PDA

View Full Version : Free information based economy



ubuntu_demon
December 19th, 2004, 08:31 PM
nice article :
http://www.libervis.com/modules/wfsection/dossier-11.html

from this article :



Information cannot be traded as it does not have a trade value. This article explains this argument and presents an economic model that does deal with information, but does not involve it's trade.
.......
CONCLUSION:

Information is knowledge and as such it does not derive its value from within itself, but from the potential of its use. In its sole unusable existence, information is valueless. Information does not have an objective trade value because attempting to trade it inevitably results in value imbalance and unfair trade where the seller is ultimately in much greater gain than the buyer as he never actually deprives himself of the information he's "selling" and this deprivation is what is essential for a trade to be possible. As untradeable, pure information economy cannot exist, but the information *based* economy where the main object of trade is not information, but something else that is only involved with information such as it's distribution, usage support etc. This is clearly the only way our progressively information dependant society can properly function contrary to the monopoly driven and artificially created environment of "proprietary" information where the impossible tradeability is being forced upon us resulting in great disruption of trade value balance and human rights.

BWF89
December 19th, 2004, 09:32 PM
I'll have to read the whole article later but I think as free software & open source become more popular people will start to realise that mabye Microsoft isn't the American dream...

poptones
December 20th, 2004, 02:53 AM
The simplest illustration.. an edited quote from the article:

Does a hammer have any value? Probably the best answer that can be given to this question is "it depends" (but not in a sense you think). The value of a hammer is not solid and self-contained, it is dependant. I would say that a hammer in itself does not have any value because the value being attached to it does not come from the hammer itself but from the possibilities of it's use and the other values that it's use can produce. It only appears to have value.

Information has whatever value the market places upon it. To take the geeky example used in the article one step further I will turn directly to another episode of his very same fable - Star Trek: Insurrection, wherein our heroine asks of Picard "Where can a warp drive take us, except away from here?"

What value do plans for a warp drive have to a people that do not want to travel? Or to a people that do not have the technology to construct it (or to power it) even if given these plans? What value do muskets have to a society lacking the technology of gunpowder?

This article appears to have been someone's High School writing exercise - it spends a lot of time explaining the most basic concepts and even some of those are poorly argued. If you want to read some good articles on the new economy, go to FirstMonday.dk (http://firstmonday.dk) Look especially to "Content is not King," Bolt's "The Binary Proletariat" and ESR's "Cathedral & the Bazaar."

ubuntu_demon
December 20th, 2004, 09:24 AM
This article appears to have been someone's High School writing exercise - it spends a lot of time explaining the most basic concepts and even some of those are poorly argued. If you want to read some good articles on the new economy, go to FirstMonday.dk (http://firstmonday.dk) Look especially to "Content is not King," Bolt's "The Binary Proletariat" and ESR's "Cathedral & the Bazaar."

I did some searching on the site and some googling

cathedral & the bazaar (and some stuff about it)
http://www.firstmonday.org/issues/issue3_3/raymond/
http://firstmonday.org/issues/issue4_10/bezroukov/index.html
http://www.firstmonday.org/issues/issue4_11/raymond/index.html
http://www.firstmonday.org/issues/issue4_12/bezroukov/index.html

content is not king
http://www.firstmonday.org/issues/issue6_2/odlyzko/index.html

the binary proletariat
http://www.firstmonday.org/issues/issue5_5/bolt/index.html

I have a lot of reading to do :)