [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
86: CH2S [1-flag] 00 [.]
87: CHBI [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
88: CHBV [2-ui16] 3138 [18]
89: CHGC [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
90: CHGD [1-flag]
91: CHGI [2-ui16] 0080 [..]
92: CHGV [2-ui16] 3130 [10]
93: CHPV [2-si16] 3130 [10]
94: CLK! [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
95: CLKC [10-{clc] 00000e1000000e10198c [..........]
96: CLKH [8-{clh] 0000708000011940 [..p....@]
97: CLKS [2-fp1f] 8000 [..]
98: CLKT [4-ui32] 0001086c [...l]
99: CLSD [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
100: CLWK [2-ui16] 0076 [.v]
101: CRCB [4-ui32] f0255a54 [.%ZT]
102: CRCU [4-ui32]
103: DPLM [3-{lim]support.apple.com/kb/HT3964?viewlocale=en_US
104: EPCA [4-ui32] 00007000 [..p.]
105: EPCF [1-flag] 01 [.]
106: EPCI [4-ui32] 03e00700 [....]
107: EPCV [2-ui16] 0001 [..]
108: EPMA [4-ch8*] 00006080 [..`.]
109: EPMI [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
110: EPUA [4-ui32] 00006000 [..`.]
111: EPUF [1-flag] 01 [.]
112: EPUI [4-ui32] 03e00001 [....]
113: EPUV [2-ui16] 0001 [..]
114: EVCT [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
115: EVMD [4-ui32]
116: EVRD [32-ch8*] 2303fa0001014a8d2304fa0001014a8df60601000000d83c760600000200858e [#.....J.#.....J........<v.......]
117: F0Ac [2-fpe2] 2edc [..]
118: F0ID [16-{fds] 00010c004c6566742073696465202000 [....Left side .]
119: F0Mn [2-fpe2] 2ee0 [..]
120: F0Mt [2-ui16] f400 [..]
121: F0Mx [2-fpe2] 5910 [Y.]
122: F0Tg [2-fpe2] 2ee0 [..]
123: FNum [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
124: FPhz [2-si16]
125: FS! [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
126: HBWK [1-flag] 00 [.]
127: HDBS [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
128: HDST [4-hex_] 00000000 [....]
129: HDSW [4-hex_] 0dcd0db2 [....]
130: IBIR [2-fp2e] 0000 [..]
131: IBIr [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
132: IC0C [2-fp6a] 0e2c [.,]
133: IC1C [2-fp4c] 0776 [.v]
134: ID0R [2-fp3d] 0000 [..]
135: ID0r [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
136: ID1R [2-fp6a] 0000 [..]
137: ID1r [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
138: IH0C [2-fp4c] 0000 [..]
139: IH0r [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
140: IN0R [2-fp6a] 07c9 [..]
141: IN1R [2-fp6a] 00e6 [..]
142: IO0C [2-fp4c] 0000 [..]
143: IO0r [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
144: IP0R [2-fp4c] 1df8 [..]
145: IP0r [2-ui16] 3500 [5.]
146: IW0C [2-fp4c] 0000 [..]
147: IW0r [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
148: LAcN [1-ui8 ]
149: LAtN [2-ui16]
150: LCCN [1-ui8 ] 41 [A]
151: LCCQ [1-ui8 ] 5f [_]
152: LCKA [1-ui8 ] 61 [a]
153: LCSA [1-ui8 ] 0f [.]
154: LCTN [1-ui8 ] 7b [{]
155: LCTQ [1-ui8 ] a2 [.]
156: LDSP [1-flag]
157: LKSB [2-{lkb]
158: LS! [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
159: LSCF [10-{lsc] 00c80190800002020020 [......... ]
160: LSDD [8-{lsd]
161: LSDU [8-{lsd] 0003000200140003 [........]
162: LSFD [6-{lsf] 00000004008c [......]
163: LSFU [6-{lsf] 00000004008c [......]
164: LSLB [2-{pwm] ffff [..]
165: LSLF [2-{pwm] 0000 [..]
166: LSLN [2-{pwm] ffff [..]
167: LSOF [1-flag] 01 [.]
168: LSOO [1-flag]
169: LSPV [2-{pwm] 0000 [..]
170: LSRB [1-flag]
171: LSSB [2-{lso]
172: LSSE [1-flag] 01 [.]
173: LSSS [2-{lso]
174: LSSV [2-ui16] ffff [..]
175: LSUP [1-ui8 ]
176: MACA [4-ui32] 00000000 [....]
177: MACM [1-flag] 01 [.]
178: MACR [32-ch8*]
179: MOCF [2-ui16] 8300 [..]
180: MOCN [2-ui16] e0f8 [..]
181: MOHD [1-ui8 ] 14 [.]
182: MOHT [2-sp78] 01c0 [..]
183: MOLD [1-ui8 ] 14 [.]
184: MOLT [2-sp78] 0060 [.`]
185: MOST [2-ui16] 8003 [..]
186: MOVX [2-sp78] 0003 [..]
187: MOVY [2-sp78] 0003 [..]
188: MOVZ [2-sp78] 0105 [..]
189: MO_X [2-sp78] 0002 [..]
190: MO_Y [2-sp78] 0000 [..]
191: MO_Z [2-sp78] 0105 [..]
192: MSAL [1-ui8 ] 4b [K]
193: MSAR [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
194: MSAc [2-fp88] 0000 [..]
195: MSAg [2-fp88] 0000 [..]
196: MSAm [2-fp88] 0000 [..]
197: MSBC [2-ui16] 01fb [..]
198: MSBP [2-ui16] 1250 [.P]
199: MSBc [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
200: MSBp [2-ui16] 0fe4 [..]
201: MSDI [1-flag] 00 [.]
202: MSDW [1-flag]
203: MSFG [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
204: MSLD [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
205: MSPA [2-fp6a] 0000 [..]
206: MSPC [1-ui8 ] 06 [.]
207: MSPS [2-ui16] 0001 [..]
208: MSPZ [1-ui8 ] 08 [.]
209: MSPs [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
210: MSSD [1-si8 ] 03 [.]
211: MSSE [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
212: MSSF [4-ui32] 00000001 [....]
213: MSSP [1-si8 ] 05 [.]
214: MSSS [1-{mss] 00 [.]
215: MSTC [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
216: MSTM [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
217: MSTc [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
218: MSTg [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
219: MSTm [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
220: MSWR [1-ui8 ]
221: MSXC [4-ch8*] 00000000 [....]
222: MSXD [16-ch8*] 00000000000000000000000000000000 [................]
223: MSXK [32-ch8*] 0102030405060708090a0b0c0d0e0f1011120000000000000000000000000000 [................................]
224: MSXN [1-ui8 ] 12 [.]
225: MSXS [4-ch8*] 0205070a [....]
226: MSXb [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
227: MSXc [4-ch8*] 00000000 [....]
228: MSXd [16-ch8*] 00000000000000000000000000000000 [................]
229: MSXk [32-ch8*] 21222324f0f1f2f3000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 [!"#$............................]
230: MSXm [2-ui16] 0008 [..]
231: MSXn [1-ui8 ] 28 [(]
232: MSXs [4-ui32] 0103060c [....]
233: NACK [1-flag]
234: NATJ [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
235: NATi [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
236: NOPB [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
237: NTOK [1-ui8 ]
238: ONMI [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
239: OWCT [2-ui16] 0010 [..]
240: PBIC [2-fp88] 0000 [..]
241: PC0C [2-fp88] 02e3 [..]
242: PC1C [2-fp88] 0486 [..]
243: PD0R [2-fp88] 0000 [..]
244: PD1R [2-fp88] 0000 [..]
245: PH0C [2-fp88] 0000 [..]
246: PHPC [2-fp88] 06c9 [..]
247: PN0R [2-fp88] 01ec [..]
248: PN1R [2-fp88] 0056 [.V]
249: PO0C [2-fp88] 0000 [..]
250: PP0R [2-fp88] 148c [..]
251: PTHC [2-fp88] 20fb [ .]
252: PW0C [2-fp88] 0000 [..]
253: RBr [8-ch8*] 6b31396900000000 [k19i....]
254: REV [6-{rev] 01490f000002 [.I....]
255: RMde [1-char] 41 [A]
256: RPlt [8-ch8*] 6b31396900000000 [k19i....]
257: RSvn [4-ui32] 00006446 [..dF]
258: RVBF [6-{rev] 01490f000002 [.I....]
259: RVUF [6-{rev] 01490f000002 [.I....]
260: SAS! [4-hex_]
261: SBS! [2-ui16]
262: SCIA [2-ui16] 03f8 [..]
263: SCIL [1-ui8] 00 [.]
264: SDRd [2-ui16]
265: SIP [1-ui8] 01 [.]
266: SIS! [2-hex_]
267: SIT! [2-hex_]
268: SM0x [2-ui16] 7fc0 [..]
269: SM0y [2-ui16] 7f80 [..]
270: SM0z [2-ui16] b400 [..]
271: SMBC [5-ch8*]
272: SMBG [1-ui8 ]
273: SMBR [32-ch8*]
274: SMBS [2-ch8*]
275: SMBW [32-ch8*]
276: SPH0 [2-ui16] 2a60 [*`]
277: SPHS [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
278: SPHT [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
279: SPHZ [1-ui8]
280: SPS! [2-ui16]
281: TB0T [2-sp78] 19b3 [..]
282: TB1T [2-sp78] 19b3 [..]
283: TB2T [2-sp78] 1933 [.3]
284: TB3T [2-sp78] 0000 [..]
285: TC0D [2-sp78] 2b20 [+ ]
286: TC0F [2-sp78] 248c [$.]
287: TC0P [2-sp78] 2500 [%.]
288: TN0D [2-sp78] 29a0 [).]
289: TN0P [2-sp78] 23e0 [#.]
290: TTF0 [2-sp78] 3100 [1.]
291: Th2H [2-sp78] 2180 [!.]
292: Ts0P [2-sp78] 1910 [..]
293: Ts0S [2-sp78] 1f78 [.x]
294: UPRC [2-ui16] 0845 [.E]
295: VBOC [2-fp6a] 0000 [..]
296: VBOc [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
297: VC0C [2-fp2e] 4259 [BY]
298: VC0c [2-ui16] 49c0 [I.]
299: VN0R [2-fp2e] 3fff [?.]
300: VN0r [2-ui16] 4d80 [M.]
301: VO0C [2-fp4c] 0000 [..]
302: VO0r [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
303: VP0R [2-fp4c] bf4b [.K]
304: VP0r [2-ui16] 9b00 [..]
305: VW0C [2-fp4c] 0000 [..]
306: VW0r [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
307: zDBG [1-ui8] 00 [.]

The good thing is, people who run linux are not generally entirely stupid, so they are aware of the temperature at least ... but to me, this is quite an important to make linux fesible for macbook pro users. I set my min speed to 3000rpm which is still relatively quiet, and then keep an eye on the temperature sensors. Obviously this is a temporary solution

**kosumi68** · April 27th, 2010

... and now intermittently i get errors reading from TG0T GPU transistor..

The TG0T is one of the nonexisting registers on the MBP5,4 that the provided applesmc DKMS package stopped trying to read. Are you perhaps still running the old applesmc module, or do you have a program reading that register, or did the module not properly recognize your model? Perhaps a

Code:

rmmod applesmc;
modprobe applesmc;
dmesg | grep applesmc:

will reveal what model is detected.

**m.prebble** · April 27th, 2010

That is probably the reason. I have libsensors and a gnome applet that displays temps on the status bar. Here is dmesg output:

Code:

[12163.540654] applesmc: driver unloaded.
[12180.099812] applesmc: Apple MacBook Pro 5 detected:
[12180.099819] applesmc:  - Model with accelerometer
[12180.099823] applesmc:  - Model with light sensors and backlight
[12180.099828] applesmc:  - Model with 20 temperature sensors
[12180.100786] applesmc: device has already been initialized (0xe0, 0xf8).
[12180.100791] applesmc: device successfully initialized.
[12180.110830] applesmc: 1 fans found.
[12180.114014] applesmc: driver successfully loaded.
[12180.541169] applesmc: light sensor data length set to 10
[12181.883072] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0

Thread: [SOLVED] MPB4,1/MBA 'wait status failed: c != 8' solved?

Thread Tools

Display

Re: [SOLVED] MPB4,1/MBA 'wait status failed: c != 8' solved?

Re: [SOLVED] MPB4,1/MBA 'wait status failed: c != 8' solved?

Re: [SOLVED] MPB4,1/MBA 'wait status failed: c != 8' solved?

Re: [SOLVED] MPB4,1/MBA 'wait status failed: c != 8' solved?

Re: [SOLVED] MPB4,1/MBA 'wait status failed: c != 8' solved?

Re: [SOLVED] MPB4,1/MBA 'wait status failed: c != 8' solved?

Re: [SOLVED] MPB4,1/MBA 'wait status failed: c != 8' solved?

Re: [SOLVED] MPB4,1/MBA 'wait status failed: c != 8' solved?

Re: [SOLVED] MPB4,1/MBA 'wait status failed: c != 8' solved?

Re: [SOLVED] MPB4,1/MBA 'wait status failed: c != 8' solved?

Tags for this Thread

Bookmarks

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions