PDA

View Full Version : A Mac Ad You'll Never See



Sporkman
February 11th, 2008, 07:15 PM
Cute. Philisophical point made at the end.

http://online.wsj.com/article/SB120172199374929447.html?mod=yahoo_hs&ru=yahoo


A Mac Ad You'll Never See

How a Columnist's Transition to Apple
Hit a Snag Almost Before It Got Started

February 4, 2008

OPEN on a stark white background, with tinkly music in the background. On the left stands a stuffy-looking man in khakis, jacket and tie, wearing glasses. On the right, a laid-back guy in casual clothes. In the center, a bald, nondescript middle-aged guy.

Laid-Back Guy (morosely): Hi, I'm a Mac.

Stuffy-Looking Guy (smugly): And I'm a PC.

Nondescript Guy: And I'm a tech columnist.

Mac: I don't know what to say. This almost never happens.

PC (gleefully): What happened, Mac?

Mac: Well --

Columnist: What happened is, you broke. Three and a half weeks after I got you, I came home and your screen was dark and you wouldn't switch on. Thank goodness I'd just put PC aside, instead of putting him on the curb like I'd planned.

PC: Came crawling back, did you? So I guess that bright and shiny Mac world wasn't quite as wonderful as you thought it would be.

Columnist: No, actually it was pretty nice.

(PC looks at the camera, nonplussed.)

Columnist: After 25 years using PCs, I bought a 24-inch iMac in December. And I was impressed before I even plugged it in -- it came in one slim box, instead of a stack of them. I had it up and running in about three minutes, and was on my wireless network a minute after that.

PC: Why don't we skip ahead to the part where Mac breaks?

Mac (patiently): PC….

Columnist: And it was great clearing out all those wires and cords. I don't think I'd seen the floor under my desk in two years with all the mess down there.

PC: But surely it must have been strange, adapting to all the peculiar ways those people work.

Mac: PC….

Columnist: Yeah, it was weird for a while. I had trouble getting used to the idea that there was one status bar at the top of the screen, instead of one on top of every application window. And it took me a long time to figure out Apple-C instead of CTRL-C. I felt lost for a week or so, sure. But then --

PC: But tell me about the part where he breaks!

(Mac hangs head.)

Columnist: Calm down, PC. It took me a while, but I got all my stuff transferred -- mostly files for iTunes and Word and Photoshop. My biggest problem was with Mozy, the program I use for remote backup. I loved it on the PC, but it was really slow on the Mac. Brought everything to a crawl, and crashed sometimes.

Mac: I like working with lots of programs. But I can't always control --

Columnist: I know, Mac. I'm not blaming you. Mozy for Mac's in beta. (They say they're working on an issue with wireless backups for the Mac, and pointed me to a new software release.) And even that hasn't been so bad: I know once I get the initial backup finished, things will be a lot easier. Meanwhile, I felt like I'd really made the switch. I mean, iTunes was a revelation on the Mac --

PC: Revelation? Let's not get sacrilegious here!

Columnist: ITunes worked a lot more quickly and smoothly, how's that? My dad was even inspired by my example -- he got a MacBook. A couple of days later, he asked me what antivirus software he should get, and I heard myself saying, "You don't need it, Dad -- it's a Mac." It was my first Mac Guy moment. And I felt proud.

PC: And then he broke.

Mac: Oh, don't be cruel, PC.

Columnist: Yeah, I came home and you were broken.

(PC begins hopping up and down and clapping his hands.)

Mac: What was wrong with me?

Columnist: Bad power supply. I called Apple and they had me take you into the shop. I got you back a week later.

Mac: Wow, tough break. But you know, if something like this does happen with me within the first 90 days after you take me home, you get complimentary phone support.

(Mac looks off to the side.)

Mac: Hey, let me bring out one of our technical-support people! I think she'll be played by that girl from "Juno" --

Columnist: No offense, Mac, but I was hoping not to be acquainted with your technical-support folks quite so soon. I got an appointment at the Genius Bar in the Soho Apple store. It's a strange place, the Genius Bar. Everybody waiting for help looks kind of mournful, like they did something wrong.

PC (scoffing): Sounds like some kind of weird cult to me. I'd be careful.

Columnist: Please. If there were such a thing as a PC Genius Bar, people wouldn't be waiting quietly. They'd be rioting.

PC: Hey! I'm not the one who stopped working!

Columnist: Don't start with me, PC. How many times a week did you tell me you were low on virtual memory? And remember Windows ME? I've had tumbles down the stairs that were more fun than that.

PC: But that was a long time ago! You were happy with XP! That's what I don't understand, Jace. I know I was getting old -- I couldn't simultaneously run Photoshop and Excel and surf the Web and play that indie rock you're too old for. But you could have upgraded me! You could have bought a new me! What did I do to you that was so bad that you'd leave?

Columnist: It wasn't you, PC. It was me. I guess I just wanted to try something new. I loved my iPod, and iTunes changed my musical life. Then I got an AirPort Express, and I liked that too. And eventually, the fact that I liked all these Apple products made me wonder what I was missing. I thought it might be fun to play around with iMovie and GarageBand, you know? And since you two can share files really easily now, what was holding me back?

PC: Well, busted power supplies, for one.

Mac: PC, please. So did everything work out OK?

Columnist: I don't know, Mac, you tell me. You've been running for a week. I guess that's progress.

Mac: You know, I'm really sorry that happened. But I'm not sure you're being fair here. Our factories make a lot of me, and sometimes something goes wrong. I got fixed, it didn't cost you anything, and now I'm sure I'll work just fine for years to come.

Columnist: I hope you're right, Mac. And I'm sorry that I'm mad. But I mean, I switched. I saw all the ads and read about all the neat products and I read my own columns, and so finally I switched. And then three weeks later I'm lugging a busted iMac around Soho. I was just so disappointed.

Mac: Like I said, I'm sorry. But -- and I don't mean to be harsh here -- you're 38 years old. You've lived with computers your whole life. You've written this column for more than five years. I just wonder why, after all that, you're taking something like this so personally. We're both just machines….

PC: Wait a minute! He was the one in the shop. Why does he gets the big philosophical speech? These should be my lines.

Columnist: Fair point. Take it away, PC.

PC: Um, where were we? Oh. We're both just machines. We may look different, and we may do some things differently, but we're still just machines. We can be a big part of your life, but what computer you buy doesn't have anything to do with what kind of person you are. We're just computers, Jace. We're ways to get things done. It's silly to make us into anything more than that.

Mac: Couldn't have said it better myself, PC.

SomeGuyDude
February 11th, 2008, 07:22 PM
Any time I see an Apple sticker on someone's car, it's like a quick coded message that says "I'm an annoying person". Convenient time-saver, that.

intense.ego
February 11th, 2008, 10:12 PM
Any time I see an Apple sticker on someone's car, it's like a quick coded message that says "I'm an annoying person". Convenient time-saver, that.

Its the same with linux. you get some people who don't shut up about how good their OS is compared to another.

days_of_ruin
February 11th, 2008, 10:21 PM
LONG:lolflag:

fissionmailed
February 11th, 2008, 10:25 PM
Its the same with linux. you get some people who don't shut up about how good their OS is compared to another.

With Apples though, the fanboys seems to be more hhmm fanboyish.

fissionmailed
February 11th, 2008, 10:27 PM
Also, PC stands for personal computer. Really, I don't get why people say I have don't have a PC I have a Mac, it IS a personal computer....

I'll quit ranting now.

Istonian
February 11th, 2008, 10:30 PM
Its the same with linux. you get some people who don't shut up about how good their OS is compared to another.

Yeah, I hate the fanboys that say their distro is the best ever. It's sad that these people give a bad name to linux.

Mac people are waaaayyyyy worse though. I know a guy who switched to mac and he might as well sell his forehead for mac adspace. Never shuts up about mac.

tuebinger
February 11th, 2008, 10:31 PM
In twenty-five years he'll write another article about how he switched to Linux, maybe.

popch
February 11th, 2008, 10:33 PM
Also, PC stands for personal computer. Really, I don't get why people say I have don't have a PC I have a Mac, it IS a personal computer....

I'll quit ranting now.

"Back when" IBM was what Microsoft is today, and Microsoft was .. oh well.

"PC" (the Personal Computer) was IBM's tag line. It was treated like a Trade Mark. Compatible PCs used to be called 'Clones', or more explicitly 'PC Clones'.

Computers not compatible with those by IBM were not called 'PCs'.

fissionmailed
February 11th, 2008, 10:35 PM
"Back when" IBM was what Microsoft is today, and Microsoft was .. oh well.

"PC" (the Personal Computer) was IBM's tag line. It was treated like a Trade Mark. Compatible PCs used to be called 'Clones', or more explicitly 'PC Clones'.

Computers not compatible with those by IBM were not called 'PCs'.

O rly? hhmmm I'll have to do some research on it.

Thanks for the heads up.

SomeGuyDude
February 11th, 2008, 10:39 PM
Also, PC stands for personal computer. Really, I don't get why people say I have don't have a PC I have a Mac, it IS a personal computer....

I'll quit ranting now.

Simple. If they admitted that they were not arguing hardware, but rather software (the whole ad campaign is really OSX v Windows, after all), then Apple wouldn't be able to sell computers. They have to act like "Macs" and "PCs" are entirely different pieces of machinery.

And yeah, Linux guys are bad at times, but Apple's far worse since you have guys with their Macbooks and iPhones, etc.

popch
February 11th, 2008, 10:44 PM
Simple. If they admitted that they were not arguing hardware, but rather software (the whole ad campaign is really OSX v Windows, after all), then Apple wouldn't be able to sell computers..

If you had to keep your computer in the living room where it is seen, liked good design and had the cash to spare, you might buy an Apple computer for its wow factor. I think a few of those machines utterly beautiful.

As soon as I have enough time for the installation and instruction, I will install Ubuntu Linux on my wife's iBook.

Depressed Man
February 11th, 2008, 11:08 PM
Or you could still just design a PC with a nice case, put it in the living room. I'm not a fan of the way most Macs look. The only thing I've really liked about Macs (hardware wise) is the ability to power on the screen without a button (usually just swipe my hand across the power area). And the monitor itself.

Which Dell also has (similar sized one).

Neither monitor I can afford reasonably, when other expenses are taken into account.

AsoSako
February 11th, 2008, 11:12 PM
I must say no OS really satisfies me enough so that I could be "Super Proud" about it. I just don't understand people who have to think that they are superior because of an OS... It is indeed quite stupid. The truth is that one OS fits the needs of some and another the needs of others. Every single one has it's good and bad sides to it.

Sammi
February 12th, 2008, 12:15 AM
This made me think of an old article by aisyu: http://ubuntucat.wordpress.com/2005/07/04/mac-zealots-linux-zealots-and-windows-zealots/

It deals with win/mac/linux fanboyism. It's from 2005 and has got somewhat the same moral as the OP. Was an eye opener first time I read it.