Last edited by snkiz; February 16th, 2012 at 12:05 AM.
Since a picture is worth a thousand words. Here is my desktop with gnome-session drawing the background, folderview widget, Marlin replacing Nautilus, and conky for info. (Screenlets could do everything I have here with conky, but that's no fun now is it. )
Last edited by snkiz; February 16th, 2012 at 12:27 AM. Reason: cranky uploader
I don't care of what manages desktop as long as it works good. I am just saying i read a lot of times on the internet replace Nautilus with Marlin. It could be done but then we would not have desktop management as we know it anymore. No right click -> send to Thunderbird for example from the desktop... This all would have to be done if same level of usefulness would want to be achieved. I just don't believe in short amount of time this will be done but it would take very short amount of time to replace Nautilus with Marlin that i agree.If you agree that the file manager isn't the best tool to manage the desktop (as even the xfce devs seem to.) Then you start exploring other ways to integrate.
I was talking about Ubuntu and i would be glad if i would be wrong.But really I was trying to illustrate that your claim that nobody does desktop management is false.
Again i was talking about (default) Ubuntu. And Unity Launcher is great "dock" but it is a different thing then what Nautilus provides in terms of desktop management? Gnome developers or Marlin developers could improve desktop management i agree on that. Gnome developers didn't and are not trying to AFAIK and Marlin developers probably are not thinking about desktop management. In the end the logical solution still is Nautilus.IMHO Docks are a better application for managing the desktop, its where they live and what they do is similar. Yes some are nothing more than simple launcher bars, but then you start getting into awn, cairo-dock, docky and even Unity and GS could be put in this category for their launcher functions. Cairo-dock is capable of managing a desktop, awn is too. heck properly configured they can both function as a shell. Unity and GS could do the job on their own, but its not a priority for them. (Good thing too doing everything under the kitchen sink leads to bloat.) Again those are examples of desktop management you said doesn't exist.
I agree nobody is doing it and now you see what i was talking about? Sane configuration would include this features i mentioned.All of that is stuff that nautilus does a poor job of now, its almost unsupported with the way nautilus development is going. Other solutions could do that as well. You know why they don't? Because its unnecessary feature bloat. Setup a sane configuration with a few options and leave it at that.
Does it support for example Send files -> Thunderbird?You're forgetting Folderview witch is not exclusive to screenlets btw. Folderview does everything nautilus does for the desktop only simplified.
They make better use if they are useful (more useful then what Nautilus provide). I could agree on that yes!Widgets make better use of the desktop than having what amounts to the giant open folder that nautilus provides ever did.
I said Unity Shell is best Shell right now (beside removal of Dodge). But this has little to do with improvements of desktop management i was talking about and Nautilus provides.Where exactly do you think the inspiration for much of Unity and GS came from? Had you shown Unity as it is now to Canonical three years, ago and said this should be default. They'd have said your off your nut. That's progress for ya.
You are basically talking about putting some widgets on the desktop aren't you? I like it but i don't know if this are sane defaults and i personal would not trade it for what Nautilus offers me because i can have that with Nautilus too if i use some widgets/Conky and stuff that will probably not be included by default any time soon and i don't know what sane defaults would be?Since a picture is worth a thousand words. Here is my desktop with gnome-session drawing the background, folderview widget, Marlin replacing Nautilus, and conky for info. (Screenlets could do everything I have here with conky, but that's no fun now is it. )
Now back to the point what i was saying:
-If u want to replace Nautilus with Marlin by default you have to have the solution for desktop management. Mentioned solutions in this thread did not convinced me they are better because i just don't see the level of integration Nautilus provides and i believe Dash and Indicators are for (default) "fancy stuff". Users that want to use widgets for some specific tasks can still do that?
-Desktop management that Nautilus provides AFAIK nobody is doing much about improving that. If i am wrong i am glad that i am.
Last edited by EgoGratis; February 16th, 2012 at 02:03 AM.