If you reinstalled HPLIP, you might want to update the print settings between
the removal and (re)install.

Because HPLIP claims to set up printers for you and works alongside CUPS or whatever native printing system you are using. It may not sync all the printer instances.

Try running:

system-config-printer

Or for CUPS:

firefox http://127.0.0.1:631/admin

Check if everything is setup correctly there.