Interesting that none of the posts (in the survey) were moderated.
First, some time ago, aguafuertes asked for an access to jail to review threads that were removed for language and communications problems. It took a long time for us to finally deny jail access, for obvious reasons. In particular, threads in jail are directly confrontational, most of them infracted, and that would breach the members privacy regarding infractions and/or threads that are better gone and forgotten.
aguafuertes redesigned his proposal and we were all ok with it.
He could choose any thread from the public area. No feedback or "censorship" from us whatsoever.
I'm sure there are many threads/posts here that go below the radar, because we cannot read everything and they did not get reported. Such is life.
imho, the threads from the survey did not deserve any staff action and I did not think one minute about going back and cleaning them. But I'm mostly of the mellow kind
| My old and mostly abandoned blog |
Linux user #413984 ; Ubuntu user #178
J'aime les fraises.
Nighty night me lovelies!
this bug first ! |
| Using a ppa ? Please install ppa-purge from universe, you may need it should you want to revert packages back |
| No support requests / username changes by PM, thanks. |
bapoumba already explained how the threads were chosen (thanks!), and I'm actually quite happy that I had to redesign my proposal. I believe that the great majority of interactions, in which we'd label someone as "rude", is not of the extreme kind. I rather believe that in most cases, there are little details that make us perceive something as rude. And I definitely believe that in a international setting like ubuntuforums.org, these details will be "amplified", as many people don't use their mother tongue.Interesting that none of the posts (in the survey) were moderated.
This is what makes the moderator job so hard - people with different perceptions communicating. I want to show how different many posts can be perceived, even if the user had only one intention. And in most of these cases, I believe, being rude is not intentional.
I agree - from my point of view these threads are examples of miscommunication, but not of escalation. If moderators had to intervene in any thread where people have misunderstandings, it would be an impossible job. It is already tough arbitrating the extreme cases, where people with different understanding of humor, sarcasm and politeness each may have their valid points. But in these cases, the communication simply "died" without somebody personally affected - people walked away.imho, the threads from the survey did not deserve any staff action.
Yep, why stir up somethig that did not end in conflict. Actually I was a bit afraid that this survey might have this effect, but so far responses have been only positive, even from someone whose post is actually in the survey.and I did not think one minute about going back and cleaning them.
Sounds like a good informal conclusion: we all should be more mellowI'm mostly of the mellow kind
Wow - last night the number of participants who completed the survey really broke the 300 barrier! This community is amazing
The stats: http://blog.openinformation.org/atti...de-static.html
I've decided to run the survey 4 days longer, until September 30, so if you are interested and have not taken it yet, here are the links:
Just rate, mark and comment the single posts and complete the survey - that's all
Thanks to all participants!
done and done!
The local slangs also contribute to a different perception of rudeness and coolness.
PS: I don't want to insult anyone, this is a clear and quite common perception we get by this side of the atlantic ocean.
AMD Phenom II X3 720 Black Edition 2,8 GHz - GIGABYTE GA-MA770T-UD3P - 6 GB RAM Mushkin DDR3 1333 - ZOTAC GeForce 9800 GT 1 GB DDR3
Forum DOs and DON'Ts
Never assume that information you find using a search engine is up-to-date.