PDA

View Full Version : ATI X800 and cedega games slow/naff


wombat20
October 18th, 2005, 12:00 PM
Hi,

I've been using Ubuntu now for a few weeks and have got my ATI driver sorted finally (thanks mlomker!). Cedega (or P2play) reports that my system passes all tests and Direct Rendering is "Yes". So I figured I'd be ok to try some games.

Warcraft 3 - basically works, but is slow and jerky to the point of being unplayable - scrolling the screen with the mouse is uncontrollable. I guess it's doing about 2 fps, even on the lowest graphical settings.

HL2 - Steam was ok. Game seems fairly smooth, but many of the wall/floor textures are white and everything else is pretty jagged. Also, people talking seem to start their second sentence before finishing the first, so it overlaps. :mad:

Both of these run really nicely in WinXP on the same machine. I didn't even dare to try Planetside.

I read in the Cedega HowTo text file (which of course you download AFTER you've paid for it!) that ATI drivers may not work properly and performance/ stability is not guaranteed.

I've got a Radeon X800, 1G RAM, Athlon 64 (although running 5.10 i386). Surely these games should work better than this?

So do I...

1. Try harder, fiddle with the drivers, try different versions, read every forum out there about it and waste my life banging my head against the wall.
2. Sell my wretched ATI X800 on ebay and buy an nVidia one.
3. Just sigh and write off the $30ish I wasted for a year of Cedega and boot into Windows for games.

Unless anyone has any great suggestions I'm opting for 3 atm... :(

Artificial Intelligence
October 18th, 2005, 12:49 PM
Get a Nvidia card if I have to choose. It don't have to the most new fancy card, but one with reasonable performance and low prize. One like Gf4 ti4600 128 mb or something similar can do it.

Ensnared
October 18th, 2005, 02:39 PM
2. Sell my wretched ATI X800 on ebay and buy an nVidia one. That one.

Simply put, if you want a noteworthy performance when gaming on Linux (especially when using Cedega), ATI simply isn't the way to go. They're either incapable of, or not interested in, making good drivers for Linux (I think it's a little of both). And if people tell you "they've gotten better", don't listen to them. They've been "getting better" for a long time now, and it's still slow and bugged. Nvidia, however, works very well.

I've been using only ATI for almost 10 years, and will be switching to Nvidia first chance I get, and I won't be looking back. You should either do the same, or be prepared to keep dual-booting into Windows for playing games for the next few years ;)

jecos
October 18th, 2005, 03:00 PM
use -opengl command in cedega when running warcraft 3.
even with nvidia cards you still have to tweak cedega for each game...
check out the cedega wiki and cedega forums for extra help with tweaking games

ATI has been in the process of re-writing all the opengl code in their drivers, if you wanna go buy an nvidia b/c you think you can't run certain games that you must, then go do it. But seriously, All my games run fine with my 9800pro, doom3 runs very playable at 1024x768 on high, with the exception of GTA series and others that cedega doesnt support well themselves..
ATI are fixing opengl... so if your not a game addict then Stick with the card...

Zeroedout
October 19th, 2005, 05:22 AM
use -opengl command in cedega when running warcraft 3.
even with nvidia cards you still have to tweak cedega for each game...
check out the cedega wiki and cedega forums for extra help with tweaking games

ATI has been in the process of re-writing all the opengl code in their drivers, if you wanna go buy an nvidia b/c you think you can't run certain games that you must, then go do it. But seriously, All my games run fine with my 9800pro, doom3 runs very playable at 1024x768 on high, with the exception of GTA series and others that cedega doesnt support well themselves..
ATI are fixing opengl... so if your not a game addict then Stick with the card...

If i may ask, what are your specs? I have an 9800 as well, but I am on an amd 2500+, and doom3 is not playable by any definition what-so-ever (at 1024x768 anyway, 640x480 runs like a dream, but let's be honest, that's not a pleasent resolution). I have the latest drivers as well.

jecos
October 19th, 2005, 11:56 AM
If i may ask, what are your specs? I have an 9800 as well, but I am on an amd 2500+, and doom3 is not playable by any definition what-so-ever (at 1024x768 anyway, 640x480 runs like a dream, but let's be honest, that's not a pleasent resolution). I have the latest drivers as well.

A64 3200+ 1GB PC4000 200gig SATA drive and 9800pro....