PDA

View Full Version : Relating Launchpad Bugs and Forum Threads


Rocket2DMn
February 3rd, 2009, 10:42 PM
This thought crossed my mind this evening and I wanted to write it down before I forgot about it. I think the effort involved in getting this idea implemented is a bit much right now since it was require specialized development, but I was curious to see what people thought of it anyway :)

I thought it would be a cool little addition to the forums to have threads be able to recognize bug links either by parsing Launchpad bug URLs or simply detecting the use of the tags. It could then show at the top of the thread a list of bugs believed to be related to the thread based on what people have mentioned inside the thread. It could then provide a quick link to the LP bug report(s). If you really wanted to make it look nice, a little icon could appear in the forum page by the thread to show that there are bugs related to the thread (say, where it currently shows icons for Attachments, Tags, and Rated threads).

I think such an addition could be beneficial in the Testing and Discussion forum for the current Development release of Ubuntu, and could encourage users to be more active with bugs in other parts of these forums. Forum users are in a unique position to supply quality information to bug reports since this is where the beginners like to come, and their feedback is very important for development. The process could even work both ways and provide links to forum threads/posts on the appropriate Launchpad bug reports (assuming we could get LP devs involved).

Anyway, just a little idea I had that I didn't want to let pass without recording it . Cheers! :popcorn:

cariboo907
February 4th, 2009, 04:25 AM
I think that would be an excellent idea, I just spent 20 minutes on launchpad looking for a non-existent bug, that I thought I had filed.

Jim

drubin
February 4th, 2009, 12:10 PM
ye I think any thing that makes life easier... We just got the forums stable (I think). :) but I am sure it while be a while before it is implemented.

Rocket2DMn
February 4th, 2009, 08:39 PM
I think that would be an excellent idea, I just spent 20 minutes on launchpad looking for a non-existent bug, that I thought I had filed.

Jim

You should try clicking the Bugs tab from your LP profile page, then clicking "List reported bugs", then use the Advanced Search and select all the different options for Status. Then click search and it will show ALL bugs you have ever reported, including those that have been closed.
HTH

ye I think any thing that makes life easier... We just got the forums stable (I think). :) but I am sure it while be a while before it is implemented.

I think we are in a holding state right now while we wait for upgrades. After that time, it might be possible to make changes. I wouldn't bank on this suggestion I'm making though, it's more of a concept than a feasible idea at this point since it would require a lot of development and testing. :(

jpeddicord
February 4th, 2009, 10:27 PM
Sounds like something that a Greasemonkey script could do fairly easily, though it would probably only be able to show bug links for the current page.

jenkinbr
February 4th, 2009, 10:36 PM
Hmmm, Greasemonkey wouldn't place much, if any, extra load on the UF servers, either.

drubin
February 5th, 2009, 04:20 AM
Hmmm, Greasemonkey wouldn't place much, if any, extra load on the UF servers, either.

No load on the server :) runs client side