[SOLVED] MPB4,1/MBA 'wait status failed: c != 8' solved?

[kosumi68]

UPDATE 12DEC2011: Since FEB2011, most Macbook models should work out of the box, without patching the kernel. If you experience problems or suspect your machine is different somehow, please read on.

UPDATE 28APR2010: For the latest applesmc, see the applesmc-dkms package in the Mactel PPA: https://wiki.ubuntu.com/MactelSupportTeam/PPA

If you have a Mac that is yet unsupported by applesmc, please reply to this post, gathering the information below.

* Determine your exact mac model

sudo dmidecode -s system-product-name


* Run the applesmc-test.sh script (found below in this post) to get a picture of the performance before the patch

./applesmc-test.sh

(you may need to do 'chmod +x ./applesmc-test.sh' before it runs)

* Run the scan-smc.sh script (found below in this post), and attach the output.

sudo ./scan-smc.sh > scan-smc-MODEL.txt

(you may need to do 'chmod +x ./scan-smc.sh' before it runs)

After some time, a reply with a new version of applesmc-dkms attached will appear. Then please run applesmc-test.sh again. Once satisfactory, the change will be incorporated in the Mactel PPA, and a patch sent upstream.

For more information, see http://bitmath.org/code/applesmc-dkms/

[cyberdork33]

It might be helpful if there was a test app or something that could verify the functions. Do you know if there is one or maybe a procedure for testing with stuff that is available?

[cyberdork33]

Have you seen any of this?
http://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=news_item&px=NjcyOA

[kosumi68]

Have you seen any of this?
http://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=news_item&px=NjcyOA

Well, the patches referred to are from me, and today they made it to Andrew Morton's mm tree, so I guess I have seen it :-) Not this link though, thanks for the tip.

Cheers,
Henrik

[kosumi68]

It might be helpful if there was a test app or something that could verify the functions. Do you know if there is one or maybe a procedure for testing with stuff that is available?

I did not fully understand what you mean here, but if you think of a script that checks the availability of accelerometer, backlight, leds, fans, temperatures etc, that could be quite handy. However, currently the testing is about whether this works at all for some machines, which is easily verified by the number of errors in dmesg from applesmc.

[cyberdork33]

Well, the patches referred to are from me, and today they made it to Andrew Morton's mm tree, so I guess I have seen it :-) Not this link though, thanks for the tip.

Cheers,
HenrikThought so ;) I thought you'd like to see your work on phoronix.

I did not fully understand what you mean here, but if you think of a script that checks the availability of accelerometer, backlight, leds, fans, temperatures etc, that could be quite handy. However, currently the testing is about whether this works at all for some machines, which is easily verified by the number of errors in dmesg from applesmc.
Actually, I don't know of anything that uses the accelerometer... backlight should work with pommed, and the fan control files can be seen in the dev tree. You have a good point on the messages though.

[kosumi68]

EDIT 28APR2010: see first post in thread for current script versions [old version deleted].

On request, here is a small script that can be run to test the performance of applesmc on your computer. Simply run it in a terminal as a normal user. Cheers!

[kosumi68]

Binary for Intrepid running 2.6.27-3-generic on i386 available, see the first post.

[_mario_]

Hi,

thanks for figuring out how to get basic support. The 'c != 8'-problem seems to be solved ;-), but there are other issues on a MacBookPro 4 (Penryn):

Sep 21 21:38:07 snoopy kernel: [12118.120999] applesmc: Apple MacBook Pro detected:
Sep 21 21:38:07 snoopy kernel: [12118.121007] applesmc: - Model with accelerometer
Sep 21 21:38:07 snoopy kernel: [12118.121010] applesmc: - Model with light sensors and backlight
Sep 21 21:38:07 snoopy kernel: [12118.121014] applesmc: - Model with 12 temperature sensors
Sep 21 21:38:07 snoopy kernel: [12118.121739] applesmc: device has already been initialized (0xe0, >
Sep 21 21:38:07 snoopy kernel: [12118.121743] applesmc: device successfully initialized.
Sep 21 21:38:07 snoopy kernel: [12118.122039] applesmc: 2 fans found.
Sep 21 21:38:07 snoopy kernel: [12118.127281] input: applesmc as /devices/platform/applesmc.768/inp>
Sep 21 21:38:07 snoopy kernel: [12118.163212] Registered led device: smc::kbd_backlight
Sep 21 21:38:07 snoopy kernel: [12118.163257] applesmc: driver successfully loaded.
Sep 21 21:38:07 snoopy kernel: [12118.169154] applesmc: light sensor data length set to 6
[tons of:]
Sep 21 21:39:03 snoopy kernel: [12130.824745] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[... and sometimes:]
Sep 21 21:39:04 snoopy kernel: [12131.267745] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 1
Sep 21 21:46:49 snoopy kernel: [12268.875983] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 4

while running your test script:

accelerometer: present, readable, output: (2,10,233)
fan: present, readable, output: 1000
light: present, readable, output: (15,44)
leds: present,
led: readable, output: 0
temperatures: present,
temperature: readable, output: 44750
temperature: readable, output: 35000
temperature: not readable
temperature: not readable
temperature: readable, output: 33750
temperature: readable, output: 51000
temperature: readable, output: 48500
temperature: readable, output: 50250
temperature: not readable
temperature: not readable
temperature: readable, output: 49750
temperature: readable, output: 42500
performance: reading all temperatures
fail frequency: 1.000
reads per second: 16


Probably due to errors reading non-existent temperature sensors (how many does this model have?).

But light sensors, keyboard backlight and fan speeds seems to work most of the time, although the GNOME applet sometimes complains about missing data/unreadable fan speeds.

ciao,
Mario

[_mario_]

those temperature sensors not readable are: 1, 6, 7, 12 and the sensors command shows:

applesmc-isa-0300
Adapter: ISA adapter
Left side : 999 RPM (min = 1000 RPM)
Right side : 996 RPM (min = 1000 RPM)
temp2: +33.8°C
temp3: +51.2°C
temp4: +49.2°C
temp5: +51.2°C
temp8: +50.2°C
temp9: +42.5°C
temp10: +44.8°C
temp11: +35.0°C

[kosumi68]

_mario_,

thanks for the report! I have a comment, a question and a script:

1. Occasional read errors are quite natural, given that there is a finite probability (p) for every read to fail (and it will stay that way unless the applesmc sensor interface introduces buffered reading). The probability of *all* 12 sensors being ok in a read is (1-p)^12, which quickly becomes small if p is only slightly greater than zero.

2. The diagnostics suggests some sensors truly are not readable, but to make sure, one can try reading a single value, like

cat /sys/devices/platform/applesmc.768/temp1_input


3. To make sure exactly what sensors are there, try running the attached script as root (courtesy of Nicolas Boichat).

[cyberdork33]

1. Occasional read errors are quite natural, given that there is a finite probability (p) for every read to fail (and it will stay that way unless the applesmc sensor interface introduces buffered reading). The probability of *all* 12 sensors being ok in a read is (1-p)^12, which quickly becomes small if p is only slightly less than unity.
free stats lesson today... :)

[_mario_]

2. The diagnostics suggests some sensors truly are not readable, but to make sure, one can try reading a single value.


Yes, as stated in my previous post the sensors 1, 6, 7 & 12 are always not readable.


3. To make sure exactly what sensors are there, try running the attached script as root (courtesy of Nicolas Boichat).


I attached the output of this command. Btw: What does this mean? Is there any documentation one can read?

thanks & ciao,
Mario

[kosumi68]

I attached the output of this command. Btw: What does this mean? Is there any documentation one can read?


Great! The sensors list shows that MBP4,1 has 12 sensors, but four of them have different names from the older MBPs, precisely the ones you reported as failing. I will submit a patch for it shortly.

Documentation? :-) This script was given to me by the applesmc maintainer. Together with the kernel code, it is about the extent of what I know. There might be some general documentation regarding the sensor codes out there, but Apple-specific details are few and far between.

[kosumi68]

_mario_,

Please find enclosed a patch to fix the temperature sensor list on MBP4,1, and a precompiled 2.6.27-3-generic i386 binary including that patch.

Hope this helps!

[_mario_]

Please find enclosed a patch to fix the temperature sensor list on MBP4,1, and a precompiled 2.6.27-3-generic i386 binary including that patch.
Hope this helps!
Thanks. I applied the patch to the source file and compiled myself, so now it seems to work:

performance: reading all temperatures
fail frequency: .262
reads per second: 71
and:

applesmc-isa-0300
Adapter: ISA adapter
Left side :1006 RPM (min = 1000 RPM)
Right side :1002 RPM (min = 1000 RPM)
temp1: +31.8°C
temp2: +50.0°C
temp3: +47.5°C
temp4: +53.0°C
temp5: +49.5°C
temp6: +70.0°C
temp7: +38.5°C
temp8: +48.5°C
temp9: +41.0°C
temp10: +42.0°C
temp11: +43.8°C
temp12: +33.5°C
There are still some messages left (as you already pointed out) we shouldn't be concerned about:

Sep 22 15:35:01 snoopy kernel: [ 1468.433884] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
Sep 22 15:35:01 snoopy kernel: [ 1468.460291] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 1
I asked for documentation to better understand how this chip works, and to get to know which temperature sensor is where inside the machine...

ciao,
Mario

[kosumi68]

performance: reading all temperatures
fail frequency: .262
reads per second: 71



Excellent, I will send the patch to kernel.org.

Thanks!

PS. I am switching this thread to solved - always wanted to do that :-P

[_mario_]

Hi again,

maybe we should also change the SYSFS directory from /sys/class/leds/smc::kbd_backlight to /sys/class/leds/smc:kbd_backlight. At least this is where pommed (version 1.16~mactel1) searchs the files. Or is it some bug in pommed? What is right? The current stable upstream kernel version still uses the former path.

ciao,
Mario

[cyberdork33]

Hi again,

maybe we should also change the SYSFS directory from /sys/class/leds/smc::kbd_backlight to /sys/class/leds/smc:kbd_backlight. At least this is where pommed (version 1.16~mactel1) searchs the files. Or is it some bug in pommed? What is right? The current stable upstream kernel version still uses the former path.

ciao,
Mario
the mactel compile is old. Try this one:
http://packages.debian.org/lenny/pommed

[kosumi68]

Not only did the name change from leds/smc:kbd_backlight to leds/smc::kbd_backlight as you noticed, but it lately (intrepid) changed to leds:smc::kbd_backlight... Somewhat confusing.

Btw, with the help of Bob McElrath, the applesmc reading errors have lately been further improved; I am attaching the latest version for Intrepid (applesmc.c.zip at the bottom). To get a version usable in Hardy, simply apply the trivial patch below.

Cheers!


--- upstream-2.6/drivers/hwmon/applesmc.c 2008-09-29 17:50:30.000000000 +0200
+++ hardy/drivers/hwmon/applesmc.c 2008-09-27 17:07:33.000000000 +0200
@@ -565,7 +565,7 @@ static ssize_t applesmc_light_show(struc
ret = applesmc_get_key_type(LIGHT_SENSOR_LEFT_KEY, query);
if (ret)
goto out;
- data_length = clamp_val(query[0], 0, 10);
+ data_length = query[0];
printk(KERN_INFO "applesmc: light sensor data length set to "
"%d\n", data_length);
}
@@ -951,7 +951,7 @@ static ssize_t applesmc_key_at_index_sto
}

static struct led_classdev applesmc_backlight = {
- .name = "smc::kbd_backlight",
+ .name = "smc:kbd_backlight",
.default_trigger = "nand-disk",
.brightness_set = applesmc_brightness_set,
};

[kosumi68]

All patches to applesmc are in Intrepid kernel 2.6.27-6.9-20, meaning they will appear in the next kernel release. They will also appear upstream in 2.6.28.

[kosumi68]

Support for the latest Macbooks can from now on be found in the applesmc-dkms package in the mactel PPA: http://ubuntuforums.org/showpost.php?p=6027135&postcount=143

[AleXit]

Hello,
I've Intrepid on a Macbook4,1.
I've installed applesmc-dkms package as suggested, but I get this:
ale@MacBook:~$ dmesg | grep applesmc
[ 18.117779] applesmc: Apple MacBook detected:
[ 18.117783] applesmc: - Model with accelerometer
[ 18.117785] applesmc: - Model without light sensors and backlight
[ 18.117787] applesmc: - Model with 10 temperature sensors
[ 18.121107] applesmc: device has already been initialized (0xe0, 0x00).
[ 18.121109] applesmc: device successfully initialized.
[ 18.121910] applesmc: 1 fans found.
[ 18.125350] input: applesmc as /devices/platform/applesmc.768/input/input13
[ 18.160105] applesmc: driver successfully loaded.
[ 20.806727] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 20.842791] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 26.833031] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 56.154154] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 56.191405] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 291.957947] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 291.994704] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
(and so on)
This is the result of the script:
ale@MacBook:~/Desktop$ ./applesmc-test.sh
accelerometer: present, readable, output: (-12,5,270)
fan: present, readable, output: 2024
light: not present
leds: not present
temperatures: present,
temperature: not readable
temperature: readable, output: 30250
temperature: readable, output: 51750
temperature: readable, output: 49000
temperature: readable, output: 52250
temperature: readable, output: 48250
temperature: not readable
temperature: readable, output: 49750
temperature: readable, output: 49250
temperature: readable, output: 49000
performance: reading all temperatures
fail frequency: 1.000
reads per second: 12
Does applesmc-dkms support my mac model?
Thanks!

[kosumi68]

Hello,
I've Intrepid on a Macbook4,1.
[...]
Does applesmc-dkms support my mac model?
Thanks!

Check the last post in this thread: http://ubuntuforums.org/showthread.php?t=964840

[calebio]

On request, here is a small script that can be run to test the performance of applesmc on your computer. Simply run it in a terminal as a normal user. Cheers!

Here is the output of this script for my iMac6,1:
accelerometer: not present
fan: present, readable, output: 600
light: not present
leds: not present
temperatures: present,
temperature: readable, output: 129000
temperature: readable, output: 25500
temperature: readable, output: 50000
temperature: readable, output: 60750
temperature: readable, output: 50250
temperature: readable, output: 48500
temperature: not readable
temperature: readable, output: 41500
temperature: not readable
performance: reading all temperatures
fail frequency: 1.000
reads per second: 13

[kosumi68]

Here is the output of this script for my iMac6,1:


Great. Would you like to also report the output of 'sudo scan-smc.sh', please? The script is here: http://ubuntuforums.org/attachment.php?attachmentid=85996&d=1224442499.

Thanks!

[calebio]

Great. Would you like to also report the output of 'sudo scan-smc.sh', please? The script is here: http://ubuntuforums.org/attachment.php?attachmentid=85996&d=1224442499.

Thanks!

Attached. It's all greek to me....

[kosumi68]

Attached. It's all greek to me....

Here is a package with support for iMac6. Please run the test script again, and post the output here. If you want to appear in the kernel logs as Tested-by, send me a private message with name and email. Thanks!

[calebio]

Here is a package with support for iMac6. Please run the test script again, and post the output here. If you want to appear in the kernel logs as Tested-by, send me a private message with name and email. Thanks!

Oh, hey, look at that! More and better output:
accelerometer: not present
fan: present, readable, output: 600
light: not present
leds: not present
temperatures: present,
temperature: readable, output: 63250
temperature: readable, output: 26500
temperature: readable, output: 129000
temperature: readable, output: 41500
temperature: readable, output: 129000
temperature: readable, output: 58000
temperature: readable, output: 47500
temperature: readable, output: 47000
temperature: readable, output: 46000
temperature: readable, output: 37000
performance: reading all temperatures
fail frequency: 0
reads per second: 83

[kosumi68]

Oh, hey, look at that! More and better output:


Great! Here is the upstream patch: http://lkml.org/lkml/2008/11/9/93

[dxlr8r]

My Mac Pro:
dmidecode -s system-product-name
MacPro3,1


Nothing with applesmc works. When I try to modprobe it it says:
modprobe applesmc
FATAL: Error inserting applesmc (/lib/modules/2.6.27-7-generic/kernel/drivers/hwmon/applesmc.ko): No such device]

But the file IS there :)

sudo applesmc-test.sh'
accelerometer:[: 23: /sys/devices/platform/applesmc.768/position: unexpected operator
not present
fan: [: 38: /sys/devices/platform/applesmc.768/fan1_output: unexpected operator
not present
light: [: 53: /sys/devices/platform/applesmc.768/light: unexpected operator
not present
leds: not present
temperatures: not present
performance: not performed


sudo scan-smc.sh
cd: 7: can't cd to /sys/devices/platform/applesmc.768/
/home/simen/Desktop/scan-smc.sh: 60: let: not found
/home/simen/Desktop/scan-smc.sh: 60: let: not found
/home/simen/Desktop/scan-smc.sh: 60: let: not found
/home/simen/Desktop/scan-smc.sh: 60: let: not found
/home/simen/Desktop/scan-smc.sh: 60: let: not found
/home/simen/Desktop/scan-smc.sh: 60: let: not found
... Continues into infinity

[kosumi68]

My Mac Pro:
dmidecode -s system-product-name
MacPro3,1



Attached is a debian package that should recognize your machine as a MacPro, so that testing can begin. :-)

[dxlr8r]

Will it work with Ubuntu 32 bit? I'm planning on installing 32 bit since I do alot of 32 bits compiling. Especially with Wine since I use Linux to play games, since I don't do Windows...

[kosumi68]

Will it work with Ubuntu 32 bit?

By design, DKMS packages work for all kernel versions and all architectures.

[cyberdork33]

By design, DKMS packages work for all kernel versions and all architectures.

It essentially compiles it specifically for your system in fact.

[dxlr8r]

When will these mactel patches be standard in the Linux kernel? I use Arch Linux, and tried Ubuntu on my Mac Pro... And to be honest I miss Arch Linux :) Ubuntu is great, but I prefer pacman over aptitude.

[kosumi68]

When will these mactel patches be standard in the Linux kernel? I use Arch Linux, and tried Ubuntu on my Mac Pro... And to be honest I miss Arch Linux :) Ubuntu is great, but I prefer pacman over aptitude.

It will become standard as soon as somebody like yourself report results for the tests described in this thread. :-) I know you did try it once already, thanks, but did you notice the dkms package I attached soon after your report? If you could please go through the same procedure again, it should make a big difference. Thanks!

[cyberdork33]

When will these mactel patches be standard in the Linux kernel? I use Arch Linux, and tried Ubuntu on my Mac Pro... And to be honest I miss Arch Linux :) Ubuntu is great, but I prefer pacman over aptitude.

They are usually submitted upstream as soon as they are verified working properly. They then have to make it into your distro repos though.

[hyperboloid]

I hate to reopen this thread, but something appears to have gone wrong with applesmc, which I've been using happily for 6 weeks or so. But now I notice:

me@laptop:~$ dmesg | grep applesmc
[ 15.985311] applesmc: Apple MacBook Pro 4 detected:
[ 15.985315] applesmc: - Model with accelerometer
[ 15.985316] applesmc: - Model with light sensors and backlight
[ 15.985318] applesmc: - Model with 12 temperature sensors
[ 16.040746] applesmc: device successfully initialized (0xe0, 0x00).
[ 16.040749] applesmc: device successfully initialized.
[ 16.041703] applesmc: 2 fans found.
[ 16.044824] input: applesmc as /devices/platform/applesmc.768/input/input12
[ 16.072193] applesmc: driver successfully loaded.
[ 78.238117] applesmc: light sensor data length set to 6
[ 1147.177492] applesmc: wait status failed: 4 != 5
[ 1148.582721] applesmc: wait status failed: 4 != 5
[ 1150.231960] applesmc: wait status failed: 4 != 5
[ 1156.748686] applesmc: wait status failed: 4 != 5
[ 1167.871484] applesmc: wait status failed: 4 != 5
[ 1742.456120] applesmc: wait status failed: 4 != 5
[ 2937.358790] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 1
[ 2940.498053] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 1
[ 2946.811860] applesmc: wait status failed: 4 != 0
[ 3068.287151] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3068.643088] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3069.096076] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 4
[ 3069.133776] applesmc: command failed: 12 -> e
[ 3069.270963] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3069.842272] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3070.389057] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3071.026342] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3071.081471] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3071.372196] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3071.435559] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3071.842024] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3071.936563] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3071.992569] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3072.071499] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3072.148329] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3072.655319] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3073.197051] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3073.540999] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3074.115340] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3074.219745] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3074.602889] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3074.648441] applesmc: wait status failed: 4 != 5
[ 3075.016513] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3075.159835] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3075.232513] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3075.558157] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3075.620663] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0

Here is a very weird thing. The script "applesmc-test.sh" produced some errors when I first ran it, and then when I ran it again after some time had passed, it seemed to work again. Same with the script "scan-smc.sh" which gave an infinite loop of error messages (something about "0: #KEY [4-ui32]" over and over) at first, then ran OK later. I did nothing in between except browse the forums.

I'm attaching the outputs from these scripts after they started working.

[cyberdork33]

Did an update appear in the Ubuntu repo? You might need to rebuild the mactel PPA package again if so to re-replace the update.

[kosumi68]

Here is a very weird thing. The script "applesmc-test.sh" produced some errors when I first ran it, and then when I ran it again after some time had passed, it seemed to work again. Same with the script "scan-smc.sh" which gave an infinite loop of error messages (something about "0: #KEY [4-ui32]" over and over) at first, then ran OK later. I did nothing in between except browse the forums.

I'm attaching the outputs from these scripts after they started working.

The reading of the SMC registers never was an exact science, and reading errors are still normal. By the look of it, you have a tiny but non-zero fail ratio on your machine, resulting in the test script sometimes reporting no errors, sometimes some errors. Nothing to worry about, as long as it seems to operate normally.

[m.prebble]

Hi guys,

I have a MBP 5,4, and have problems with the SMC not regulating the fan temperature. After digging through various forums, I have only found people having the same issue. For others, they have no problem. This is very frustrating, as I can't rely on thermal mgmt when using Linux - I am afraid to come back and find the a rogue app has cooked my CPU.

I have followed the steps in the top of this forum. Please find the output of this attached:


0: #KEY [4-ui32] 00000134 [...4]
1: $Adr [4-ui32] 00000300 [....]
2: $Num [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
3: +LKS [1-flag] 07 [.]
4: ACCL [1-ui8 ]
5: ACEN [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
6: ACFP [1-flag] 01 [.]
7: ACIC [2-ui16] 0e10 [..]
8: ACID [8-ch8*] 8598d028c00310e7 [...(....]
9: ACIN [1-flag] 01 [.]
10: ACLM [1-ui8 ] 55 [U]
11: AL! [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
12: ALA0 [6-{ala] ca1effd602d9 [......]
13: ALA1 [6-{ala] 30a4021f0315 [0.....]
14: ALA2 [6-{ala] 0cea02d40396 [......]
15: ALA3 [6-{ala] 0389036103dc [...a..]
16: ALA4 [6-{ala] 00ee03bc0400 [......]
17: ALA5 [6-{ala] 04fcfff30400 [......]
18: ALAT [4-{alt] 002b0308 [.+..]
19: ALI0 [4-{ali] 04000f00 [....]
20: ALI1 [4-{ali] 00000000 [....]
21: ALP0 [4-ui16] 13330780 [.3..]
22: ALP1 [4-ui16] 00000000 [....]
23: ALRV [2-ui16] 0001 [..]
24: ALSC [16-{alc] 00c8009603e8000f0001015e1d030106 [...........^....]
25: ALSF [2-fp1f] 4b44 [KD]
26: ALSL [2-ui16] 004d [.M]
27: ALT0 [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
28: ALT1 [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
29: ALTH [10-{alr] 00320070025200140041 [.2.p.R...A]
30: ALV0 [10-{alv] 010102ed01990013466a [........Fj]
31: ALV1 [10-{alv] 00010000000000000000 [..........]
32: AUPO [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
33: B0AC [2-si16] 0000 [..]
34: B0AV [2-ui16] 3097 [0.]
35: B0Ad [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
36: B0Al [2-ui16] ffff [..]
37: B0Am [1-ui8 ] 10 [.]
38: B0Ar [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
39: B0As [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
40: B0At [2-ui16] 0960 [.`]
41: B0Au [2-ui16] 0960 [.`]
42: B0Az [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
43: B0BI [1-ui8 ] 51 [Q]
44: B0CM [2-ui16] 0119 [..]
45: B0CT [2-ui16] 0060 [.`]
46: B0FC [2-ui16] 1958 [.X]
47: B0FV [2-ui16] 0003 [..]
48: B0LI [2-ui16] 7fff [..]
49: B0PS [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
50: B0RI [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
51: B0RM [2-ui16] 18e3 [..]
52: B0SN [13-ch8*] 57303932364245373737375641 [W0926BE7777VA]
53: B0St [2-ui16] 40e0 [@.]
54: B0TF [2-ui16] ffff [..]
55: BATP [1-flag] 00 [.]
56: BBAD [1-flag] 00 [.]
57: BBIN [1-flag] 01 [.]
58: BC1V [2-ui16] 1032 [.2]
59: BC2V [2-ui16] 1033 [.3]
60: BC3V [2-ui16] 1031 [.1]
61: BCHA [1-ui8 ] 02 [.]
62: BCHB [1-ui8 ] 06 [.]
63: BCHF [1-ui8 ]
64: BCHG [1-ui8 ]
65: BCHL [1-ui8 ]
66: BCHO [1-ui8 ] 1f [.]
67: BCHP [1-ui8 ] 13 [.]
68: BCHR [1-ui8 ] 3a [:]
69: BCHT [1-ui8 ] 06 [.]
70: BCHX [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
71: BCLM [1-ui8 ] 64 [d]
72: BEZL [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
73: BILB [1-ui8 ] 1f [.]
74: BILO [2-ui8 ] 1f12 [..]
75: BNCM [1-ui8 ]
76: BNCR [1-ui8 ] 04 [.]
77: BNum [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
78: BRSC [2-ui16] 0063 [.c]
79: BSAC [1-ui8 ] 33 [3]
80: BSIn [1-ui8 ] 42 [B]
81: BTIL [2-ui16] 0780 [..]
82: BTTI [1-ui8 ] 02 [.]
83: BTVI [1-ui8 ] 03 [.]
84: BTVR [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
85: BTVT [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
86: CH2S [1-flag] 00 [.]
87: CHBI [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
88: CHBV [2-ui16] 3130 [10]
89: CHGC [2-ui16] 0040 [.@]
90: CHGD [1-flag]
91: CHGI [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
92: CHGV [2-ui16] 3130 [10]
93: CHPV [2-si16] 3130 [10]
94: CLK! [1-ui8 ]
95: CLKC [10-{clc] 00000e1000000e10198c [..........]
96: CLKH [8-{clh] 0000708000011940 [..p....@]
97: CLKS [2-fp1f] 198c [..]
98: CLKT [4-ui32] 000144d3 [..D.]
99: CLSD [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
100: CLWK [2-ui16] 0071 [.q]
101: CRCB [4-ui32] f0255a54 [.%ZT]
102: CRCU [4-ui32]
103: DPLM [3-{lim]
104: EPCA [4-ui32] 00007000 [..p.]
105: EPCF [1-flag] 01 [.]
106: EPCI [4-ui32] 03e00700 [....]
107: EPCV [2-ui16] 0001 [..]
108: EPMA [4-ch8*] 00006080 [..`.]
109: EPMI [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
110: EPUA [4-ui32] 00006000 [..`.]
111: EPUF [1-flag] 01 [.]
112: EPUI [4-ui32] 03e00001 [....]
113: EPUV [2-ui16] 0001 [..]
114: EVCT [2-ui16] 4a0a [J.]
115: EVMD [4-ui32]
116: EVRD [32-ch8*] 730000046f013d33631a7281050092c536c4000003011fca62 b736050100bf10 [s...o.=3c.r.....6.......b.6.....]
117: F0Ac [2-fpe2] 2eef [..]
118: F0ID [16-{fds] 00010c004c6566742073696465202000 [....Left side .]
119: F0Mn [2-fpe2] 2ee0 [..]
120: F0Mt [2-ui16] f400 [..]
121: F0Mx [2-fpe2] 5910 [Y.]
122: F0Tg [2-fpe2] 2ee0 [..]
123: FNum [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
124: FPhz [2-si16]
125: FS! [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
126: HBWK [1-flag]
127: HDBS [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
128: HDST [4-hex_] 00000000 [....]
129: HDSW [4-hex_] 0dcb0db0 [....]
130: IBIR [2-fp2e] 0000 [..]
131: IBIr [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
132: IC0C [2-fp6a] 0851 [.Q]
133: IC1C [2-fp4c] 047b [.{]
134: ID0R [2-fp3d] 2966 [)f]
135: ID0r [2-ui16] 2740 ['@]
136: ID1R [2-fp6a] 0000 [..]
137: ID1r [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
138: IH0C [2-fp4c] 0000 [..]
139: IH0r [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
140: IN0R [2-fp6a] 085c [.\]
141: IN1R [2-fp6a] 00e6 [..]
142: IO0C [2-fp4c] 0000 [..]
143: IO0r [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
144: IP0R [2-fp4c] 0241 [.A]
145: IP0r [2-ui16] 0380 [..]
146: IW0C [2-fp4c] 0000 [..]
147: IW0r [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
148: LAcN [1-ui8 ]
149: LAtN [2-ui16]
150: LCCN [1-ui8 ] e0 [.]
151: LCCQ [1-ui8 ] 0b [.]
152: LCKA [1-ui8 ] 6f [o]
153: LCSA [1-ui8 ] 28 [(]
154: LCTN [1-ui8 ] 59 [Y]
155: LCTQ [1-ui8 ] a0 [.]
156: LDSP [1-flag]
157: LKSB [2-{lkb]
158: LS! [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
159: LSCF [10-{lsc] 00c80190800002020020 [......... ]
160: LSDD [8-{lsd] 0002000300030019 [........]
161: LSDU [8-{lsd] 0003000200140003 [........]
162: LSFD [6-{lsf] 00000004008c [......]
163: LSFU [6-{lsf] 00000004008c [......]
164: LSLB [2-{pwm] ffff [..]
165: LSLF [2-{pwm] 0000 [..]
166: LSLN [2-{pwm] ffff [..]
167: LSOF [1-flag] 01 [.]
168: LSOO [1-flag]
169: LSPV [2-{pwm] 0000 [..]
170: LSRB [1-flag]
171: LSSB [2-{lso]
172: LSSE [1-flag] 01 [.]
173: LSSS [2-{lso]
174: LSSV [2-ui16] ffff [..]
175: LSUP [1-ui8 ]
176: MACA [4-ui32] 00000000 [....]
177: MACM [1-flag] 01 [.]
178: MACR [32-ch8*]
179: MOCF [2-ui16] 8300 [..]
180: MOCN [2-ui16] e0f8 [..]
181: MOHD [1-ui8 ] 14 [.]
182: MOHT [2-sp78] 01c0 [..]
183: MOLD [1-ui8 ] 14 [.]
184: MOLT [2-sp78] 0060 [.`]
185: MOST [2-ui16] 8003 [..]
186: MOVX [2-sp78] 0016 [..]
187: MOVY [2-sp78] ffea [..]
188: MOVZ [2-sp78] 0102 [..]
189: MO_X [2-sp78] 0016 [..]
190: MO_Y [2-sp78] ffea [..]
191: MO_Z [2-sp78] 0101 [..]
192: MSAL [1-ui8 ] 4b [K]
193: MSAR [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
194: MSAc [2-fp88] 0000 [..]
195: MSAg [2-fp88] 0000 [..]
196: MSAm [2-fp88] 0000 [..]
197: MSBC [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
198: MSBP [2-ui16] 1191 [..]
199: MSBc [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
200: MSBp [2-ui16] 1191 [..]
201: MSDI [1-flag] 00 [.]
202: MSDW [1-flag]
203: MSFG [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
204: MSLD [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
205: MSPA [2-fp6a] 0000 [..]
206: MSPC [1-ui8 ] 06 [.]
207: MSPS [2-ui16] 0001 [..]
208: MSPZ [1-ui8 ] 08 [.]
209: MSPs [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
210: MSSD [1-si8 ] 05 [.]
211: MSSE [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
212: MSSF [4-ui32] 00000001 [....]
213: MSSP [1-si8 ] 05 [.]
214: MSSS [1-{mss] 00 [.]
215: MSTC [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
216: MSTM [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
217: MSTc [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
218: MSTg [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
219: MSTm [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
220: MSWR [1-ui8 ]
221: MSXC [4-ch8*] 00000000 [....]
222: MSXD [16-ch8*] 00000000000000000000000000000000 [................]
223: MSXK [32-ch8*] 0102030405060708090a0b0c0d0e0f10111200000000000000 00000000000000 [................................]
224: MSXN [1-ui8 ] 12 [.]
225: MSXS [4-ch8*] 0205070a [....]
226: MSXb [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
227: MSXc [4-ch8*] 00000000 [....]
228: MSXd [16-ch8*] 00000000000000000000000000000000 [................]
229: MSXk [32-ch8*] 0102030405060708090a0b0c0d0e0f10111213141516171819 1a1b1c1d1e1f20 [............................... ]
230: MSXm [2-ui16] 0008 [..]
231: MSXn [1-ui8 ] 28 [(]
232: MSXs [4-ui32] 0103060c [....]
233: NACK [1-flag]
234: NATJ [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
235: NATi [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
236: NOPB [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
237: NTOK [1-ui8 ]
238: ONMI [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
239: OWCT [2-ui16] 000e [..]
240: PBIC [2-fp88] 0000 [..]
241: PC0C [2-fp88] 03cd [..]
242: PC1C [2-fp88] 05bb [..]
243: PD0R [2-fp88] 17d3 [..]
244: PD1R [2-fp88] 0000 [..]
245: PH0C [2-fp88] 0000 [..]
246: PHPC [2-fp88] 0845 [.E]
247: PN0R [2-fp88] 0234 [.4]
248: PN1R [2-fp88] 0056 [.V]
249: PO0C [2-fp88] 0000 [..]
250: PP0R [2-fp88] 01c4 [..]
251: PTHC [2-fp88] 20fb [ .]
252: PW0C [2-fp88] 0000 [..]
253: RBr [8-ch8*] 6b31396900000000 [k19i....]
254: REV [6-{rev] 01490f000002 [.I....]
255: RMde [1-char] 41 [A]
256: RPlt [8-ch8*] 6b31396900000000 [k19i....]
257: RSvn [4-ui32] 00006446 [..dF]
258: RVBF [6-{rev] 01490f000002 [.I....]
259: RVUF [6-{rev] 01490f000002 [.I....]
260: SAS! [4-hex_]
261: SBS! [2-ui16]
262: SCIA [2-ui16] 03f8 [..]
263: SCIL [1-ui8] 00 [.]
264: SDRd [2-ui16]
265: SIP [1-ui8] 01 [.]
266: SIS! [2-hex_]
267: SIT! [2-hex_]
268: SM0x [2-ui16] 7c40 [|@]
269: SM0y [2-ui16] 8340 [.@]
270: SM0z [2-ui16] b3c0 [..]
271: SMBC [5-ch8*]
272: SMBG [1-ui8 ]
273: SMBR [32-ch8*]
274: SMBS [2-ch8*]
275: SMBW [32-ch8*]
276: SPH0 [2-ui16] 2992 [).]
277: SPHS [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
278: SPHT [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
279: SPHZ [1-ui8]
280: SPS! [2-ui16]
281: TB0T [2-sp78] 1e4c [.L]
282: TB1T [2-sp78] 1e4c [.L]
283: TB2T [2-sp78] 1d00 [..]
284: TB3T [2-sp78] 0000 [..]
285: TC0D [2-sp78] 3760 [7`]
286: TC0F [2-sp78] 2f56 [/V]
287: TC0P [2-sp78] 3100 [1.]
288: TN0D [2-sp78] 3620 [6 ]
289: TN0P [2-sp78] 2ea0 [..]
290: TTF0 [2-sp78] 3100 [1.]
291: Th2H [2-sp78] 2dc0 [-.]
292: Ts0P [2-sp78] 1c40 [.@]
293: Ts0S [2-sp78] 2444 [$D]
294: UPRC [2-ui16] 0845 [.E]
295: VBOC [2-fp6a] 0000 [..]
296: VBOc [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
297: VC0C [2-fp2e] 43bc [C.]
298: VC0c [2-ui16] 5a40 [Z@]
299: VN0R [2-fp2e] 3fff [?.]
Can anyone possibly shed some light on this for me? fan1_manual is 0. Kind regards,

Here is my dmsg output:


(Many more before this)
[ 2866.895374] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2866.928232] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2866.961124] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2866.997974] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2867.040855] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2867.073667] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2867.109340] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2867.143917] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2867.176778] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2867.209802] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2867.246832] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2867.288783] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2867.321608] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2867.357032] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2867.390128] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2867.422935] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2867.455741] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2867.497112] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2867.538676] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2867.571490] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2867.607085] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2867.639999] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2867.672884] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2867.706434] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2867.743508] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2867.785468] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2867.818277] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2867.855732] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2867.893148] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2867.925998] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2867.958804] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2867.995312] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2868.037271] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2868.070078] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2868.105554] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2868.139460] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2868.172276] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2868.205087] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2868.242107] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2868.286271] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2868.319083] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2868.354592] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2868.387518] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2868.420333] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2868.453144] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2868.491307] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2868.532904] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2868.565717] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2868.601705] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2868.635068] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2868.668262] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2868.701093] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2868.738888] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2868.782822] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2868.815631] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2868.853941] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2868.887535] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2868.920346] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2868.953156] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2868.989667] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2869.031752] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 2869.064560] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3044.253372] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3046.171132] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3046.226736] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3046.282905] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3046.563544] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3046.772481] applesmc: wait status failed: 4 != 5
[ 3047.179824] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3047.364443] applesmc: wait status failed: 4 != 5
[ 3047.576426] applesmc: wait status failed: 4 != 5
[ 3047.789169] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 4
[ 3047.824862] applesmc: command failed: 12 -> e
[ 3047.872516] applesmc: command failed: 10 -> 8
[ 3047.945687] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3048.444321] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3048.845766] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3048.928590] applesmc: wait status failed: 4 != 5
[ 3049.770745] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3049.839235] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3050.130181] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3050.200773] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3050.665543] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3050.728575] applesmc: wait status failed: 4 != 5
[ 3050.851919] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3050.922045] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3051.036258] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3051.150109] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3051.254577] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3052.037991] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3052.648339] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3053.045371] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3053.177547] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3053.831860] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3053.893642] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3053.995580] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3054.075667] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3054.158045] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3054.288659] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3054.347425] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3054.418522] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3054.489607] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3054.565982] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3054.696608] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0
[ 3054.755403] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0



Marcus

[kosumi68]

Thanks for providing the data. Please find attached a package for testing the MBP5,4 settings. I have to ask again if this is indeed a MacBook Pro? Is so, the 5,4 model has only one fan, which might explain one or two things.

Output of the test scripts after unpacking and installing this package followed by a reboot would be greatly appreciated.

Cheers!

[m.prebble]

Hi,

Thank you very much for taking the time to investigate this with me. Yep, definitely macbook pro, 5.4 model according to dmidecode.

Installed the package, here is the output. Unfortunately the fan still stayed static at 2000rpm throughout the testing.



accelerometer: present, readable, output: (7,43,253)
fan: present, readable, output: 2000
light: present, readable, output: (2,0)
leds: present,
led: readable, output: 100
temperatures: present,
temperature: readable, output: 49000
temperature: readable, output: 40750
temperature: readable, output: 26250
temperature: readable, output: 34500
temperature: readable, output: 27250
temperature: readable, output: 27250
temperature: readable, output: 27000
temperature: readable, output: 0
temperature: readable, output: 49250
temperature: readable, output: 43250
temperature: readable, output: 45250
temperature: readable, output: 50000
temperature: readable, output: 43500
performance: reading all temperatures
fail frequency: .002
reads per second: 62



0: #KEY [4-ui32] 00000134 [...4]
1: $Adr [4-ui32] 00000300 [....]
2: $Num [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
3: +LKS [1-flag] 07 [.]
4: ACCL [1-ui8 ]
5: ACEN [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
6: ACFP [1-flag] 01 [.]
7: ACIC [2-ui16] 0e10 [..]
8: ACID [8-ch8*] 8598d028c00310e7 [...(....]
9: ACIN [1-flag] 01 [.]
10: ACLM [1-ui8 ] 55 [U]
11: AL! [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
12: ALA0 [6-{ala] ca1effd602d9 [......]
13: ALA1 [6-{ala] 30a4021f0315 [0.....]
14: ALA2 [6-{ala] 0cea02d40396 [......]
15: ALA3 [6-{ala] 0389036103dc [...a..]
16: ALA4 [6-{ala] 00ee03bc0400 [......]
17: ALA5 [6-{ala] 04fcfff30400 [......]
18: ALAT [4-{alt] 002b0308 [.+..]
19: ALI0 [4-{ali] 04000f00 [....]
20: ALI1 [4-{ali] 00000000 [....]
21: ALP0 [4-ui16] 13330780 [.3..]
22: ALP1 [4-ui16] 00000000 [....]
23: ALRV [2-ui16] 0001 [..]
24: ALSC [16-{alc] 00c8009603e8000f0001015e1d030106 [...........^....]
25: ALSF [2-fp1f] 3873 [8s]
26: ALSL [2-ui16] 0030 [.0]
27: ALT0 [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
28: ALT1 [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
29: ALTH [10-{alr] 00320070025200140041 [.2.p.R...A]
30: ALV0 [10-{alv] 010101cd00fa000c1296 [..........]
31: ALV1 [10-{alv] 00010000000000000000 [..........]
32: AUPO [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
33: B0AC [2-si16] 0000 [..]
34: B0AV [2-ui16] 3091 [0.]
35: B0Ad [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
36: B0Al [2-ui16] ffff [..]
37: B0Am [1-ui8 ] 10 [.]
38: B0Ar [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
39: B0As [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
40: B0At [2-ui16] 0960 [.`]
41: B0Au [2-ui16] 0960 [.`]
42: B0Az [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
43: B0BI [1-ui8 ] 51 [Q]
44: B0CM [2-ui16] 0119 [..]
45: B0CT [2-ui16] 0060 [.`]
46: B0FC [2-ui16]
47: B0FV [2-ui16] 0003 [..]
48: B0LI [2-ui16] 7fff [..]
49: B0PS [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
50: B0RI [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
51: B0RM [2-ui16] 1936 [.6]
52: B0SN [13-ch8*] 57303932364245373737375641 [W0926BE7777VA]
53: B0St [2-ui16] 40e0 [@.]
54: B0TF [2-ui16] ffff [..]
55: BATP [1-flag] 00 [.]
56: BBAD [1-flag] 00 [.]
57: BBIN [1-flag] 01 [.]
58: BC1V [2-ui16] 1030 [.0]
59: BC2V [2-ui16] 1031 [.1]
60: BC3V [2-ui16] 1030 [.0]
61: BCHA [1-ui8 ] 02 [.]
62: BCHB [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
63: BCHF [1-ui8 ]
64: BCHG [1-ui8 ]
65: BCHL [1-ui8 ]
66: BCHO [1-ui8 ] 1f [.]
67: BCHP [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
68: BCHR [1-ui8 ] 3a [:]
69: BCHT [1-ui8 ] 06 [.]
70: BCHX [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
71: BCLM [1-ui8 ] 64 [d]
72: BEZL [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
73: BILB [1-ui8 ] 1f [.]
74: BILO [2-ui8 ] 1f0e [..]
75: BNCM [1-ui8 ]
76: BNCR [1-ui8 ] 04 [.]
77: BNum [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
78: BRSC [2-ui16] 0062 [.b]
79: BSAC [1-ui8 ] 33 [3]
80: BSIn [1-ui8 ] 42 [B]
81: BTIL [2-ui16] 0780 [..]
82: BTTI [1-ui8 ] 02 [.]
83: BTVI [1-ui8 ] 03 [.]
84: BTVR [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
85: BTVT [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
86: CH2S [1-flag] 00 [.]
87: CHBI [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
88: CHBV [2-ui16] 3138 [18]
89: CHGC [2-ui16] 0040 [.@]
90: CHGD [1-flag]
91: CHGI [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
92: CHGV [2-ui16] 3130 [10]
93: CHPV [2-si16] 3130 [10]
94: CLK! [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
95: CLKC [10-{clc] 00000e1000000e10198c [..........]
96: CLKH [8-{clh] 0000708000011940 [..p....@]
97: CLKS [2-fp1f] 8000 [..]
98: CLKT [4-ui32] 0000e03b [...;]
99: CLSD [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
100: CLWK [2-ui16] 0076 [.v]
101: CRCB [4-ui32] f0255a54 [.%ZT]
102: CRCU [4-ui32]
103: DPLM [3-{lim]
104: EPCA [4-ui32] 00007000 [..p.]
105: EPCF [1-flag] 01 [.]
106: EPCI [4-ui32] 03e00700 [....]
107: EPCV [2-ui16] 0001 [..]
108: EPMA [4-ch8*] 00006080 [..`.]
109: EPMI [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
110: EPUA [4-ui32] 00006000 [..`.]
111: EPUF [1-flag] 01 [.]
112: EPUI [4-ui32] 03e00001 [....]
113: EPUV [2-ui16] 0001 [..]
114: EVCT [2-ui16] 0505 [..]
115: EVMD [4-ui32]
116: EVRD [32-ch8*] 2303fa0001014a8d2304fa0001014a8df60601000000d83c76 0600000200858e [#.....J.#.....J........<v.......]
117: F0Ac [2-fpe2] 1f19 [..]
118: F0ID [16-{fds] 00010c004c6566742073696465202000 [....Left side .]
119: F0Mn [2-fpe2] 1f40 [.@]
120: F0Mt [2-ui16] f400 [..]
121: F0Mx [2-fpe2] 5910 [Y.]
122: F0Tg [2-fpe2] 1f40 [.@]
123: FNum [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
124: FPhz [2-si16]
125: FS! [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
126: HBWK [1-flag] 00 [.]
127: HDBS [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
128: HDST [4-hex_] 00000000 [....]
129: HDSW [4-hex_] 0dcd0db2 [....]
130: IBIR [2-fp2e] 0000 [..]
131: IBIr [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
132: IC0C [2-fp6a] 0dcd [..]
133: IC1C [2-fp4c] 06f1 [..]
134: ID0R [2-fp3d] 2e5d [.]]
135: ID0r [2-ui16] 2b80 [+.]
136: ID1R [2-fp6a] 0000 [..]
137: ID1r [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
138: IH0C [2-fp4c] 0000 [..]
139: IH0r [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
140: IN0R [2-fp6a] 087b [.{]
141: IN1R [2-fp6a] 00e9 [..]
142: IO0C [2-fp4c] 0000 [..]
143: IO0r [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
144: IP0R [2-fp4c] 0241 [.A]
145: IP0r [2-ui16] 0380 [..]
146: IW0C [2-fp4c] 0000 [..]
147: IW0r [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
148: LAcN [1-ui8 ]
149: LAtN [2-ui16]
150: LCCN [1-ui8 ] a5 [.]
151: LCCQ [1-ui8 ] 84 [.]
152: LCKA [1-ui8 ] 68 [h]
153: LCSA [1-ui8 ] 76 [v]
154: LCTN [1-ui8 ] 7b [{]
155: LCTQ [1-ui8 ] de [.]
156: LDSP [1-flag]
157: LKSB [2-{lkb]
158: LS! [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
159: LSCF [10-{lsc] 00c80190800002020020 [......... ]
160: LSDD [8-{lsd] 0002000300030019 [........]
161: LSDU [8-{lsd] 0003000200140003 [........]
162: LSFD [6-{lsf] 00000004008c [......]
163: LSFU [6-{lsf] 00000004008c [......]
164: LSLB [2-{pwm] ffff [..]
165: LSLF [2-{pwm] 0000 [..]
166: LSLN [2-{pwm] ffff [..]
167: LSOF [1-flag] 01 [.]
168: LSOO [1-flag]
169: LSPV [2-{pwm] 0000 [..]
170: LSRB [1-flag]
171: LSSB [2-{lso]
172: LSSE [1-flag] 01 [.]
173: LSSS [2-{lso]
174: LSSV [2-ui16] ffff [..]
175: LSUP [1-ui8 ]
176: MACA [4-ui32] 00000000 [....]
177: MACM [1-flag] 01 [.]
178: MACR [32-ch8*]
179: MOCF [2-ui16] 8300 [..]
180: MOCN [2-ui16] e0f8 [..]
181: MOHD [1-ui8 ] 14 [.]
182: MOHT [2-sp78] 01c0 [..]
183: MOLD [1-ui8 ] 14 [.]
184: MOLT [2-sp78] 0060 [.`]
185: MOST [2-ui16] 8003 [..]
186: MOVX [2-sp78] 0005 [..]
187: MOVY [2-sp78] 002b [.+]
188: MOVZ [2-sp78] 0100 [..]
189: MO_X [2-sp78] 0002 [..]
190: MO_Y [2-sp78] 002c [.,]
191: MO_Z [2-sp78] 0100 [..]
192: MSAL [1-ui8 ] 4b [K]
193: MSAR [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
194: MSAc [2-fp88] 0000 [..]
195: MSAg [2-fp88] 0000 [..]
196: MSAm [2-fp88] 0000 [..]
197: MSBC [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
198: MSBP [2-ui16] 0fe4 [..]
199: MSBc [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
200: MSBp [2-ui16] 0fe4 [..]
201: MSDI [1-flag] 00 [.]
202: MSDW [1-flag]
203: MSFG [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
204: MSLD [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
205: MSPA [2-fp6a] 0000 [..]
206: MSPC [1-ui8 ] 06 [.]
207: MSPS [2-ui16] 0001 [..]
208: MSPZ [1-ui8 ] 08 [.]
209: MSPs [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
210: MSSD [1-si8 ] 03 [.]
211: MSSE [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
212: MSSF [4-ui32] 00000001 [....]
213: MSSP [1-si8 ] 05 [.]
214: MSSS [1-{mss] 00 [.]
215: MSTC [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
216: MSTM [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
217: MSTc [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
218: MSTg [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
219: MSTm [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
220: MSWR [1-ui8 ]
221: MSXC [4-ch8*] 00000000 [....]
222: MSXD [16-ch8*] 00000000000000000000000000000000 [................]
223: MSXK [32-ch8*] 0102030405060708090a0b0c0d0e0f10111200000000000000 00000000000000 [................................]
224: MSXN [1-ui8 ] 12 [.]
225: MSXS [4-ch8*] 0205070a [....]
226: MSXb [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
227: MSXc [4-ch8*] 00000000 [....]
228: MSXd [16-ch8*] 00000000000000000000000000000000 [................]
229: MSXk [32-ch8*] 0102030405060708090a0b0c0d0e0f10111213141516171819 1a1b1c1d1e1f20 [............................... ]
230: MSXm [2-ui16] 0008 [..]
231: MSXn [1-ui8 ] 28 [(]
232: MSXs [4-ui32] 0103060c [....]
233: NACK [1-flag]
234: NATJ [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
235: NATi [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
236: NOPB [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
237: NTOK [1-ui8 ]
238: ONMI [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
239: OWCT [2-ui16] 0010 [..]
240: PBIC [2-fp88] 0000 [..]
241: PC0C [2-fp88] 0211 [..]
242: PC1C [2-fp88] 0398 [..]
243: PD0R [2-fp88] 15ce [..]
244: PD1R [2-fp88] 0000 [..]
245: PH0C [2-fp88] 0000 [..]
246: PHPC [2-fp88]
247: PN0R [2-fp88] 021d [..]
248: PN1R [2-fp88] 0057 [.W]
249: PO0C [2-fp88] 0000 [..]
250: PP0R [2-fp88] 01c4 [..]
251: PTHC [2-fp88] 20fb [ .]
252: PW0C [2-fp88] 0000 [..]
253: RBr [8-ch8*] 6b31396900000000 [k19i....]
254: REV [6-{rev] 01490f000002 [.I....]
255: RMde [1-char] 41 [A]
256: RPlt [8-ch8*] 6b31396900000000 [k19i....]
257: RSvn [4-ui32] 00006446 [..dF]
258: RVBF [6-{rev] 01490f000002 [.I....]
259: RVUF [6-{rev] 01490f000002 [.I....]
260: SAS! [4-hex_]
261: SBS! [2-ui16]
262: SCIA [2-ui16] 03f8 [..]
263: SCIL [1-ui8] 00 [.]
264: SDRd [2-ui16]
265: SIP [1-ui8] 01 [.]
266: SIS! [2-hex_]
267: SIT! [2-hex_]
268: SM0x [2-ui16] 8000 [..]
269: SM0y [2-ui16] 7680 [v.]
270: SM0z [2-ui16] b2c0 [..]
271: SMBC [5-ch8*]
272: SMBG [1-ui8 ]
273: SMBR [32-ch8*]
274: SMBS [2-ch8*]
275: SMBW [32-ch8*]
276: SPH0 [2-ui16] 2a60 [*`]
277: SPHS [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
278: SPHT [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
279: SPHZ [1-ui8]
280: SPS! [2-ui16]
281: TB0T [2-sp78] 1b99 [..]
282: TB1T [2-sp78] 1b99 [..]
283: TB2T [2-sp78] 1b4c [.L]
284: TB3T [2-sp78] 0000 [..]
285: TC0D [2-sp78] 3740 [7@]
286: TC0F [2-sp78] 2b97 [+.]
287: TC0P [2-sp78] 2de0 [-.]
288: TN0D [2-sp78] 3320 [3 ]
289: TN0P [2-sp78] 2ba0 [+.]
290: TTF0 [2-sp78] 3100 [1.]
291: Th2H [2-sp78] 29a0 [).]
292: Ts0P [2-sp78] 1ac0 [..]
293: Ts0S [2-sp78] 22cd [".]
294: UPRC [2-ui16] 0845 [.E]
295: VBOC [2-fp6a] 0000 [..]
296: VBOc [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
297: VC0C [2-fp2e] 450e [E.]
298: VC0c [2-ui16] 4d40 [M@]
299: VN0R [2-fp2e] 3fff [?.]


I am happy to try anything more to get this solved.

Kind regards,

Marcus

[kosumi68]

Thanks, I take it there are fewer errors in dmesg? If so, it is a valid kernel patch, although for a different problem. If you want your name to appear as a tester in the kernel logs, please send me a private message with your full name and email address, and I will include it in the patch.

Just to get a clean baseline, did you try to set the /sys/devices/platform/applesmc.768/fan1_manual to one, then to zero again, after applying the package? Just to rule out that stopping reading of non-existing temperature sensors did not somehow magically solve the problem. I would also consider resetting the SMC (support.apple.com/kb/HT3964?viewlocale=en_US).

[kosumi68]

Looking at the data again I realize Apple added even more sensors to the new machines, so the scan-smc.sh script needs to be changed slightly. Modify the line starting with "END=" to

END=400

and run the script again - you should see more entrys after the last one (299: VN0R).

[kosumi68]

Looking even more at the data and comparing to other models, it seems one fan register (F0Sf) has been dropped for the new models MB51, MBA21, MBP51, MBP54. That register is commonly referred to as "safe speed".

Because the register has been removed, it is likely that Apple changed the way fan control works. It could well be that the SMC overheat protection that keeps the other models cool enough under Linux was removed and replaced by something else. Anyone's guess at this point.

In practise, it means the fan might have to be regulated by the OS for all those newer models. Are there any new mac owners out there that beg to differ?

[m.prebble]

Kosumi68, thank you again for your continued efforts on this. In reply to your previous message re: dmsg output, no, this is not the case... and now intermittently i get errors reading from TG0T GPU transistor..

But the number has changed again now:


marcus@marcus-ubuntu:~/scripts$ dmesg | tail
[ 7340.889817] applesmc: wait status failed: 4 != 0
[ 7648.893822] applesmc: wait status failed: 4 != 0
[ 9082.888785] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 1
[ 9452.889228] applesmc: wait status failed: 4 != 0
[ 9518.894479] applesmc: wait status failed: 4 != 0
[10050.887675] applesmc: wait status failed: 4 != 0
[10092.895570] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 1
[10114.896571] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 1
[10292.890494] applesmc: wait status failed: 4 != 0
[10344.887784] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 1




here is the updated script output:

0: #KEY [4-ui32] 00000134 [...4]
1: $Adr [4-ui32] 00000300 [....]
2: $Num [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
3: +LKS [1-flag] 07 [.]
4: ACCL [1-ui8 ]
5: ACEN [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
6: ACFP [1-flag] 00 [.]
7: ACIC [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
8: ACID [8-ch8*] 0000000000000000 [........]
9: ACIN [1-flag] 00 [.]
10: ACLM [1-ui8 ] 55 [U]
11: AL! [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
12: ALA0 [6-{ala] ca1effd602d9 [......]
13: ALA1 [6-{ala] 30a4021f0315 [0.....]
14: ALA2 [6-{ala] 0cea02d40396 [......]
15: ALA3 [6-{ala] 0389036103dc [...a..]
16: ALA4 [6-{ala] 00ee03bc0400 [......]
17: ALA5 [6-{ala] 04fcfff30400 [......]
18: ALAT [4-{alt] 002b0308 [.+..]
19: ALI0 [4-{ali] 04000f00 [....]
20: ALI1 [4-{ali] 00000000 [....]
21: ALP0 [4-ui16] 13330780 [.3..]
22: ALP1 [4-ui16] 00000000 [....]
23: ALRV [2-ui16] 0001 [..]
24: ALSC [16-{alc] 00c8009603e8000f0001015e1d030106 [...........^....]
25: ALSF [2-fp1f] 4b44 [KD]
26: ALSL [2-ui16] 004d [.M]
27: ALT0 [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
28: ALT1 [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
29: ALTH [10-{alr] 00320070025200140041 [.2.p.R...A]
30: ALV0 [10-{alv] 01010228010b00135312 [...(....S.]
31: ALV1 [10-{alv] 00010000000000000000 [..........]
32: AUPO [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
33: B0AC [2-si16] fa1a [..]
34: B0AV [2-ui16] 2f62 [/b]
35: B0Ad [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
36: B0Al [2-ui16] ffff [..]
37: B0Am [1-ui8 ] 10 [.]
38: B0Ar [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
39: B0As [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
40: B0At [2-ui16] 0960 [.`]
41: B0Au [2-ui16] 0960 [.`]
42: B0Az [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
43: B0BI [1-ui8 ] 51 [Q]
44: B0CM [2-ui16] 0119 [..]
45: B0CT [2-ui16] 0060 [.`]
46: B0FC [2-ui16] 19b1 [..]
47: B0FV [2-ui16] 0003 [..]
48: B0LI [2-ui16] 7fff [..]
49: B0PS [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
50: B0RI [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
51: B0RM [2-ui16] 1869 [.i]
52: B0SN [13-ch8*] 57303932364245373737375641 [W0926BE7777VA]
53: B0St [2-ui16] 40e0 [@.]
54: B0TF [2-ui16] ffff [..]
55: BATP [1-flag] 01 [.]
56: BBAD [1-flag] 00 [.]
57: BBIN [1-flag] 01 [.]
58: BC1V [2-ui16] 0fca [..]
59: BC2V [2-ui16] 0fcf [..]
60: BC3V [2-ui16] 0fca [..]
61: BCHA [1-ui8 ] 02 [.]
62: BCHB [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
63: BCHF [1-ui8 ]
64: BCHG [1-ui8 ]
65: BCHL [1-ui8 ]
66: BCHO [1-ui8 ] 1f [.]
67: BCHP [1-ui8 ] 0d [.]
68: BCHR [1-ui8 ] 3a [:]
69: BCHT [1-ui8 ] 06 [.]
70: BCHX [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
71: BCLM [1-ui8 ] 64 [d]
72: BEZL [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
73: BILB [1-ui8 ] 1f [.]
74: BILO [2-ui8 ] 1f12 [..]
75: BNCM [1-ui8 ]
76: BNCR [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
77: BNum [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
78: BRSC [2-ui16] 005f [._]
79: BSAC [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
80: BSIn [1-ui8 ] 40 [@]
81: BTIL [2-ui16] 0780 [..]
82: BTTI [1-ui8 ] 02 [.]
83: BTVI [1-ui8 ] 03 [.]
84: BTVR [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
85: BTVT [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
86: CH2S [1-flag] 00 [.]
87: CHBI [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
88: CHBV [2-ui16] 3138 [18]
89: CHGC [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
90: CHGD [1-flag]
91: CHGI [2-ui16] 0080 [..]
92: CHGV [2-ui16] 3130 [10]
93: CHPV [2-si16] 3130 [10]
94: CLK! [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
95: CLKC [10-{clc] 00000e1000000e10198c [..........]
96: CLKH [8-{clh] 0000708000011940 [..p....@]
97: CLKS [2-fp1f] 8000 [..]
98: CLKT [4-ui32] 0001086c [...l]
99: CLSD [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
100: CLWK [2-ui16] 0076 [.v]
101: CRCB [4-ui32] f0255a54 [.%ZT]
102: CRCU [4-ui32]
103: DPLM [3-{lim]support.apple.com/kb/HT3964?viewlocale=en_US
104: EPCA [4-ui32] 00007000 [..p.]
105: EPCF [1-flag] 01 [.]
106: EPCI [4-ui32] 03e00700 [....]
107: EPCV [2-ui16] 0001 [..]
108: EPMA [4-ch8*] 00006080 [..`.]
109: EPMI [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
110: EPUA [4-ui32] 00006000 [..`.]
111: EPUF [1-flag] 01 [.]
112: EPUI [4-ui32] 03e00001 [....]
113: EPUV [2-ui16] 0001 [..]
114: EVCT [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
115: EVMD [4-ui32]
116: EVRD [32-ch8*] 2303fa0001014a8d2304fa0001014a8df60601000000d83c76 0600000200858e [#.....J.#.....J........<v.......]
117: F0Ac [2-fpe2] 2edc [..]
118: F0ID [16-{fds] 00010c004c6566742073696465202000 [....Left side .]
119: F0Mn [2-fpe2] 2ee0 [..]
120: F0Mt [2-ui16] f400 [..]
121: F0Mx [2-fpe2] 5910 [Y.]
122: F0Tg [2-fpe2] 2ee0 [..]
123: FNum [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
124: FPhz [2-si16]
125: FS! [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
126: HBWK [1-flag] 00 [.]
127: HDBS [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
128: HDST [4-hex_] 00000000 [....]
129: HDSW [4-hex_] 0dcd0db2 [....]
130: IBIR [2-fp2e] 0000 [..]
131: IBIr [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
132: IC0C [2-fp6a] 0e2c [.,]
133: IC1C [2-fp4c] 0776 [.v]
134: ID0R [2-fp3d] 0000 [..]
135: ID0r [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
136: ID1R [2-fp6a] 0000 [..]
137: ID1r [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
138: IH0C [2-fp4c] 0000 [..]
139: IH0r [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
140: IN0R [2-fp6a] 07c9 [..]
141: IN1R [2-fp6a] 00e6 [..]
142: IO0C [2-fp4c] 0000 [..]
143: IO0r [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
144: IP0R [2-fp4c] 1df8 [..]
145: IP0r [2-ui16] 3500 [5.]
146: IW0C [2-fp4c] 0000 [..]
147: IW0r [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
148: LAcN [1-ui8 ]
149: LAtN [2-ui16]
150: LCCN [1-ui8 ] 41 [A]
151: LCCQ [1-ui8 ] 5f [_]
152: LCKA [1-ui8 ] 61 [a]
153: LCSA [1-ui8 ] 0f [.]
154: LCTN [1-ui8 ] 7b [{]
155: LCTQ [1-ui8 ] a2 [.]
156: LDSP [1-flag]
157: LKSB [2-{lkb]
158: LS! [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
159: LSCF [10-{lsc] 00c80190800002020020 [......... ]
160: LSDD [8-{lsd]
161: LSDU [8-{lsd] 0003000200140003 [........]
162: LSFD [6-{lsf] 00000004008c [......]
163: LSFU [6-{lsf] 00000004008c [......]
164: LSLB [2-{pwm] ffff [..]
165: LSLF [2-{pwm] 0000 [..]
166: LSLN [2-{pwm] ffff [..]
167: LSOF [1-flag] 01 [.]
168: LSOO [1-flag]
169: LSPV [2-{pwm] 0000 [..]
170: LSRB [1-flag]
171: LSSB [2-{lso]
172: LSSE [1-flag] 01 [.]
173: LSSS [2-{lso]
174: LSSV [2-ui16] ffff [..]
175: LSUP [1-ui8 ]
176: MACA [4-ui32] 00000000 [....]
177: MACM [1-flag] 01 [.]
178: MACR [32-ch8*]
179: MOCF [2-ui16] 8300 [..]
180: MOCN [2-ui16] e0f8 [..]
181: MOHD [1-ui8 ] 14 [.]
182: MOHT [2-sp78] 01c0 [..]
183: MOLD [1-ui8 ] 14 [.]
184: MOLT [2-sp78] 0060 [.`]
185: MOST [2-ui16] 8003 [..]
186: MOVX [2-sp78] 0003 [..]
187: MOVY [2-sp78] 0003 [..]
188: MOVZ [2-sp78] 0105 [..]
189: MO_X [2-sp78] 0002 [..]
190: MO_Y [2-sp78] 0000 [..]
191: MO_Z [2-sp78] 0105 [..]
192: MSAL [1-ui8 ] 4b [K]
193: MSAR [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
194: MSAc [2-fp88] 0000 [..]
195: MSAg [2-fp88] 0000 [..]
196: MSAm [2-fp88] 0000 [..]
197: MSBC [2-ui16] 01fb [..]
198: MSBP [2-ui16] 1250 [.P]
199: MSBc [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
200: MSBp [2-ui16] 0fe4 [..]
201: MSDI [1-flag] 00 [.]
202: MSDW [1-flag]
203: MSFG [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
204: MSLD [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
205: MSPA [2-fp6a] 0000 [..]
206: MSPC [1-ui8 ] 06 [.]
207: MSPS [2-ui16] 0001 [..]
208: MSPZ [1-ui8 ] 08 [.]
209: MSPs [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
210: MSSD [1-si8 ] 03 [.]
211: MSSE [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
212: MSSF [4-ui32] 00000001 [....]
213: MSSP [1-si8 ] 05 [.]
214: MSSS [1-{mss] 00 [.]
215: MSTC [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
216: MSTM [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
217: MSTc [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
218: MSTg [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
219: MSTm [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
220: MSWR [1-ui8 ]
221: MSXC [4-ch8*] 00000000 [....]
222: MSXD [16-ch8*] 00000000000000000000000000000000 [................]
223: MSXK [32-ch8*] 0102030405060708090a0b0c0d0e0f10111200000000000000 00000000000000 [................................]
224: MSXN [1-ui8 ] 12 [.]
225: MSXS [4-ch8*] 0205070a [....]
226: MSXb [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
227: MSXc [4-ch8*] 00000000 [....]
228: MSXd [16-ch8*] 00000000000000000000000000000000 [................]
229: MSXk [32-ch8*] 21222324f0f1f2f30000000000000000000000000000000000 00000000000000 [!"#$............................]
230: MSXm [2-ui16] 0008 [..]
231: MSXn [1-ui8 ] 28 [(]
232: MSXs [4-ui32] 0103060c [....]
233: NACK [1-flag]
234: NATJ [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
235: NATi [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
236: NOPB [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
237: NTOK [1-ui8 ]
238: ONMI [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
239: OWCT [2-ui16] 0010 [..]
240: PBIC [2-fp88] 0000 [..]
241: PC0C [2-fp88] 02e3 [..]
242: PC1C [2-fp88] 0486 [..]
243: PD0R [2-fp88] 0000 [..]
244: PD1R [2-fp88] 0000 [..]
245: PH0C [2-fp88] 0000 [..]
246: PHPC [2-fp88] 06c9 [..]
247: PN0R [2-fp88] 01ec [..]
248: PN1R [2-fp88] 0056 [.V]
249: PO0C [2-fp88] 0000 [..]
250: PP0R [2-fp88] 148c [..]
251: PTHC [2-fp88] 20fb [ .]
252: PW0C [2-fp88] 0000 [..]
253: RBr [8-ch8*] 6b31396900000000 [k19i....]
254: REV [6-{rev] 01490f000002 [.I....]
255: RMde [1-char] 41 [A]
256: RPlt [8-ch8*] 6b31396900000000 [k19i....]
257: RSvn [4-ui32] 00006446 [..dF]
258: RVBF [6-{rev] 01490f000002 [.I....]
259: RVUF [6-{rev] 01490f000002 [.I....]
260: SAS! [4-hex_]
261: SBS! [2-ui16]
262: SCIA [2-ui16] 03f8 [..]
263: SCIL [1-ui8] 00 [.]
264: SDRd [2-ui16]
265: SIP [1-ui8] 01 [.]
266: SIS! [2-hex_]
267: SIT! [2-hex_]
268: SM0x [2-ui16] 7fc0 [..]
269: SM0y [2-ui16] 7f80 [..]
270: SM0z [2-ui16] b400 [..]
271: SMBC [5-ch8*]
272: SMBG [1-ui8 ]
273: SMBR [32-ch8*]
274: SMBS [2-ch8*]
275: SMBW [32-ch8*]
276: SPH0 [2-ui16] 2a60 [*`]
277: SPHS [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
278: SPHT [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
279: SPHZ [1-ui8]
280: SPS! [2-ui16]
281: TB0T [2-sp78] 19b3 [..]
282: TB1T [2-sp78] 19b3 [..]
283: TB2T [2-sp78] 1933 [.3]
284: TB3T [2-sp78] 0000 [..]
285: TC0D [2-sp78] 2b20 [+ ]
286: TC0F [2-sp78] 248c [$.]
287: TC0P [2-sp78] 2500 [%.]
288: TN0D [2-sp78] 29a0 [).]
289: TN0P [2-sp78] 23e0 [#.]
290: TTF0 [2-sp78] 3100 [1.]
291: Th2H [2-sp78] 2180 [!.]
292: Ts0P [2-sp78] 1910 [..]
293: Ts0S [2-sp78] 1f78 [.x]
294: UPRC [2-ui16] 0845 [.E]
295: VBOC [2-fp6a] 0000 [..]
296: VBOc [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
297: VC0C [2-fp2e] 4259 [BY]
298: VC0c [2-ui16] 49c0 [I.]
299: VN0R [2-fp2e] 3fff [?.]
300: VN0r [2-ui16] 4d80 [M.]
301: VO0C [2-fp4c] 0000 [..]
302: VO0r [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
303: VP0R [2-fp4c] bf4b [.K]
304: VP0r [2-ui16] 9b00 [..]
305: VW0C [2-fp4c] 0000 [..]
306: VW0r [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
307: zDBG [1-ui8] 00 [.]




The good thing is, people who run linux are not generally entirely stupid, so they are aware of the temperature at least ... but to me, this is quite an important to make linux fesible for macbook pro users. I set my min speed to 3000rpm which is still relatively quiet, and then keep an eye on the temperature sensors. Obviously this is a temporary solution :)

[kosumi68]

... and now intermittently i get errors reading from TG0T GPU transistor..


The TG0T is one of the nonexisting registers on the MBP5,4 that the provided applesmc DKMS package stopped trying to read. Are you perhaps still running the old applesmc module, or do you have a program reading that register, or did the module not properly recognize your model? Perhaps a

rmmod applesmc;
modprobe applesmc;
dmesg | grep applesmc:

will reveal what model is detected.

[m.prebble]

That is probably the reason. I have libsensors and a gnome applet that displays temps on the status bar. Here is dmesg output:

[12163.540654] applesmc: driver unloaded.
[12180.099812] applesmc: Apple MacBook Pro 5 detected:
[12180.099819] applesmc: - Model with accelerometer
[12180.099823] applesmc: - Model with light sensors and backlight
[12180.099828] applesmc: - Model with 20 temperature sensors
[12180.100786] applesmc: device has already been initialized (0xe0, 0xf8).
[12180.100791] applesmc: device successfully initialized.
[12180.110830] applesmc: 1 fans found.
[12180.114014] applesmc: driver successfully loaded.
[12180.541169] applesmc: light sensor data length set to 10
[12181.883072] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0

[kosumi68]

It should actually say "Apple MacBook Pro 5,4 detected", it is falling back to the MacBookPro5 model. To know if the dkms package got properly installed, the "modprobe -l | grep applesmc" should point to updates/dkms/applesmc.ko rather than to the kernel module tree.

[m.prebble]

marcus@marcus-ubuntu:~$ modprobe -l | grep applesmc
updates/dkms/applesmc.ko

[kosumi68]

Puzzling. If "grep MacBookPro5 /usr/src/applesmc-0.15.1/applesmc.c" reports the 5,4 line, there is something wrong with the patch I just cannot see. For the record, posting the exact product name from dmidecode could help as well.

[kosumi68]

Was the MacBookPro5,4 issue resolved? I need a confirmation that it works before the needed change can propagate any further.

[bye]

HI kosumi68, My MacBookPro5,3 has a similar problem: the fans stay at 2000 most of time until the cpu temperatures go up to ~78 degrees, then the fans speed up to 3200rpm gradually and cpu temperatures stay at about 72~75 degrees. Is this normal?

[kosumi68]

Thanks for the data! Please find enclosed a DKMS package to test. Uncompress, install (double-click on the .deb file), reboot. "dmesg | grep applesmc:" should read "Apple MacBook Pro 5,3 detected:" in your case. Please confirm. Thanks!

EDIT: to answer you question, yes it seems normal for the 2007-2008 type models, and many users report that this setup works fine for them. (It does however mean that the smc-check-fan-safe.sh makes the wrong assumption regarding the MBP53 model.)

EDIT2: and the attached package can be found at http://ubuntuforums.org/showpost.php?p=9199384&postcount=24 -- I was apparently in a hurry this morning ;-)

[bye]

Yes, it reports the correct model after loading the new module


[ 25.894059] applesmc: Apple MacBook Pro 5,3 detected:
[ 25.894061] applesmc: - Model with accelerometer
[ 25.894063] applesmc: - Model with light sensors and backlight
[ 25.894064] applesmc: - Model with 19 temperature sensors
[ 25.897015] applesmc: device has already been initialized (0xe0, 0x00).
[ 25.897016] applesmc: device successfully initialized.
[ 25.899475] applesmc: 2 fans found.
[ 25.911453] input: applesmc as /devices/platform/applesmc.768/input/input7
[ 25.911575] applesmc: driver successfully loaded.
[ 535.504990] applesmc: light sensor data length set to 10
[ 686.679002] applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 1


The output of applesmc-test.sh


accelerometer: present, readable, output: (18,-8,-280)
fan: present, readable, output: 2000
light: present, readable, output: (0,0)
leds: present,
led: readable, output: 100
temperatures: present,
temperature: readable, output: 48500
temperature: readable, output: 54500
temperature: readable, output: 57500
temperature: readable, output: 59500
temperature: readable, output: 56500
temperature: readable, output: 49000
temperature: readable, output: 53000
temperature: readable, output: 55500
temperature: readable, output: 33000
temperature: readable, output: 44750
temperature: readable, output: 36250
temperature: readable, output: 36250
temperature: readable, output: 34750
temperature: readable, output: 0
temperature: readable, output: 59500
temperature: readable, output: 54500
temperature: readable, output: 54750
temperature: readable, output: 63000
temperature: readable, output: 56000
performance: reading all temperatures
fail frequency: 0
reads per second: 41

[kosumi68]

Excellent! Version 0.15.2 of applesmc-dkms has been uploaded to the mactel PPA for karmic and lucid, with temperature sensor support for MBP5,3, MBP5,4, MBP6 and MBP7. Thanks!

[linuxopjemac]

Good work kosumi68 !

[bluenode]

This eliminated the message:
"applesmc: wait status failed: 4 != 0"
appearing on my MacBook 4.1, Lucid install.

Thanks very much!

[undoIT]

I have the Macbook 5,1 with Nvidia 9400m and the GPU regularly overheats whenever I am doing anything system intensive or if there is inadequate airflow under the laptop. I have sensor applet installed and if the GPU is running above 65 degrees celsius for an extended period of time (not that long) then the system freezes up. This happened yesterday while installing an OS in VirtualBox. I came back and Ubuntu was frozen half way thru the install and the GPU was reading 68 degrees. Usually, before it freezes, the screen may flicker slightly, like the graphics card is getting ready to crap out. Then a minute or two later, it freezes.

I opened the case last night for the first time in almost two years and there was hardly any dust in the fan / cooling, wasn't even worth cracking it open but I blew it out anyways. Do I just have a flaky Nvidia GPU that can't take the heat? Or is it actually overheating? Currently, it is idling at 55 degrees, core 1 and 2 are at 47 degrees. Also, it seems that the fans never go higher than 2000 rpm. Shouldn't they ramp up as heat increases?

[kosumi68]

Hi undoit,

I am sure you are aware of the "set fan1_manual to zero" issue, so there could be a problem with your hardware. There are many reports from "genuine" apple users having the same problem in OSX. Could be memory, could be battery, could be heat paste poorly applied, for instance.

And yes, it should ramp up, but on newer macbooks it does not happen until around 85-95 degC -- and that is true also in OSX without special fan control.

[undoIT]

Hi undoit,

I am sure you are aware of the "set fan1_manual to zero" issue, so there could be a problem with your hardware. There are many reports from "genuine" apple users having the same problem in OSX. Could be memory, could be battery, could be heat paste poorly applied, for instance.

And yes, it should ramp up, but on newer macbooks it does not happen until around 85-95 degC -- and that is true also in OSX without special fan control.

Thanks Kosumi, I have already tested the memory. I guess fan speed isn't the issue. And yes, I've had it freeze up in OS X as well, I just hardly ever use OS X.

Makes me wish I had gotten the 3 year Applecare :(

[undoIT]

I'm using sensors-applet to monitor temperatures. There is a way to adjust the properties so that a command is fired when the sensor high value is hit. Is there a way to fire off the command to adjust fan speed with this? I'm not sure how to do this since the command requires sudo.

Fan speed command:

echo 4000 | sudo tee -a /sys/devices/platform/applesmc.768/fan1_min

[undoIT]

I have the Macbook 5,1 with Nvidia 9400m and the GPU regularly overheats whenever I am doing anything system intensive or if there is inadequate airflow under the laptop. I have sensor applet installed and if the GPU is running above 65 degrees celsius for an extended period of time (not that long) then the system freezes up. This happened yesterday while installing an OS in VirtualBox. I came back and Ubuntu was frozen half way thru the install and the GPU was reading 68 degrees. Usually, before it freezes, the screen may flicker slightly, like the graphics card is getting ready to crap out. Then a minute or two later, it freezes.

I opened the case last night for the first time in almost two years and there was hardly any dust in the fan / cooling, wasn't even worth cracking it open but I blew it out anyways. Do I just have a flaky Nvidia GPU that can't take the heat? Or is it actually overheating? Currently, it is idling at 55 degrees, core 1 and 2 are at 47 degrees. Also, it seems that the fans never go higher than 2000 rpm. Shouldn't they ramp up as heat increases?

Well, I made a nice discovery regarding the overheating issue. After installing some of the latest updates, I couldn't boot into Lucid anymore without the low graphics mode error. I searched around for some hacks and nothing I tried worked. So, I decided to try installing the 173 driver as a last resort.

Wow! Not only is the low graphics mode error gone, the Macbook doesn't freeze anymore! I've done several tests now. Yesterday I ran glxgears and a youtube video simultaneously to get the GPU up to a toasty 84 degrees celsius and the CPU cores above 80 degrees. Also got the fan RPMs maxed out at 6000 for the first time ever. After 20 minutes, no freezing.

Later in the evening, I tried the same thing for another hour. Again no freezes. This morning, I ran it through the paces for 2 hours straight, the GPU settled into 75 degrees and the CPUS were around 80. No freezes. Not even a screen flicker.

So, it seems to me that the 18x and 19x Nvidia drivers for Linux (and perhaps the drivers for OS X) are to blame when it comes to the 9400m card causing system freezes. I haven't tested OS X recently, but I had it lock up on me 5 or 6 times in the past with some pink and green screen artifacts. That is a lot of freezes considering that I rarely use OS X.

What is unfortunate is that it is highly doubtful this will get fixed, since the 9400m is an older card, the Nvidia drivers are proprietary, and Nvidia has clearly stated that they have no interest in supporting Linux / open source drivers. I made a decision recently not to purchase any laptops with Nvidia cards because of these issues. I have just had way too many problems with their cards and I don't like their policy regarding open source software.

It is also a shame that Apple doesn't offer any laptops without Nvidia cards.

[kosumi68]

Excellent. What about the noveau? I am not running nVidia myself, so I am asking out of curiosity.

[alexmurray]

@undoIT: you should send an email to the Nvidia developers linux-bugs@nvidia.com and post a bug report on their forums - they're usually pretty responsive to issues I've notified them of in the past for their binary drivers - see here for more info http://www.nvnews.net/vbulletin/showthread.php?t=46678 and from the README (http://us.download.nvidia.com/XFree86/Linux-x86_64/195.36.24/README/README.txt)

When emailing linux-bugs@nvidia.com,
please include the 'nvidia-bug-report.log.gz' file generated by the
'nvidia-bug-report.sh' script (which is installed as part of driver
installation).

[undoIT]

Excellent. What about the noveau? I am not running nVidia myself, so I am asking out of curiosity.

I'm really rooting for noveau. However, with the current noveau driver on the MacBook 5,1 the CPU cores run a lot hotter, the GPU thermal sensor is not detected, 3D acceleration is not supported and there may be other issues I'm not aware of. However, the correct resolution is set and there was no hack needed for plymouth.

If the noveau driver can match the functionality of the proprietary driver, minus all the bugs, I'd have no problem with Nvidia cards. I just wish Nvidia would cooperate and collaborate with the noveau team.

[onejdev]

hate to do this, but even after reading a lot of great info in this thread and applying what I thought would fix this, I am having some errors on an MacPro running Lucid. /var/log/messages is littered with the following errors:

applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0

I ran the applesmc-test.sh script and this is the result:


model: MacPro1,1

accelerometer: not present
fan: present, readable, output: 500
light: not present
leds: not present
temperatures: present,
temperature: not readable
temperature: readable, output: 50000
temperature: not readable
temperature: readable, output: 0
temperature: not readable
temperature: not readable
temperature: readable, output: 35000
temperature: readable, output: 35000
temperature: readable, output: 34000
temperature: readable, output: 32500
temperature: readable, output: 28000
temperature: readable, output: 50000
temperature: readable, output: 57500
temperature: readable, output: 58500
temperature: readable, output: 40000
temperature: readable, output: 66000
temperature: readable, output: 47000
temperature: readable, output: 68000
temperature: readable, output: 47000
temperature: readable, output: 65000
temperature: readable, output: 62000
temperature: not readable
temperature: readable, output: 40000
temperature: readable, output: 67000
temperature: readable, output: 47000
temperature: readable, output: 67000
temperature: readable, output: 67000
temperature: readable, output: 35500
temperature: readable, output: 31000
temperature: not readable
temperature: readable, output: 32000
temperature: readable, output: 49000
temperature: not readable
temperature: readable, output: 40000
temperature: readable, output: 0
performance: reading all temperatures
fail frequency: 1.000
reads per second: 3

smc-fan: Mt Sf type B


Here is the result of the scan-smc.sh script also


0: #KEY [4-ui32] 000000ff [....]
1: +LKS [1-flag] 07 [.]
2: ACID [8-ch8*] 0000000000000000 [........]
3: ALSC [16-{alc] 0192009608b00002000100640ed90000 [...........d....]
4: AUPO [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
5: BATP [1-flag] 00 [.]
6: BISE [1-ui8 ]
7: BNum [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
8: BRSC [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
9: CLK! [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
10: CLKC [10-{clc] 00000e1000000e10198c [..........]
11: CLKH [8-{clh] 0000000000000000 [........]
12: CLKS [2-fp1f] 8000 [..]
13: CLKT [4-ui32] 00013e65 [..>e]
14: CONT [4-ui32] 16001600 [....]
15: CRCB [4-ui32] c512fc40 [...@]
16: CRCU [4-ui32]
17: Dlpc [1-flag]
18: EPCF [1-flag] 01 [.]
19: EPCI [4-ui32] 00800700 [....]
20: EPCV [2-ui16] 0001 [..]
21: EPMA [4-ch8*] 0000e080 [....]
22: EPMI [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
23: EPUF [1-flag] 01 [.]
24: EPUI [4-ui32] 00800001 [....]
25: EPUV [2-ui16] 0001 [..]
26: EVCT [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
27: EVMD [4-ui32]
28: EVRD [32-ch8*] f6060300000124f0c101000001000f2b000000000000000000 00000000000000 [......$........+................]
29: F0Ac [2-fpe2] 07cd [..]
30: F0ID [16-{fds] 010001004350555f4d454d2000000000 [....CPU_MEM ....]
31: F0Mn [2-fpe2] 07d0 [..]
32: F0Mt [2-ui16] 01f4 [..]
33: F0Mx [2-fpe2] 2d50 [-P]
34: F0Sf [2-fpe2] 12c0 [..]
35: F0Tg [2-fpe2] 07d0 [..]
36: F1Ac [2-fpe2] 07d1 [..]
37: F1ID [16-{fds] 01010400494f20000000000000000000 [....IO .........]
38: F1Mn [2-fpe2] 07d0 [..]
39: F1Mt [2-ui16] 0252 [.R]
40: F1Mx [2-fpe2] 2d50 [-P]
41: F1Sf [2-fpe2] 12c0 [..]
42: F1Tg [2-fpe2] 07d0 [..]
43: F2Ac [2-fpe2] 095a [.Z]
44: F2ID [16-{fds] 01000d00455848415553542000000000 [....EXHAUST ....]
45: F2Mn [2-fpe2] 07d0 [..]
46: F2Mt [2-ui16] 0258 [.X]
47: F2Mx [2-fpe2] 2d50 [-P]
48: F2Sf [2-fpe2] 12c0 [..]
49: F2Tg [2-fpe2] 0960 [.`]
50: F3Ac [2-fpe2] 0b3c [.<]
51: F3ID [16-{fds] 01021000505320202000000000000000 [....PS .......]
52: F3Mn [2-fpe2] 0b40 [.@]
53: F3Mt [2-ui16] 035c [.\]
54: F3Mx [2-fpe2] 2bc0 [+.]
55: F3Sf [2-fpe2] 12c0 [..]
56: F3Tg [2-fpe2] 0b40 [.@]
57: FNum [1-ui8 ] 04 [.]
58: FPhz [2-i16 ]
59: FS! [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
60: HDBS [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
61: HDST [4-ui16] 00000000 [....]
62: HDSW [4-ui32] 00000000 [....]
63: ICAC [2-fp88] 088a [..]
64: ICAc [2-ui16] 1900 [..]
65: ICBC [2-fp88] 092f [./]
66: ICBc [2-ui16] 1b00 [..]
67: IM1s [2-ui16] 2e80 [..]
68: IM2s [2-ui16] 2680 [&.]
69: IMAS [2-fp88] 0269 [.i]
70: IMBS [2-fp88] 01f8 [..]
71: IN0C [2-fp88] 0db9 [..]
72: IN0c [2-ui16] 7d40 [}@]
73: Ie1S [2-fp88] 009e [..]
74: Ie1s [2-ui16] 0c40 [.@]
75: Ie2S [2-fp88] 0010 [..]
76: Ie2s [2-ui16] 0100 [..]
77: Ie3S [2-fp88] 000d [..]
78: Ie3s [2-ui16] 0100 [..]
79: Ie4S [2-fp88] 0006 [..]
80: Ie4s [2-ui16] 0080 [..]
81: IeAS [2-fp88] 000d [..]
82: IeAs [2-ui16] 0100 [..]
83: IeBS [2-fp88] 0009 [..]
84: IeBs [2-ui16] 00c0 [..]
85: Ip0C [2-fp88] 0d78 [.x]
86: Ip0c [2-ui16] 035e [.^]
87: Jp0D [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
88: Jp0S [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
89: Jp0W [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
90: JpFE [1-flag] 01 [.]
91: LAcN [1-ui8 ]
92: LAtN [2-ui16]
93: LS! [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
94: LSCF [10-{lsc] 02ee0190800001020006 [..........]
95: LSDD [8-{lsd] 0002000300030019 [........]
96: LSDU [8-{lsd] 0003000200140003 [........]
97: LSFD [6-{lsf] 00000004001e [......]
98: LSFU [6-{lsf] 17700007003c [.p...<]
99: LSLB [2-{pwm] ffff [..]
100: LSLF [2-{pwm] 0000 [..]
101: LSLN [2-{pwm] 4e20 [N ]
102: LSOF [1-flag] 00 [.]
103: LSOO [1-flag]
104: LSPV [2-{pwm] 4e20 [N ]
105: LSRB [1-flag]
106: LSSB [2-{lso]
107: LSSE [1-flag] 01 [.]
108: LSSS [2-{lso]
109: LSSV [2-ui16] ffff [..]
110: LSUP [1-ui8 ]
111: MACA [4-ui32] 00000000 [....]
112: MACM [1-flag] 01 [.]
113: MACR [32-ch8*] 6368382a900124f0c101000001000f2b000000000000000000 00000000000000 [ch8*..$........+................]
114: MDE [2-ui16] 00ff [..]
115: MDLC [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
116: MDSS [1-ui8 ] 02 [.]
117: MOCF [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
118: MSAL [1-si8 ]
119: MSDW [1-flag]
120: MSLD [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
121: MSPS [1-{msp] 00 [.]
122: MSSD [1-si8 ] 03 [.]
123: MSSS [1-{mss] 00 [.]
124: MSTM [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
125: MSWR [1-ui8 ]
126: NATJ [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
127: NATi [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
128: NTOK [1-ui8 ]
129: NVPR [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
130: NVPW [1-ui8 ]
131: ONMI [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
132: OSK0 [32-ch8*] 6f757268617264776f726b62797468657365776f7264736775 6172646564706c [ourhardworkbythesewordsguardedpl]
133: OSK1 [32-ch8*] 65617365646f6e74737465616c2863294170706c65436f6d70 75746572496e63 [easedontsteal(c)AppleComputerInc]
134: PCAC [2-fp88] 100d [..]
135: PCBC [2-fp88] 0e55 [.U]
136: PMAS [2-fp88] 1c97 [..]
137: PMBS [2-fp88] 173b [.;]
138: PN0C [2-fp88] 1454 [.T]
139: Pe1S [2-fp88] 077c [.|]
140: Pe2S [2-fp88] 009a [..]
141: Pe3S [2-fp88] 009a [..]
142: Pe4S [2-fp88] 0047 [.G]
143: PeAS [2-fp88] 009a [..]
144: PeBS [2-fp88] 0047 [.G]
145: PeTS [2-ui16] 0009 [..]
146: Pp0C [2-fpc4] 0a2b [.+]
147: RBr [8-ch8*] 6d34330000000000 [m43.....]
148: REV [6-{rev] 01070f000008 [......]
149: RMde [1-byte] 41 [A]
150: RPS0 [8-{psh] 0c02060408ce0000 [........]
151: RPlt [8-ch8*] 6d34330000000000 [m43.....]
152: RSvn [4-ui32] 00002721 [..'!]
153: RVBF [6-{rev] 01070f000008 [......]
154: RVUF [6-{rev] 01070f000008 [......]
155: SAS! [4-ui32]
156: SBF [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
157: SDRd [2-ui16]
158: SIS! [2-ui16]
159: SIT! [2-ui16]
160: SIU! [2-ui16]
161: SIV! [2-ui16]
162: SIW! [2-ui16]
163: SPC0 [1-ui8] 04 [.]
164: SPC1 [1-ui8] 01 [.]
165: SPC2 [1-ui8] 00 [.]
166: SPH0 [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
167: SPH1 [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
168: SPHS [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
169: SPHT [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
170: SPS! [2-ui16]
171: TA0P [2-sp78] 1c00 [..]
172: TC0C [2-sp78] 2f00 [/.]
173: TC0P [2-sp78] 2810 [(.]
174: TC1C [2-sp78] 0000 [..]
175: TC2C [2-sp78] 2f00 [/.]
176: TC3C [2-sp78] 0000 [..]
177: TCAH [2-sp78] 1f90 [..]
178: TCBH [2-sp78] 2090 [ .]
179: TH0P [2-sp78] 2320 [# ]
180: TH1P [2-sp78] 22e0 [".]
181: TH2P [2-sp78] 2220 [" ]
182: TH3P [2-sp78] 2080 [ .]
183: TM0P [2-sp78] 2900 [).]
184: TM0S [2-sp78] 4280 [B.]
185: TM1P [2-sp78] 2f00 [/.]
186: TM1S [2-sp78] 4500 [E.]
187: TM2P [2-sp78] 2f00 [/.]
188: TM2S [2-sp78] 4180 [A.]
189: TM3S [2-sp78] 3e00 [>.]
190: TM8P [2-sp78] 2800 [(.]
191: TM8S [2-sp78] 4300 [C.]
192: TM9P [2-sp78] 2f00 [/.]
193: TM9S [2-sp78] 4380 [C.]
194: TMAP [2-sp78] 3200 [2.]
195: TMAS [2-sp78] 3a00 [:.]
196: TMBS [2-sp78] 3a80 [:.]
197: TN0H [2-sp78] 4280 [B.]
198: TS0C [2-sp78] 2380 [#.]
199: Tp0C [2-sp78] 2f00 [/.]
200: Tp1C [2-sp78] 2b90 [+.]
201: Tv0S [2-sp78] 22b0 [".]
202: Tv1S [2-sp78] 2332 [#2]
203: VCAC [2-fp88] 013b [.;]
204: VCAc [2-ui16] 65c0 [e.]
205: VCBC [2-fp88] 013d [.=]
206: VCBc [2-ui16] 58c0 [X.]
207: VM0s [2-ui16] 02ac [..]
208: VM1s [2-ui16] 0198 [..]
209: VM2s [2-ui16] 02f4 [..]
210: VM3s [2-ui16] 0330 [.0]
211: VM4s [2-ui16] 02f8 [..]
212: VM8s [2-ui16] 02ac [..]
213: VM9s [2-ui16] 0198 [..]
214: VMAS [2-fp88] 0bdd [..]
215: VMAs [2-ui16] 02f4 [..]
216: VMBS [2-fp88] 0bcd [..]
217: VMBs [2-ui16] 0334 [.4]
218: VMCs [2-ui16] 02f4 [..]
219: VN0C [2-fp88] 017c [.|]
220: VS2c [2-ui16] 00c4 [..]
221: VS3c [2-ui16] 00bf [..]
222: VS4c [2-ui16] 00bd [..]
223: VS5c [2-ui16] 00bf [..]
224: VS6c [2-ui16] 00d3 [..]
225: VS7c [2-ui16] 00cb [..]
226: VS8c [2-ui16] 00bd [..]
227: VS9c [2-ui16] 00c4 [..]
228: VSAc [2-ui16] 0073 [.s]
229: VSBc [2-ui16] 00af [..]
230: VSCc [2-ui16] 00e9 [..]
231: VSDc [2-ui16] 00c9 [..]
232: VSEc [2-ui16] 00cb [..]
233: VSFc [2-ui16] 00bb [..]
234: VeES [2-fp88] 0be8 [..]
235: Vp0C [2-fp88] 0c12 [..]
236: Vp0c [2-ui16] 0c15 [..]
237: zDBG [1-ui8]
238: zSCI [1-ui8]
239: {clc [3-] 0001db [...]
240: {clf [3-] 0001e0 [...]
241: {clh [3-] 0001db [...]
242: {fds [3-] 0001db [...]
243: {lsc [3-] 0001dd [...]
244: {lsd [3-] 0001db [...]
245: {lsf [3-] 0001db [...]
246: {lsm [3-] 0001dd [...]
247: {lso [3-] 0001dd [...]
248: {lss [3-] 0001dd [...]
249: {msp [3-] 0001df [...]
250: {mss [3-] 0001df [...]
251: {psh [3-] 0001df [...]
252: {pwm [3-] 0001dc [...]
253: {rev [3-] 0001e0 [...]
254: {sds [3-] 0001db [...]


Any help anyone could offer would be greatly appreciated.

[xeno74]

Mac Pro 2009 info :)

http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/c/ca/Mac_Pro_Tower.jpg/300px-Mac_Pro_Tower.jpg

sudo dmidecode -s system-product-name

MacPro4,1sudo ./applesmc-test.sh

model: MacPro4,1

accelerometer: not present
fan: present, readable, output: 838
light: not present
leds: not present
temperatures: present,
temperature: not readable
temperature: not readable
temperature: not readable
temperature: not readable
temperature: not readable
temperature: readable, output: 58000
temperature: not readable
temperature: readable, output: 29000
temperature: readable, output: 31000
temperature: readable, output: 31750
temperature: readable, output: 28500
temperature: not readable
temperature: not readable
temperature: not readable
temperature: not readable
temperature: not readable
temperature: readable, output: 36250
temperature: not readable
temperature: readable, output: 38250
temperature: not readable
temperature: not readable
temperature: readable, output: 80000
temperature: readable, output: 129000
temperature: not readable
temperature: not readable
temperature: not readable
temperature: readable, output: 47000
temperature: not readable
temperature: readable, output: 47750
temperature: readable, output: 80000
temperature: readable, output: 129000
temperature: not readable
temperature: not readable
temperature: not readable
temperature: not readable
performance: reading all temperatures


fail frequency: 1.000
reads per second: 1

smc-fan: Mt type C



Cheers,

Christian

[davidryderuk]

Hi,
Thanks for all the work. This is from the latest version of applesmc on my 2010 Macbook.

sudo dmidecode -s system-product-name

MacBook 7,1

sudo ./applesmc-test.sh

model: MacBook7,1

accelerometer: present, readable, output: (1,19,264)
fan: present, readable, output: 2000
light: not present
leds: not present
temperatures: present,
temperature: readable, output: 29500
temperature: readable, output: 31250
temperature: readable, output: 48000
temperature: readable, output: 43500
temperature: not readable
temperature: readable, output: 41750
temperature: not readable
temperature: not readable
temperature: not readable
temperature: readable, output: 41750
performance: reading all temperatures
fail frequency: 1.000
reads per second: 6

smc-fan: Mt type C


sudo ./scan-smc.sh

0: #KEY [4-ui32] 0000013d [...=]
1: $Adr [4-ui32] 00000300 [....]
2: $Num [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
3: +LKS [1-flag] 07 [.]
4: ACCL [1-ui8 ]
5: ACEN [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
6: ACFP [1-flag] 01 [.]
7: ACIC [2-ui16] 0d80 [..]
8: ACID [8-ch8*] 8518cdb0c0031060 [.......`]
9: ACIN [1-flag] 01 [.]
10: ACLM [1-ui8 ] 55 [U]
11: ALRV [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
12: ALSC [16-{alc] 01920096042e0002000100642efd0000 [...........d....]
13: AUPO [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
14: B0AC [2-si16] 0568 [.h]
15: B0AV [2-ui16] 30f8 [0.]
16: B0Ad [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
17: B0Al [2-ui16] ffff [..]
18: B0Am [1-ui8 ] 10 [.]
19: B0Ar [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
20: B0As [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
21: B0At [2-ui16] 0960 [.`]
22: B0Au [2-ui16] 0960 [.`]
23: B0Az [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
24: B0BI [1-hex_] 51 [Q]
25: B0CM [2-ui16] 0164 [.d]
26: B0CT [2-ui16] 0002 [..]
27: B0FC [2-ui16] 15c4 [..]
28: B0FV [2-ui16] 0201 [..]
29: B0LI [2-ui16] 0f80 [..]
30: B0PS [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
31: B0RI [2-ui16] 0fa0 [..]
32: B0RM [2-ui16] 1429 [.)]
33: B0St [2-ui16] 0080 [..]
34: B0TF [2-ui16] 0021 [.!]
35: BATP [1-flag] 00 [.]
36: BBAD [1-flag] 00 [.]
37: BBIN [1-flag] 01 [.]
38: BC1V [2-ui16] 105b [.[]
39: BC2V [2-ui16] 1050 [.P]
40: BC3V [2-ui16] 104f [.O]
41: BCLM [1-ui8 ] 64 [d]
42: BCMV [2-ui16] 105b [.[]
43: BEMB [1-flag] 01 [.]
44: BFCT [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
45: BNCM [1-ui8 ]
46: BNCR [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
47: BNum [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
48: BRSC [2-ui16] 005d [.]]
49: BSAC [1-ui8 ] 33 [3]
50: BSIn [1-hex_] 43 [C]
51: BTIL [2-ui16] 0580 [..]
52: BTTI [1-ui8 ] 02 [.]
53: BTVI [1-ui8 ] 02 [.]
54: BTVR [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
55: BTVT [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
56: BWLM [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
57: CHBI [2-ui16] 0580 [..]
58: CHBV [2-ui16] 3130 [10]
59: CHGC [2-ui16] 0062 [.b]
60: CHGD [1-flag]
61: CHGI [2-ui16] 0580 [..]
62: CHGV [2-ui16] 3130 [10]
63: CHPV [2-si16] 3130 [10]
64: CLK! [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
65: CLKC [10-{clc] 00000e1000000e10198c [..........]
66: CLKH [8-{clh] 0000708000011940 [..p....@]
67: CLKS [2-fp1f] 8000 [..]
68: CLKT [4-ui32] 0000b115 [....]
69: CLSD [2-ui16] 0905 [..]
70: CLWK [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
71: CRCB [4-ui32] a3da51a6 [..Q.]
72: CRCU [4-ui32]
73: DPLM [3-{lim]
74: EPCA [4-ui32] 00007000 [..p.]
75: EPCF [1-flag] 01 [.]
76: EPCI [4-ui32] 05200700 [. ..]
77: EPCV [2-ui16] 0001 [..]
78: EPMA [4-ch8*] 00006080 [..`.]
79: EPMI [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
80: EPUA [4-ui32] 00006000 [..`.]
81: EPUF [1-flag] 01 [.]
82: EPUI [4-ui32] 05200001 [. ..]
83: EPUV [2-ui16] 0001 [..]
84: EVCT [2-ui16] 0303 [..]
85: EVMD [4-ui32]
86: EVRD [32-ch8*] f60603000000a5822304f7000101201736c400000100938600 00000000000000 [........#..... .6...............]
87: F0Ac [2-fpe2] 1f2e [..]
88: F0ID [16-{fds] 00000a00457868617573742020000000 [....Exhaust ...]
89: F0Mn [2-fpe2] 1f40 [.@]
90: F0Mt [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
91: F0Mx [2-fpe2] 60e0 [`.]
92: F0Tg [2-fpe2] 1f40 [.@]
93: FMAx [2-fpe2] 1fe2 [..]
94: FNum [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
95: FPVK [1-ui8 ] 03 [.]
96: FPhz [2-si16]
97: FS! [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
98: G3WD [1-flag] 00 [.]
99: HBWK [1-flag] 00 [.]
100: HDBS [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
101: HDST [4-hex_] 00000000 [....]
102: HDSW [4-hex_] 0040003f [.@.?]
103: IB0R [2-sp5a] 0097 [..]
104: IB0r [2-ui16] 0440 [.@]
105: IC0C [2-sp5a] 199c [..]
106: IC0R [2-sp5a] 0290 [..]
107: IC0c [2-ui16] 0a80 [..]
108: IC0r [2-ui16] 1180 [..]
109: ID0R [2-sp5a] 0900 [..]
110: ID0r [2-ui16] 49c0 [I.]
111: IN0C [2-sp5a] 099a [..]
112: IN0c [2-ui16] 1c40 [.@]
113: IN1C [2-sp5a] 0287 [..]
114: IN1c [2-ui16] 0e80 [..]
115: IZAP [2-sp5a] 8100 [..]
116: IZAp [2-ui16] 8100 [..]
117: IZBL [2-sp5a] 8100 [..]
118: IZBl [2-ui16] 8100 [..]
119: IZHD [2-sp5a] 8100 [..]
120: IZHd [2-ui16] 8100 [..]
121: IZOD [2-sp5a] 8100 [..]
122: IZOd [2-ui16] 8100 [..]
123: LAcN [1-ui8 ]
124: LAtN [2-ui16]
125: LC2D [2-ui16] 5c4d [\M]
126: LC2E [2-ui16] 5c4d [\M]
127: LCCN [1-ui8 ] d8 [.]
128: LCCQ [1-ui8 ] 81 [.]
129: LCKA [1-ui8 ] fc [.]
130: LCSA [1-ui8 ] 28 [(]
131: LCTN [1-ui8 ] 3b [;]
132: LCTQ [1-ui8 ] e4 [.]
133: LDI2 [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
134: LDSP [1-flag]
135: LEDC [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
136: LEDT [2-ui16] 8100 [..]
137: LEIC [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
138: LEID [32-ui16] 00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 00000000000000 [................................]
139: LET0 [4-ui32] 00000000 [....]
140: LET1 [4-ui32] 00000000 [....]
141: LET2 [4-ui32] 00000000 [....]
142: LS! [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
143: LSCF [10-{lsc] 04b0023a800001020001 [...:......]
144: LSDD [8-{lsd] 0002000300030019 [........]
145: LSDU [8-{lsd] 0003000200140003 [........]
146: LSFD [6-{lsf] 2ee000040017 [......]
147: LSFU [6-{lsf] ffff01900320 [..... ]
148: LSLB [2-{pwm] ffff [..]
149: LSLF [2-{pwm] 0000 [..]
150: LSLN [2-{pwm] ffff [..]
151: LSOF [1-flag] 01 [.]
152: LSOO [1-flag]
153: LSPV [2-{pwm] 0000 [..]
154: LSRB [1-flag]
155: LSSB [2-{lso]
156: LSSE [1-flag] 01 [.]
157: LSSS [2-{lso]
158: LSSV [2-ui16] ffff [..]
159: LSUP [1-ui8 ]
160: MACA [4-ui32] 00000000 [....]
161: MACM [1-flag] 01 [.]
162: MACR [32-ch8*]
163: MLEN [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
164: MLIA [2-ui16] 04c1 [..]
165: MLIR [32-ch8*] 04b804a004a404ac04a804af049f04ab04aa04a804a404a904 ae04c104ba04bd [................................]
166: MLSR [2-ui16] 03e8 [..]
167: MLTM [32-ch8*] 5b005b005b005b005a805a805b005b005b005b005b005b005b 005b005b005b00 [[.[.[.[.Z.Z.[.[.[.[.[.[.[.[.[.[.]
168: MOCF [2-ui16] 8600 [..]
169: MOCN [2-ui16] e000 [..]
170: MOHC [1-ui8 ] 0f [.]
171: MOHD [1-ui8 ] 0a [.]
172: MOHT [2-sp78] 01e0 [..]
173: MOLD [1-ui8 ] 0a [.]
174: MOLT [2-sp78] 0020 [. ]
175: MOST [2-ui16] a003 [..]
176: MOVX [2-sp78] 0003 [..]
177: MOVY [2-sp78] 0011 [..]
178: MOVZ [2-sp78] 010a [..]
179: MO_X [2-sp78] 0000 [..]
180: MO_Y [2-sp78] 0014 [..]
181: MO_Z [2-sp78] 0108 [..]
182: MSAL [1-ui8 ] 4b [K]
183: MSAb [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
184: MSAc [2-fp88] 0000 [..]
185: MSAf [2-fp6a] 0000 [..]
186: MSAg [2-fp88] 0000 [..]
187: MSAm [2-fp88] 0000 [..]
188: MSBC [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
189: MSBP [2-ui16] 10c2 [..]
190: MSBc [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
191: MSBp [2-ui16] 10c2 [..]
192: MSDI [1-flag] 00 [.]
193: MSDW [1-flag]
194: MSG3 [1-flag] 00 [.]
195: MSLD [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
196: MSPA [2-fp6a] 0000 [..]
197: MSPC [1-ui8 ] 05 [.]
198: MSPS [2-ui16] 0003 [..]
199: MSSD [1-si8 ] 03 [.]
200: MSSE [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
201: MSSF [4-ui32] 00000000 [....]
202: MSSG [4-ui32] 00000000 [....]
203: MSSP [1-si8 ] c4 [.]
204: MSSS [1-{mss] 00 [.]
205: MSTC [2-ui16] 0001 [..]
206: MSTM [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
207: MSTc [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
208: MSTg [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
209: MSTm [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
210: MSWR [1-ui8 ]
211: MSXC [4-ch8*] 00000000 [....]
212: MSXD [32-ch8*] 00000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000 00000000000000 [................................]
213: MSXK [32-ch8*] 0102030405060708090a0b0c0d0e0f10111213141516171819 00000000000000 [................................]
214: MSXN [1-ui8 ] 19 [.]
215: MSXS [8-ch8*] 0208070a04090103 [........]
216: MSXb [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
217: MSXc [4-ch8*] 00000000 [....]
218: MSXd [16-ch8*] 00000000000000000000000000000000 [................]
219: MSXk [32-ch8*] 0102030405060708090a0b0c0d0e0f10f0f1f2f30000000000 00000000000000 [................................]
220: MSXm [2-ui16] 0008 [..]
221: MSXn [1-ui8 ] 14 [.]
222: MSXs [4-ui32] 01031009 [....]
223: NACK [1-ui8 ]
224: NATJ [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
225: NATi [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
226: NOPB [1-ui8 ]
227: NTOK [1-ui8 ]
228: ONMI [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
229: PB0R [2-sp78] 01da [..]
230: PC0C [2-sp78] 07ee [..]
231: PC0R [2-sp78] 0956 [.V]
232: PD0R [2-sp78] 276c ['l]
233: PHPC [2-sp78] 0d31 [.1]
234: PN0C [2-sp78] 02df [..]
235: PN1C [2-sp78] 00fb [..]
236: PTHC [2-sp78] 20e4 [ .]
237: PZAP [2-sp78] 8100 [..]
238: PZBL [2-sp78] 8100 [..]
239: PZHD [2-sp78] 8100 [..]
240: PZOD [2-sp78] 8100 [..]
241: RBr [8-ch8*] 6b38370000000000 [k87.....]
242: REV [6-{rev] 01600f000005 [.`....]
243: RMde [1-char] 41 [A]
244: RPlt [8-ch8*] 6b38370000000000 [k87.....]
245: RSvn [4-ui32] 00000000 [....]
246: RVBF [6-{rev] 01600f000005 [.`....]
247: RVUF [6-{rev] 01600f000005 [.`....]
248: SAS! [4-hex_] 0000ffff [....]
249: SBF [4-hex_] 00000000 [....]
250: SBFC [4-hex_] 00000000 [....]
251: SBFD [4-hex_] 00000000 [....]
252: SBFE [1-flag] 01 [.]
253: SBFF [4-hex_] 00000000 [....]
254: SBFS [4-hex_] 00000000 [....]
255: SBS! [2-ui16]
256: SCIA [2-ui16] 03f8 [..]
257: SCII [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
258: SCIL [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
259: SDAF [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
260: SDAS [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
261: SDRd [2-ui16]
262: SFBR [1-ui8 ] 04 [.]
263: SIP [1-ui8] 01 [.]
264: SIS! [2-hex_]
265: SIT! [2-hex_]
266: SIU! [2-hex_]
267: SM0x [2-ui16] 8040 [.@]
268: SM0y [2-ui16] 7c00 [|.]
269: SM0z [2-ui16] 4b00 [K.]
270: SMBC [6-ch8*]
271: SMBG [1-ui8 ]
272: SMBR [32-ch8*]
273: SMBS [2-ch8*]
274: SMBW [32-ch8*]
275: SPH0 [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
276: SPHR [4-ui32] 00000000 [....]
277: SPHS [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
278: SPHT [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
279: SPHZ [1-ui8]
280: SPS! [4-hex_] 00000000 [....]
281: TB0T [2-sp78] 1f80 [..]
282: TB1T [2-sp78] 1d19 [..]
283: TB2T [2-sp78] 1f80 [..]
284: TC0D [2-sp78] 35e0 [5.]
285: TC0P [2-sp78] 2ca0 [,.]
286: TC0p [2-sp78] 2ca0 [,.]
287: TH0P [2-sp78] 2620 [& ]
288: TN0D [2-sp78] 3300 [3.]
289: TN0P [2-sp78] 2a80 [*.]
290: TN0S [2-sp78] 39c8 [9.]
291: TN1D [2-sp78] 3600 [6.]
292: TN1E [2-sp78] 3600 [6.]
293: TN1F [2-sp78]
294: TN1G [2-sp78] 5a00 [Z.]
295: TN1S [2-sp78] 39c8 [9.]
296: Th1H [2-sp78] 2aa0 [*.]
297: Th1h [2-sp78] 2aa0 [*.]
298: Ts0P [2-sp78] 1d30 [.0]
299: Ts0S [2-sp78] 24ef [$.]
300: Ts0p [2-sp78] 1d30 [.0]
301: UPRC [2-ui16] 0845 [.E]
302: VC0C [2-sp5a] 042d [.-]
303: VC0c [2-ui16] 4cc0 [L.]
304: VN0C [2-sp5a] 0459 [.Y]
305: VN0c [2-ui16] 54c0 [T.]
306: VP0R [2-sp5a] 321c [2.]
307: VP0r [2-ui16] a300 [..]
308: VZAP [2-sp5a] 8100 [..]
309: VZAp [2-ui16] 8100 [..]
310: VZBL [2-sp5a] 8100 [..]
311: VZBl [2-ui16] 8100 [..]
312: VZOD [2-sp5a] 8100 [..]
313: VZOd [2-ui16] 8100 [..]
314: WKEN [1-ui8] 00 [.]
315: zDBG [1-ui8] 00 [.]
316: zRDB [1-flag] 00 [.]

[kimptoc]

Hi,

Results for a MacBook Air 11", late 2010 model:

MacBookAir3,1

Attached are the applesmc and scan-smc results.

HTH,
Chris

[mayurdange]

Hi,
Thanks for all the work. This is from the latest version of applesmc on my 2010 Macbook.

sudo dmidecode -s system-product-name

MacBook 7,1

.................................................. .......

refer the attached module source code...
added details for macbook 7,1.
someone please submit patch/or tell me where to??

[andybotting]

Details of the MacBookPro8,2 machine attached

cheers

[onejdev]

hate to do this, but even after reading a lot of great info in this thread and applying what I thought would fix this, I am having some errors on an MacPro running Lucid. /var/log/messages is littered with the following errors:

applesmc: wait status failed: 5 != 0

I ran the applesmc-test.sh script and this is the result:


model: MacPro1,1

accelerometer: not present
fan: present, readable, output: 500
light: not present
leds: not present
temperatures: present,
temperature: not readable
temperature: readable, output: 50000
temperature: not readable
temperature: readable, output: 0
temperature: not readable
temperature: not readable
temperature: readable, output: 35000
temperature: readable, output: 35000
temperature: readable, output: 34000
temperature: readable, output: 32500
temperature: readable, output: 28000
temperature: readable, output: 50000
temperature: readable, output: 57500
temperature: readable, output: 58500
temperature: readable, output: 40000
temperature: readable, output: 66000
temperature: readable, output: 47000
temperature: readable, output: 68000
temperature: readable, output: 47000
temperature: readable, output: 65000
temperature: readable, output: 62000
temperature: not readable
temperature: readable, output: 40000
temperature: readable, output: 67000
temperature: readable, output: 47000
temperature: readable, output: 67000
temperature: readable, output: 67000
temperature: readable, output: 35500
temperature: readable, output: 31000
temperature: not readable
temperature: readable, output: 32000
temperature: readable, output: 49000
temperature: not readable
temperature: readable, output: 40000
temperature: readable, output: 0
performance: reading all temperatures
fail frequency: 1.000
reads per second: 3

smc-fan: Mt Sf type B


Here is the result of the scan-smc.sh script also


0: #KEY [4-ui32] 000000ff [....]
1: +LKS [1-flag] 07 [.]
2: ACID [8-ch8*] 0000000000000000 [........]
3: ALSC [16-{alc] 0192009608b00002000100640ed90000 [...........d....]
4: AUPO [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
5: BATP [1-flag] 00 [.]
6: BISE [1-ui8 ]
7: BNum [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
8: BRSC [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
9: CLK! [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
10: CLKC [10-{clc] 00000e1000000e10198c [..........]
11: CLKH [8-{clh] 0000000000000000 [........]
12: CLKS [2-fp1f] 8000 [..]
13: CLKT [4-ui32] 00013e65 [..>e]
14: CONT [4-ui32] 16001600 [....]
15: CRCB [4-ui32] c512fc40 [...@]
16: CRCU [4-ui32]
17: Dlpc [1-flag]
18: EPCF [1-flag] 01 [.]
19: EPCI [4-ui32] 00800700 [....]
20: EPCV [2-ui16] 0001 [..]
21: EPMA [4-ch8*] 0000e080 [....]
22: EPMI [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
23: EPUF [1-flag] 01 [.]
24: EPUI [4-ui32] 00800001 [....]
25: EPUV [2-ui16] 0001 [..]
26: EVCT [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
27: EVMD [4-ui32]
28: EVRD [32-ch8*] f6060300000124f0c101000001000f2b000000000000000000 00000000000000 [......$........+................]
29: F0Ac [2-fpe2] 07cd [..]
30: F0ID [16-{fds] 010001004350555f4d454d2000000000 [....CPU_MEM ....]
31: F0Mn [2-fpe2] 07d0 [..]
32: F0Mt [2-ui16] 01f4 [..]
33: F0Mx [2-fpe2] 2d50 [-P]
34: F0Sf [2-fpe2] 12c0 [..]
35: F0Tg [2-fpe2] 07d0 [..]
36: F1Ac [2-fpe2] 07d1 [..]
37: F1ID [16-{fds] 01010400494f20000000000000000000 [....IO .........]
38: F1Mn [2-fpe2] 07d0 [..]
39: F1Mt [2-ui16] 0252 [.R]
40: F1Mx [2-fpe2] 2d50 [-P]
41: F1Sf [2-fpe2] 12c0 [..]
42: F1Tg [2-fpe2] 07d0 [..]
43: F2Ac [2-fpe2] 095a [.Z]
44: F2ID [16-{fds] 01000d00455848415553542000000000 [....EXHAUST ....]
45: F2Mn [2-fpe2] 07d0 [..]
46: F2Mt [2-ui16] 0258 [.X]
47: F2Mx [2-fpe2] 2d50 [-P]
48: F2Sf [2-fpe2] 12c0 [..]
49: F2Tg [2-fpe2] 0960 [.`]
50: F3Ac [2-fpe2] 0b3c [.<]
51: F3ID [16-{fds] 01021000505320202000000000000000 [....PS .......]
52: F3Mn [2-fpe2] 0b40 [.@]
53: F3Mt [2-ui16] 035c [.\]
54: F3Mx [2-fpe2] 2bc0 [+.]
55: F3Sf [2-fpe2] 12c0 [..]
56: F3Tg [2-fpe2] 0b40 [.@]
57: FNum [1-ui8 ] 04 [.]
58: FPhz [2-i16 ]
59: FS! [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
60: HDBS [1-ui8 ] 01 [.]
61: HDST [4-ui16] 00000000 [....]
62: HDSW [4-ui32] 00000000 [....]
63: ICAC [2-fp88] 088a [..]
64: ICAc [2-ui16] 1900 [..]
65: ICBC [2-fp88] 092f [./]
66: ICBc [2-ui16] 1b00 [..]
67: IM1s [2-ui16] 2e80 [..]
68: IM2s [2-ui16] 2680 [&.]
69: IMAS [2-fp88] 0269 [.i]
70: IMBS [2-fp88] 01f8 [..]
71: IN0C [2-fp88] 0db9 [..]
72: IN0c [2-ui16] 7d40 [}@]
73: Ie1S [2-fp88] 009e [..]
74: Ie1s [2-ui16] 0c40 [.@]
75: Ie2S [2-fp88] 0010 [..]
76: Ie2s [2-ui16] 0100 [..]
77: Ie3S [2-fp88] 000d [..]
78: Ie3s [2-ui16] 0100 [..]
79: Ie4S [2-fp88] 0006 [..]
80: Ie4s [2-ui16] 0080 [..]
81: IeAS [2-fp88] 000d [..]
82: IeAs [2-ui16] 0100 [..]
83: IeBS [2-fp88] 0009 [..]
84: IeBs [2-ui16] 00c0 [..]
85: Ip0C [2-fp88] 0d78 [.x]
86: Ip0c [2-ui16] 035e [.^]
87: Jp0D [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
88: Jp0S [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
89: Jp0W [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
90: JpFE [1-flag] 01 [.]
91: LAcN [1-ui8 ]
92: LAtN [2-ui16]
93: LS! [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
94: LSCF [10-{lsc] 02ee0190800001020006 [..........]
95: LSDD [8-{lsd] 0002000300030019 [........]
96: LSDU [8-{lsd] 0003000200140003 [........]
97: LSFD [6-{lsf] 00000004001e [......]
98: LSFU [6-{lsf] 17700007003c [.p...<]
99: LSLB [2-{pwm] ffff [..]
100: LSLF [2-{pwm] 0000 [..]
101: LSLN [2-{pwm] 4e20 [N ]
102: LSOF [1-flag] 00 [.]
103: LSOO [1-flag]
104: LSPV [2-{pwm] 4e20 [N ]
105: LSRB [1-flag]
106: LSSB [2-{lso]
107: LSSE [1-flag] 01 [.]
108: LSSS [2-{lso]
109: LSSV [2-ui16] ffff [..]
110: LSUP [1-ui8 ]
111: MACA [4-ui32] 00000000 [....]
112: MACM [1-flag] 01 [.]
113: MACR [32-ch8*] 6368382a900124f0c101000001000f2b000000000000000000 00000000000000 [ch8*..$........+................]
114: MDE [2-ui16] 00ff [..]
115: MDLC [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
116: MDSS [1-ui8 ] 02 [.]
117: MOCF [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
118: MSAL [1-si8 ]
119: MSDW [1-flag]
120: MSLD [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
121: MSPS [1-{msp] 00 [.]
122: MSSD [1-si8 ] 03 [.]
123: MSSS [1-{mss] 00 [.]
124: MSTM [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
125: MSWR [1-ui8 ]
126: NATJ [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
127: NATi [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
128: NTOK [1-ui8 ]
129: NVPR [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
130: NVPW [1-ui8 ]
131: ONMI [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
132: OSK0 [32-ch8*] 6f757268617264776f726b62797468657365776f7264736775 6172646564706c [ourhardworkbythesewordsguardedpl]
133: OSK1 [32-ch8*] 65617365646f6e74737465616c2863294170706c65436f6d70 75746572496e63 [easedontsteal(c)AppleComputerInc]
134: PCAC [2-fp88] 100d [..]
135: PCBC [2-fp88] 0e55 [.U]
136: PMAS [2-fp88] 1c97 [..]
137: PMBS [2-fp88] 173b [.;]
138: PN0C [2-fp88] 1454 [.T]
139: Pe1S [2-fp88] 077c [.|]
140: Pe2S [2-fp88] 009a [..]
141: Pe3S [2-fp88] 009a [..]
142: Pe4S [2-fp88] 0047 [.G]
143: PeAS [2-fp88] 009a [..]
144: PeBS [2-fp88] 0047 [.G]
145: PeTS [2-ui16] 0009 [..]
146: Pp0C [2-fpc4] 0a2b [.+]
147: RBr [8-ch8*] 6d34330000000000 [m43.....]
148: REV [6-{rev] 01070f000008 [......]
149: RMde [1-byte] 41 [A]
150: RPS0 [8-{psh] 0c02060408ce0000 [........]
151: RPlt [8-ch8*] 6d34330000000000 [m43.....]
152: RSvn [4-ui32] 00002721 [..'!]
153: RVBF [6-{rev] 01070f000008 [......]
154: RVUF [6-{rev] 01070f000008 [......]
155: SAS! [4-ui32]
156: SBF [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
157: SDRd [2-ui16]
158: SIS! [2-ui16]
159: SIT! [2-ui16]
160: SIU! [2-ui16]
161: SIV! [2-ui16]
162: SIW! [2-ui16]
163: SPC0 [1-ui8] 04 [.]
164: SPC1 [1-ui8] 01 [.]
165: SPC2 [1-ui8] 00 [.]
166: SPH0 [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
167: SPH1 [2-ui16] 0000 [..]
168: SPHS [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
169: SPHT [1-ui8 ] 00 [.]
170: SPS! [2-ui16]
171: TA0P [2-sp78] 1c00 [..]
172: TC0C [2-sp78] 2f00 [/.]
173: TC0P [2-sp78] 2810 [(.]
174: TC1C [2-sp78] 0000 [..]
175: TC2C [2-sp78] 2f00 [/.]
176: TC3C [2-sp78] 0000 [..]
177: TCAH [2-sp78] 1f90 [..]
178: TCBH [2-sp78] 2090 [ .]
179: TH0P [2-sp78] 2320 [# ]
180: TH1P [2-sp78] 22e0 [".]
181: TH2P [2-sp78] 2220 [" ]
182: TH3P [2-sp78] 2080 [ .]
183: TM0P [2-sp78] 2900 [).]
184: TM0S [2-sp78] 4280 [B.]
185: TM1P [2-sp78] 2f00 [/.]
186: TM1S [2-sp78] 4500 [E.]
187: TM2P [2-sp78] 2f00 [/.]
188: TM2S [2-sp78] 4180 [A.]
189: TM3S [2-sp78] 3e00 [>.]
190: TM8P [2-sp78] 2800 [(.]
191: TM8S [2-sp78] 4300 [C.]
192: TM9P [2-sp78] 2f00 [/.]
193: TM9S [2-sp78] 4380 [C.]
194: TMAP [2-sp78] 3200 [2.]
195: TMAS [2-sp78] 3a00 [:.]
196: TMBS [2-sp78] 3a80 [:.]
197: TN0H [2-sp78] 4280 [B.]
198: TS0C [2-sp78] 2380 [#.]
199: Tp0C [2-sp78] 2f00 [/.]
200: Tp1C [2-sp78] 2b90 [+.]
201: Tv0S [2-sp78] 22b0 [".]
202: Tv1S [2-sp78] 2332 [#2]
203: VCAC [2-fp88] 013b [.;]
204: VCAc [2-ui16] 65c0 [e.]
205: VCBC [2-fp88] 013d [.=]
206: VCBc [2-ui16] 58c0 [X.]
207: VM0s [2-ui16] 02ac [..]
208: VM1s [2-ui16] 0198 [..]
209: VM2s [2-ui16] 02f4 [..]
210: VM3s [2-ui16] 0330 [.0]
211: VM4s [2-ui16] 02f8 [..]
212: VM8s [2-ui16] 02ac [..]
213: VM9s [2-ui16] 0198 [..]
214: VMAS [2-fp88] 0bdd [..]
215: VMAs [2-ui16] 02f4 [..]
216: VMBS [2-fp88] 0bcd [..]
217: VMBs [2-ui16] 0334 [.4]
218: VMCs [2-ui16] 02f4 [..]
219: VN0C [2-fp88] 017c [.|]
220: VS2c [2-ui16] 00c4 [..]
221: VS3c [2-ui16] 00bf [..]
222: VS4c [2-ui16] 00bd [..]
223: VS5c [2-ui16] 00bf [..]
224: VS6c [2-ui16] 00d3 [..]
225: VS7c [2-ui16] 00cb [..]
226: VS8c [2-ui16] 00bd [..]
227: VS9c [2-ui16] 00c4 [..]
228: VSAc [2-ui16] 0073 [.s]
229: VSBc [2-ui16] 00af [..]
230: VSCc [2-ui16] 00e9 [..]
231: VSDc [2-ui16] 00c9 [..]
232: VSEc [2-ui16] 00cb [..]
233: VSFc [2-ui16] 00bb [..]
234: VeES [2-fp88] 0be8 [..]
235: Vp0C [2-fp88] 0c12 [..]
236: Vp0c [2-ui16] 0c15 [..]
237: zDBG [1-ui8]
238: zSCI [1-ui8]
239: {clc [3-] 0001db [...]
240: {clf [3-] 0001e0 [...]
241: {clh [3-] 0001db [...]
242: {fds [3-] 0001db [...]
243: {lsc [3-] 0001dd [...]
244: {lsd [3-] 0001db [...]
245: {lsf [3-] 0001db [...]
246: {lsm [3-] 0001dd [...]
247: {lso [3-] 0001dd [...]
248: {lss [3-] 0001dd [...]
249: {msp [3-] 0001df [...]
250: {mss [3-] 0001df [...]
251: {psh [3-] 0001df [...]
252: {pwm [3-] 0001dc [...]
253: {rev [3-] 0001e0 [...]
254: {sds [3-] 0001db [...]


Any help anyone could offer would be greatly appreciated.

Still unanswered.

re-did the scan:


# dmidecode -s system-product-name

MacPro1,1




# ./applesmc-test.sh
model: MacPro1,1

accelerometer: not present
fan: present, readable, output: 500
light: not present
leds: not present
temperatures: present,
temperature: not readable
temperature: readable, output: 48000
temperature: not readable
temperature: readable, output: 0
temperature: not readable
temperature: not readable
temperature: readable, output: 33750
temperature: readable, output: 33750
temperature: readable, output: 33000
temperature: readable, output: 31250
temperature: readable, output: 27000
temperature: readable, output: 50000
temperature: readable, output: 58000
temperature: readable, output: 58500
temperature: readable, output: 39000
temperature: readable, output: 65000
temperature: readable, output: 46000
temperature: readable, output: 68000
temperature: readable, output: 46000
temperature: readable, output: 64500
temperature: readable, output: 61000
temperature: not readable
temperature: readable, output: 39000
temperature: readable, output: 66500
temperature: readable, output: 46000
temperature: readable, output: 67000
temperature: readable, output: 65500
temperature: readable, output: 34000
temperature: readable, output: 29750
temperature: not readable
temperature: readable, output: 31500
temperature: readable, output: 49000
temperature: not readable
temperature: readable, output: 38500
temperature: readable, output: 0
performance: reading all temperatures
fail frequency: 1.000
reads per second: 3

smc-fan: Mt Sf type B


any help on this would be very much appreciated.

[coolbeet]

Hi, I want get memory modules temperature, my machine is Apple Xserve with ubuntu 10.04, kernel 2.6.35-30-generic.

sudo dmidecode -s system-product-name

the system gave nothing, but if I use "sudo dmidecode",

# dmidecode 2.9
# No SMBIOS nor DMI entry point found, sorry.

./applesmc-test.sh
model:
accelerometer: not present
fan: not present
light: not present
leds: not present
temperatures: not present
performance: not performed

./applesmc-test.sh: line 128: cd: /sys/devices/platform/applesmc.768: No such file or directory
smc-fan: cat: key_count: No such file or directory

sudo ./scan-smc.sh
./scan-smc.sh: line 11: cd: /sys/devices/platform/applesmc.768/: No such file or directory
cat: key_count: No such file or directory
./scan-smc.sh: line 15: [: 0: unary operator expected

For "modprobe applesmc" && ,
FATAL: Error inserting applesmc (/lib/modules/2.6.35-30-generic/updates/dkms/applesmc.ko): No such device

Then for "dmesg | grep applesmc"
applesmc: supported laptop not found!
applesmc: driver init failed (ret=-19)!

Also, when I was installing the applesmc-dkms package, there are some kind of error message.

root@lake:/home/szhang# apt-get install applesmc-dkms
Reading package lists... Done
Building dependency tree
Reading state information... Done
The following NEW packages will be installed:
applesmc-dkms
0 upgraded, 1 newly installed, 0 to remove and 1 not upgraded.
Need to get 10.5kB of archives.
After this operation, 41.0kB of additional disk space will be used.
Get:1 http://ppa.launchpad.net/mactel-support/ppa/ubuntu/ maverick/main applesmc-dkms all 0.17.3-maverick-mactel1 [10.5kB]
Fetched 10.5kB in 0s (30.2kB/s)
Selecting previously deselected package applesmc-dkms.
(Reading database ... 46576 files and directories currently installed.)
Unpacking applesmc-dkms (from .../applesmc-dkms_0.17.3-maverick-mactel1_all.deb) ...
Setting up applesmc-dkms (0.17.3-maverick-mactel1) ...
Loading new applesmc-0.17.3 DKMS files...

Loading tarball for module: applesmc / version: 0.17.3

Loading /usr/src/applesmc-0.17.3...
Creating /var/lib/dkms/applesmc/0.17.3/source symlink...

DKMS: ldtarball Completed.
Installing prebuilt kernel module binaries (if any)
Building module...

Kernel preparation unnecessary for this kernel. Skipping...

Building module:
cleaning build area....
make KERNELRELEASE=2.6.35-30-generic -C /lib/modules/2.6.35-30-generic/build SUBDIRS=/var/lib/dkms/applesmc/0.17.3/build modules....
cleaning build area....

DKMS: build Completed.
Installing module...

applesmc.ko:
Running module version sanity check.
- Original module
- Installation
- Installing to /lib/modules/2.6.35-30-generic/updates/dkms/

depmod......

DKMS: install Completed.

Thank you so much~~~

[metatechbe]

Hi, I want get memory modules temperature, my machine is Apple Xserve with ubuntu 10.04, kernel 2.6.35-30-generic.

# dmidecode 2.9
# No SMBIOS nor DMI entry point found, sorry.


Hello,

Xserve machines do not have a BIOS compatibility layer.
Your machine must be be booted in EFI mode, hence the error.
You could try "fakebios" in grub.cfg if you are lucky.

[coolbeet]

Hello,

Xserve machines do not have a BIOS compatibility layer.
Your machine must be be booted in EFI mode, hence the error.
You could try "fakebios" in grub.cfg if you are lucky.

Hi, thanks for the information.

The machine does booted in EFI mode, and there are already "fakebios" in grub.cfg
.......
menuentry "Ubuntu System" {
fakebios
root=(hd0,8)
linux /vmlinuz root=/dev/sda8 ro vga=normal video=efifb
initrd /initrd.img
}
.......

Is there any other way to fix that? I really hate this Xserve:-(

Thank you so much~

[dfacto]

Ran the scan on the new 2011 MacBookAir4,2.

Please let me know what else is needed to get this fully supported!

[alexmurray]

Looks like it is already working from your output - what is in the directory /sys/devices/platform/applesmc.768/

[dfacto]

Looks like it is already working from your output - what is in the directory /sys/devices/platform/applesmc.768/

Hey thanks for getting back to me!

It may indeed be working. I am concerned that there was some issue since the fans seem to run all the time after installing macfantld. Prior to installing macfantld I felt like it ran a tad hot at times. Obviously these are subjective statements but still I want to be sure there are no troubles down the line (some scary posts about the dangers of running non-osx on the new MBA).

Cheers

[alexmurray]

Yep all the sensors are listed there so looks good for the new MB(A) models.

[dfacto]

Yep all the sensors are listed there so looks good for the new MB(A) models.

Good; thanks for confirming. This is my first mac so I was wondering if you knew if it is normal for macfanctld to run the fans all the time?

[alexmurray]

No idea, I don't use macfanctld on my MBP5,1 - it seems cool enough without it. Perhaps you could try resetting the SMC to see if that helps with cooling issues?