Tom_ZeCat
June 3rd, 2010, 05:41 AM
I didn’t think I would ever need a tri-boot machine, but I do. I need a PC that gives me the choice of booting to Ubuntu 8.04, Windows 7 64-bit, or Windows XP 32-bit. My machine is already a dual boot with Windows 7 Ultimate and Ubuntu Hardy Heron. These two operating systems are on separate physical hard drives. Ubuntu is on the original 250 gig master drive and Win 7 is on the 1 TB slave drive. I installed each OS completely independently of the other with the other hard drive not plugged in. Originally, I set the PC up as an Ubuntu only PC on that one 250 gig drive. Later, when I needed Windows, I unplugged the 250 gig drive and installed Windows on the 1 TB one. Then I plugged the original drive back in and, in Ubuntu, edited the menu.lst file under /boot/grub, per the instructions in this post so that Grub would give me the menu choice of either Windows 7 or Ubuntu:
Dual Boot Two Hard Drives (http://ubuntuforums.org/showthread.php?t=179902&highlight=dualboot)
It works great. It was a wonderful way to install two OSes cleanly and independently of one another.
You must be wondering why on earth I would desire to add yet another operating system to the mix. It’s because of Quicken for Palm OS, the application that was once the answer to my prayers, but has lately been my nightmare. I used to never know how much money I had in the bank because I always lost track, never entering my receipts into Quicken. Then I got a Palm and put Quicken for Palm on it and always entered everything as soon as I bought it. I came home and synced with Quicken for Windows and thus always kept absolute track of my money.
Then Palm went out of fashion and so no sync drivers were written for any 64-bit OS. Yet for my photography work I need a PC with 4 gig of memory, which requires a 64-bit OS. I researched the issue and learned it can be done via Bluetooth into Windows 7, but I’ve had no luck getting it to work. I added Virtual PC to Win 7 and tried with Windows XP/64-bit, but also had no luck. Win XP/32 would not install under Virtual PC in Win 7. There’s probably a way to get this to work, but I’m spending a ton of time trying to solve it. Meanwhile my transactions are piling up on my Palm without getting synced into Quicken for Windows. I know for a fact that all this runs perfectly under Windows XP/32-bit.
I therefore plan to partition 200 gig of my 1 TB drive into a logical drive onto which I’ll install Windows XP/32-bit. Onto it will go all my Palm scheduling software and Quicken. When the computer boots up, I need to have the choice of Windows 7, Windows XP, or Ubuntu Hardy Heron. I’m hoping to keep the same basic setup I have now with the 250 gig Ubuntu hard drive as the master and the other one as the slave. I imagine I’ll need to edit the menu.lst file again. Here’s how it was edited previously, per the instructions in the Dual Boot Two Hard Drives (http://ubuntuforums.org/showthread.php?t=179902&highlight=dualboot) post:
title Windows 7
root (hd1,0)
savedefault
makeactive
map (hd0) (hd1)
map (hd1) (hd0)
chainloader +1
Do I just leave it like that? Then when I choose Windows and it goes over to the slave drive, will it give me the choice of Win 7 or Win XP? If anyone has advice on my turning this into a tri-boot, I would be grateful for it.
There is one other option, but thinking of it makes my head spin. I had heard there is Palm scheduling software for Linux that is capable of syncing with Palm devices. I could install that and then install WINE and Quicken for Windows under Linux. Thinking of that makes my head spin. It doesn’t seem like as good an option when I know for certain all my Palm stuff and Quicken run great under Windows XP/32.
Dual Boot Two Hard Drives (http://ubuntuforums.org/showthread.php?t=179902&highlight=dualboot)
It works great. It was a wonderful way to install two OSes cleanly and independently of one another.
You must be wondering why on earth I would desire to add yet another operating system to the mix. It’s because of Quicken for Palm OS, the application that was once the answer to my prayers, but has lately been my nightmare. I used to never know how much money I had in the bank because I always lost track, never entering my receipts into Quicken. Then I got a Palm and put Quicken for Palm on it and always entered everything as soon as I bought it. I came home and synced with Quicken for Windows and thus always kept absolute track of my money.
Then Palm went out of fashion and so no sync drivers were written for any 64-bit OS. Yet for my photography work I need a PC with 4 gig of memory, which requires a 64-bit OS. I researched the issue and learned it can be done via Bluetooth into Windows 7, but I’ve had no luck getting it to work. I added Virtual PC to Win 7 and tried with Windows XP/64-bit, but also had no luck. Win XP/32 would not install under Virtual PC in Win 7. There’s probably a way to get this to work, but I’m spending a ton of time trying to solve it. Meanwhile my transactions are piling up on my Palm without getting synced into Quicken for Windows. I know for a fact that all this runs perfectly under Windows XP/32-bit.
I therefore plan to partition 200 gig of my 1 TB drive into a logical drive onto which I’ll install Windows XP/32-bit. Onto it will go all my Palm scheduling software and Quicken. When the computer boots up, I need to have the choice of Windows 7, Windows XP, or Ubuntu Hardy Heron. I’m hoping to keep the same basic setup I have now with the 250 gig Ubuntu hard drive as the master and the other one as the slave. I imagine I’ll need to edit the menu.lst file again. Here’s how it was edited previously, per the instructions in the Dual Boot Two Hard Drives (http://ubuntuforums.org/showthread.php?t=179902&highlight=dualboot) post:
title Windows 7
root (hd1,0)
savedefault
makeactive
map (hd0) (hd1)
map (hd1) (hd0)
chainloader +1
Do I just leave it like that? Then when I choose Windows and it goes over to the slave drive, will it give me the choice of Win 7 or Win XP? If anyone has advice on my turning this into a tri-boot, I would be grateful for it.
There is one other option, but thinking of it makes my head spin. I had heard there is Palm scheduling software for Linux that is capable of syncing with Palm devices. I could install that and then install WINE and Quicken for Windows under Linux. Thinking of that makes my head spin. It doesn’t seem like as good an option when I know for certain all my Palm stuff and Quicken run great under Windows XP/32.