jharris1993
February 20th, 2011, 10:39 PM
This is one of those questions where I highly suspect that the answer will be something like ". . .just stinks bein' you, kid."
My setup:
I have Ubuntu 10.04 x64 (desktop) installed on a computer with a bunch of SATA ports, including one e-SATA on the back
Because of the way the hardware works with these ports, the *external* port is the first SATA port, a second SATA port inside becomes #2, and a cluster of four ports (that can be made into a (ahem!) RAID array become ports 3 through 6.
All ports are configured as SATA (PATA emulation)
My boot drive is located on SATA-2 (the inside connector), a four disk "MD" raid array is located on SATA 3-6, and I have an external HD enclosure that I plug into the e-SATA connection.
With all six drives plugged in, they get ordered like this:
/dev/sda - External drive
/dev/sdb - Internal operating system drive (bootable)
/dev/sdc - RAID drive 1
/dev/sdd - RAID drive 2
/dev/sde - RAID drive 3
/dev/sdf - RAID drive4
Here's the problem:
If, for whatever reason, I decide to disconnect the external HD (/dev/sda), upon the next reboot everybody moves up a notch - making the boot drive /dev/sda, and the four RAID drives /dev/sdb - /dev/sde
This causes untold confusion - not only with myself, (I accidentally totally boffed a nicely configured Ubuntu install that I was working on, tweaking for days. Errrr!), but with the MD raid utillities because (via the mdadm.conf file) it expects the devices to be /dev/sdc - /dev/sdf - and when they all bump up a slot, the array fails to boot.
This is (IMHO) totally unacceptable because I would very much like to use that external SATA port to plug whatever I want into - like a USB port - especially since I have several HD docks that use eSATA, along with other external SATA devices.
I cannot use UUID's, because the four RAID drives do not have individual UUID's, they share the array-specific UUID established when the filesystem is generated.
What I would like to be able to do is assign certain logical positions to fixed device names.
Viz.: The boot drive as /dev/sda - the raid drives as /dev/sdb-sde, the eSATA as ../sdf and whatever I plug into a USB port come up as a device lower in the chain. (these would be allowed to change as needed) However I wold like the drive assignments for /dev/sda - /dev/sdf to be statically assigned.
I would especially like the devices to remain constant - despite the fact that they may be removed or not working - so that I can set up my system knowing that a particular drive will always remain where it is set to be - and if a drive fails, I can remove it and reboot (if necessary) without screwing up my entire configuration.
My setup:
I have Ubuntu 10.04 x64 (desktop) installed on a computer with a bunch of SATA ports, including one e-SATA on the back
Because of the way the hardware works with these ports, the *external* port is the first SATA port, a second SATA port inside becomes #2, and a cluster of four ports (that can be made into a (ahem!) RAID array become ports 3 through 6.
All ports are configured as SATA (PATA emulation)
My boot drive is located on SATA-2 (the inside connector), a four disk "MD" raid array is located on SATA 3-6, and I have an external HD enclosure that I plug into the e-SATA connection.
With all six drives plugged in, they get ordered like this:
/dev/sda - External drive
/dev/sdb - Internal operating system drive (bootable)
/dev/sdc - RAID drive 1
/dev/sdd - RAID drive 2
/dev/sde - RAID drive 3
/dev/sdf - RAID drive4
Here's the problem:
If, for whatever reason, I decide to disconnect the external HD (/dev/sda), upon the next reboot everybody moves up a notch - making the boot drive /dev/sda, and the four RAID drives /dev/sdb - /dev/sde
This causes untold confusion - not only with myself, (I accidentally totally boffed a nicely configured Ubuntu install that I was working on, tweaking for days. Errrr!), but with the MD raid utillities because (via the mdadm.conf file) it expects the devices to be /dev/sdc - /dev/sdf - and when they all bump up a slot, the array fails to boot.
This is (IMHO) totally unacceptable because I would very much like to use that external SATA port to plug whatever I want into - like a USB port - especially since I have several HD docks that use eSATA, along with other external SATA devices.
I cannot use UUID's, because the four RAID drives do not have individual UUID's, they share the array-specific UUID established when the filesystem is generated.
What I would like to be able to do is assign certain logical positions to fixed device names.
Viz.: The boot drive as /dev/sda - the raid drives as /dev/sdb-sde, the eSATA as ../sdf and whatever I plug into a USB port come up as a device lower in the chain. (these would be allowed to change as needed) However I wold like the drive assignments for /dev/sda - /dev/sdf to be statically assigned.
I would especially like the devices to remain constant - despite the fact that they may be removed or not working - so that I can set up my system knowing that a particular drive will always remain where it is set to be - and if a drive fails, I can remove it and reboot (if necessary) without screwing up my entire configuration.